Is Alex Smith (49ers Qb) a Bust?
- Thread starter Tony
- Start date
lmao i didnt say that i said any qb should be ready to play right away just look at the qb the bucs used last season fool got drafted in the 7th round and had to play the rest of the season cuz of an injury sims had
the reason why i called alex smith a bust is because he is not meeting expectations for a 1st round pick in his third year
so no there was no contradiction u just read it a lil wrong
the reason why i called alex smith a bust is because he is not meeting expectations for a 1st round pick in his third year
so no there was no contradiction u just read it a lil wrong
no i did say that here read it all
Originally Posted by KOOL_AID
niner fans need to open up there eyes and see that yes for a first round pick he is a bust, if u pick a qb in the first round he needs to be ready right away and focus on the game right away and needs to know he will be playing by at least next season or sooner this has been alex smiths 3rd yr and he has improved but he is looking more like a second round pick and is not meeting expectations for a number 1 first round pick
now tell me where it is in there that i said the reason why i said alex smith was a bust was because he wasnt ready his first year
here maybe i need to break it up for u in order for ur lil niner fan brain to understand
Originally Posted by KOOL_AID
niner fans need to open up there eyes and see that yes for a first round pick he is a bust, if u pick a qb in the first round he needs to be ready right away and focus on the game right away and needs to know he will be playing by at least next season or sooner.
in this part i am talkin about how first round qbs need to be ready right away
this has been alex smiths 3rd yr and he has improved but he is looking more like a second round pick and is not meeting expectations for a number 1 first round pick
this is the reason why he is a bust
if u cant understand that then ur just retarded
Originally Posted by KOOL_AID
niner fans need to open up there eyes and see that yes for a first round pick he is a bust, if u pick a qb in the first round he needs to be ready right away and focus on the game right away and needs to know he will be playing by at least next season or sooner this has been alex smiths 3rd yr and he has improved but he is looking more like a second round pick and is not meeting expectations for a number 1 first round pick
now tell me where it is in there that i said the reason why i said alex smith was a bust was because he wasnt ready his first year
here maybe i need to break it up for u in order for ur lil niner fan brain to understand
Originally Posted by KOOL_AID
niner fans need to open up there eyes and see that yes for a first round pick he is a bust, if u pick a qb in the first round he needs to be ready right away and focus on the game right away and needs to know he will be playing by at least next season or sooner.
in this part i am talkin about how first round qbs need to be ready right away
this has been alex smiths 3rd yr and he has improved but he is looking more like a second round pick and is not meeting expectations for a number 1 first round pick
this is the reason why he is a bust
if u cant understand that then ur just retarded
Hands down Smith will be weak!! 2ndly Russell will be a star mark my words!! 3rdly Russell was good in college fool!! Do yall watch college!! Sometimes college is all about hype!! Russell was dope at LSU and shitted on Quinn in their bcs bowl game!! QB's arent drafted outta collge based on there stats in college fully!! look at Jason White of Oklahome who was a stud college qb but wasnt even drafted or drafted hella late better never made it!! Yall need to get knowledge of the game. Russell has superstardom written all over him!! I dont like Quinn either!! Well see in due time but yall will see what im sayin!! Got Em!!
Some of your info is wrong...but I definitely won’t argue that Butch fucked them up…but my point is…excuses only last for so long.
Excuses for Couch (I made them too) were expansion team, no O-Line, no RB, no good receivers…new coach…changing offensive coordinators. And they are all good reasons why a QB will not succeed. But when you go in the first round…especially being the No. 1 pick…you expect more. And when you don’t see those results…you finally begin to see the flaws that your homer-glasses were blinding you from.
Couch was a good QB…even took the Browns to the playoffs…but he wasn’t consistant. He flat out didn’t have what it takes.
Smith is in a very similar situation…this is the year that people are expecting big things from him. So far, he hasn’t shown much. But it’s early…we’ll see what happens.
Excuses for Couch (I made them too) were expansion team, no O-Line, no RB, no good receivers…new coach…changing offensive coordinators. And they are all good reasons why a QB will not succeed. But when you go in the first round…especially being the No. 1 pick…you expect more. And when you don’t see those results…you finally begin to see the flaws that your homer-glasses were blinding you from.
Couch was a good QB…even took the Browns to the playoffs…but he wasn’t consistant. He flat out didn’t have what it takes.
Smith is in a very similar situation…this is the year that people are expecting big things from him. So far, he hasn’t shown much. But it’s early…we’ll see what happens.
How can he apply the samething to JaMarcus Russell when JaMarcus wasn't even signed until week 2 of the regular season?
Alex Smith was signed right after he was drafted. He played in pre-season and couldn't even beat out Rattay. LOL
KOOL_AID is just saying when you're drafted number 1 overall you gotta be ready to contribute right away (assuming you got your contract situation out of the way)
This is Alex Smith's 3rd year and so far he's not looking like he was picked number one overall.
Eli Manning, Carson Palmer, Jay Cutler, even Vince Young are all playing better than Smith right now.
Alex Smith was signed right after he was drafted. He played in pre-season and couldn't even beat out Rattay. LOL
KOOL_AID is just saying when you're drafted number 1 overall you gotta be ready to contribute right away (assuming you got your contract situation out of the way)
This is Alex Smith's 3rd year and so far he's not looking like he was picked number one overall.
Eli Manning, Carson Palmer, Jay Cutler, even Vince Young are all playing better than Smith right now.
if u cant understand any of that then damn there is no hope for u, keep thinking that alex smith is a good qb and that he is meeting expectations for a first round pick i dont know why its so hard for u to understand the fact he is a bust and i really dont care, u can really tell u dont know much about football im done tryin to explain to u its useless
