Fatal Nyghtmare please enlighten me by telling me what elite fighters has Pac-man beating in there prime? Jose Castillo 45-4-1 , Diego Corrales 33-0, Genaro Henanadez 38-1-1, and Ricky Hatton 43-0. Now that's Mayweather's list, I will be waiting on your list of already damaged punch drunk no defense having fighters that Manny keeps fighting..
Diego Corrales wasn't in his prime, having just been released from prison and complaining of flu like symptons BEFORE the fight.
Oscar De La Hoya wasn't in his prime, and many people think he could have earned a victory in that fight (not me, just saying).
Ricky Hatton was a perfect style for Floyd...straight ahead, no defense...but, wait...that's only a negative if Manny is fighting him, right?
Jose Luis Castillo BEAT Floyd in their first fight, IMO. Obviously, Floyd got the victory, but if you think Floyd won that fight, you're in the minority.
You keep mentioning Marquez, like anyone's going to forget that Marquez is a 130-135 lb fighter...who went up 12 lbs, to fight Floyd, who wouldn't even make weight...like that $600,000 he paid made up for the weight during the fight. LOL
Floyd is the "KING OF THE WORLD"...yet won't fight any top fighters in his OWN DIVISION.
So, if you want to question Manny's record, or Cotto's record...and diminish their resume...take a close look at who Floyd DIDN'T FIGHT. There's an even MORE IMPRESSIVE list than who he DID FIGHT.