Is Alex Smith (49ers Qb) a Bust?

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.
Q

Quick

Active member
#101
May 6, 2002
6,443
30
48
Yay Area, CA
#101
KOOL_AID said:
niner fans need to open up there eyes and see that yes for a first round pick he is a bust, if u pick a qb in the first round he needs to be ready right away and focus on the game right away and needs to know he will be playing by at least next season or sooner this has been alex smiths 3rd yr and he has improved but he is looking more like a second round pick and is not meeting expectations for a number 1 first round pick
Click to expand...
LMAO damn.....


Alex is only 23 years old. If he wasnt improving, you guys would have an arguement here
 
Rich

Rich

Sicc OG
#102
Jul 22, 2003
6,700
0
0
43
#102
RAS 925 said:
well if Josh McCown is playing better than him.. it wont be that hard for Russel to do!
Click to expand...
How is McCown playing better than Alex Smith? Cuz he played against the Lions in his first week? He only had 73 yards passing against Denver the 2nd week, and only 108 yards against the Browns.

The 49ers beat the Broncos in the last game of last season, Alex Smith had 194 passing yards.
 
Rich

Rich

Sicc OG
#103
Jul 22, 2003
6,700
0
0
43
#103
KOOL_AID said:
niner fans need to open up there eyes and see that yes for a first round pick he is a bust, if u pick a qb in the first round he needs to be ready right away and focus on the game right away and needs to know he will be playing by at least next season or sooner this has been alex smiths 3rd yr and he has improved but he is looking more like a second round pick and is not meeting expectations for a number 1 first round pick
Click to expand...
Then why isn't Russell ready right away??
 
KOOL_AID

KOOL_AID

Sicc OG
#104
Sep 26, 2005
1,595
0
0
39
#104
Quick said:
LMAO damn.....


Alex is only 23 years old. If he wasnt improving, you guys would have an arguement here
Click to expand...
why are u defending the fact that he is a bust? just look at the qb who yall played on sunday ben roethlisberger he's young 2 and already lead his team to win a superbowl, look at jay cutler he is what to expect with a first round pick look at vince young now look at alex smith u see how his name just doesnt fit in with the rest of all those????
 
RAS 925

RAS 925

Sicc OG
#105
Jan 4, 2003
4,549
5
0
#105
Rich said:
How is McCown playing better than Alex Smith? Cuz he played against the Lions in his first week? He only had 73 yards passing against Denver the 2nd week, and only 108 yards against the Browns.

The 49ers beat the Broncos in the last game of last season, Alex Smith had 194 passing yards.
Click to expand...
why even bring up last season!? but umm I'll be the first to say.. I want Culpepper to start for the Raiders.. but as far as statistics go I'm saying McCown is doin better than Smith.. from the yards to the TDS to the completion ratings
 
KOOL_AID

KOOL_AID

Sicc OG
#106
Sep 26, 2005
1,595
0
0
39
#106
Rich said:
Then why isn't Russell ready right away??
Click to expand...
this is what week 3? this aint his 3rd year its his 3rd week he missed preseason and he missed hella practices kiffin has said the reason why he is not ready is cuz he hasnt had enough time to get all the plays from the playbook down but that he is doin good but he wont start and why start him right away when we have qb's who have more experience right now who get the job done there is no reason why we need to rush him to get out on the field and im sure by the end of this season he will prove he is ready and he will start but come on week 3? and u want him to start lol
 
Q

Quick

Active member
#107
May 6, 2002
6,443
30
48
Yay Area, CA
#107
Besides Vince Young, look at how good the other teams are.

Alex Smith can still prove ya'll wrong. Im just saying I wouldnt call him a bust quite yet. But by your standards, J Russell is already a bust because he isnt ready to play right away being that he was the number one pick. See how smart you raider fans are......
 
KOOL_AID

KOOL_AID

Sicc OG
#110
Sep 26, 2005
1,595
0
0
39
#110
Quick said:
Besides Vince Young, look at how good the other teams are.

Alex Smith can still prove ya'll wrong. Im just saying I wouldnt call him a bust quite yet. But by your standards, J Russell is already a bust because he isnt ready to play right away being that he was the number one pick. See how smart you raider fans are......
Click to expand...
wtf are u talkin about? look how good the other teams are? the niners got a decent o line and good rb, smith just cant make good decisions like i said he is doin better but still for a first round pick he is a bust and lmao at russell bein a bust like i said its his 3rd week not 3rd year
 
AleX510

AleX510

Sicc OG
#111
Jun 11, 2007
1,148
4
0
36
#111
@ Quick He wasn't signed until Week 2 of the Regular season. Maybe if he was in training camp and pre season and outperforming other QB's he'd be the starter right now. Russell will start the last few games of this season and will be the starter next year.
 
Rich

Rich

Sicc OG
#112
Jul 22, 2003
6,700
0
0
43
#112
KOOL_AID said:
why are u defending the fact that he is a bust? just look at the qb who yall played on sunday ben roethlisberger he's young 2 and already lead his team to win a superbowl, look at jay cutler he is what to expect with a first round pick look at vince young now look at alex smith u see how his name just doesnt fit in with the rest of all those????
Click to expand...
Alex Smith was the best QB in that draft. There were only 3 QBs drafted in the 1st round, Smith #1, Aaron Rodgers #24, Jason Campbell #25.
 
Q

Quick

Active member
#113
May 6, 2002
6,443
30
48
Yay Area, CA
#113
KOOL_AID said:
wtf are u talkin about? look how good the other teams are? the niners got a decent o line and good rb, smith just cant make good decisions like i said he is doin better but still for a first round pick he is a bust and lmao at russell bein a bust like i said its his 3rd week not 3rd year
Click to expand...
By what you said

OOL_AID said:
yes for a first round pick he is a bust, if u pick a qb in the first round he needs to be ready right away
Click to expand...
= J Russell to be a bust. He should be ready to play because he was the number one pick. You said that.
 
Rich

Rich

Sicc OG
#114
Jul 22, 2003
6,700
0
0
43
#114
KOOL_AID said:
wtf are u talkin about? look how good the other teams are? the niners got a decent o line and good rb, smith just cant make good decisions like i said he is doin better but still for a first round pick he is a bust and lmao at russell bein a bust like i said its his 3rd week not 3rd year
Click to expand...
decent oline? Have you been watching the 9ers games? Gore hasn't even touched 100 yards yet. You just said it yourself a #1 pick QB should be ready.
 
Q

Quick

Active member
#115
May 6, 2002
6,443
30
48
Yay Area, CA
#115
AleX510 said:
@ Quick He wasn't signed until Week 2 of the Regular season. Maybe if he was in training camp and pre season and outperforming other QB's he'd be the starter right now. Russell will start the last few games of this season and will be the starter next year.
Click to expand...
And truthfully he shouldnt even play this year. I was juist going by what he said. J Russell is not a bust yet......
 
Rich

Rich

Sicc OG
#116
Jul 22, 2003
6,700
0
0
43
#116
KOOL_AID said:
wtf are u talkin about? look how good the other teams are? the niners got a decent o line and good rb, smith just cant make good decisions like i said he is doin better but still for a first round pick he is a bust and lmao at russell bein a bust like i said its his 3rd week not 3rd year
Click to expand...
All those other guys you mentioned are in the AFC.
 
KOOL_AID

KOOL_AID

Sicc OG
#117
Sep 26, 2005
1,595
0
0
39
#117
Quick said:
I mean he gets a pass because of the raider uniform. Fuck an excuse
Click to expand...
yea he should be ready right away what if culpepper and mccown get injured there is no excuse, i agree he should have signed before preseason to be able to get playing time in the preseason and have more time practicing
 
Q

Quick

Active member
#118
May 6, 2002
6,443
30
48
Yay Area, CA
#118
Rich said:
Alex Smith was the best QB in that draft. There were only 3 QBs drafted in the 1st round, Smith #1, Aaron Rodgers #24, Jason Campbell #25.
Click to expand...
Niner should have picked Braylon Edwards that year and got Young or Leinart the next year. Thats what I said before the 05 draft but what can you do......
 
DubbC415

DubbC415

Mickey Fallon
#119
Sep 10, 2002
22,620
6,984
0
38
Tomato Alley
#119
The whole offense lacks confidence. I think we know what the niners are capable of when theyre firing on all cylinders. im frustrated too, they need to pick it up if theyre going to compete. When the o line is at its best, and gore gets up there, Smith will gain confidence and his numbers will pick up. its only week 4, we got a ways to go.
 
KOOL_AID

KOOL_AID

Sicc OG
#120
Sep 26, 2005
1,595
0
0
39
#120
Quick said:
And truthfully he shouldnt even play this year. I was juist going by what he said. J Russell is not a bust yet......
Click to expand...
he cant be a bust yet he hasnt even played a game lol but i dont know if kiffin sees that he is getting better by mid season fuck it they should try him out
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom