Floyd Mayweather Jr - He Does Right By Boxing
By Jake Donovan
Perhaps your stance is that he retired at the right time – on top, with his faculties still intact and bank account stuffed to the gills. Maybe you’re among those disappointed that he leaves the game without defending his linear crown against the world’s best welterweights. Or maybe, you don’t believe that he’s done for good, that the right fight - and more specifically, the right price to go along with it – lures him back into the ring.
Regardless of your stance, there’s no denying that Floyd Mayweather Jr’s sudden retirement announcement comes at a perfect time for the welterweight division and boxing as a whole.
The news came about early Friday afternoon, preceding an already active boxing weekend that included two major fight cards and the annual Hall of Fame inductions in Canastota. Yet with so much going in on the sport, the major talk surrounded Money May, who hasn’t fought since last December and quite possibly will never fight again.
Should Mayweather decide to make it stick, his departure leaves vacancies galore. A new opponent is now needed for Oscar de la Hoya’s reserved September 20 PPV date. A new name will now appear atop the pound for pound rankings. Hopefully, a new welterweight champion can be crowned in the near future.
Most of the voids are easy to fill. There’s certainly no shortage of fighters willing to face the Golden Boy, and the golden payday that comes with it. Pound-for-pound? When number one loses, looks really bad or, in this case, retires, someone’s always automatically inserted into the top spot. Manny Pacquiao and Joe Calzaghe are already waiting in the wings, even already at the top on some lists.
The gaping hole atop the welterweight division will be the most difficult to produce in a timely fashion. Not because Mayweather is irreplaceable or that he enjoyed a linear title reign of legendary proportions, at least beyond the amount of money he collected while king. It’s because crowning a linear champion requires more than simply calling up a pinch hitter, or advancing the next highest ranked fighter by default.
The good news, though, is that a fight can be made to crown a new champion, something that wasn’t the case while Mayweather ruled the division. His lopsided title win over Carlos Baldomir in November 2006 was Mayweather’s only fight during his reign against an actual welterweight. His lone defense came last December, when he scored a 10th round knockout over Ricky Hatton, who was undefeated and coming up from junior welterweight for an event that drew 850,000 PPV buys in the states and turned Las Vegas into Little Manchester during fight week.
The win over Baldomir made Mayweather a legitimate world linear champion in three divisions - 130, 135 and 147 – while also collecting alphabet titles at 140 and 154. His fifth divisional title came in a win over Oscar de la Hoya last May in the most lucrative event in boxing history, drawing 2.4 million PPV buys, exceeding $130 million in TV revenue and a $19 million live gate.
Money aside, it was during his days in the lower weight classes where Mayweather provided his best body of work, even if to a much smaller audience than he’s enjoyed in recent years. A precocious junior lightweight, Mayweather picked up his first world title just 18 fights and less than two years into his pro career, dominating two-time titlist Genaro Hernandez before forcing him to quit on his stool after eight rounds.
A three-year reign was accentuated by his coming out party in January 2001, when he scored five knockdowns en route to a 10th round stoppage over Diego Corrales when both were undefeated and the best junior lightweights in the world. The win confirmed Mayweather’s status among the game’s very best, remaining a fixture at or near the top of most pound for pound rankings for the entire decade.
A closer-than-expected win in his first fight against Jose Luis Castillo was one of the few occasions where Mayweather was pushed to the limit in a fight of any kind. That the scores were so wide (Mayweather winning 8-9 rounds on all three cards in a fight many had him only winning anywhere from 5-7) bothered fans more so than his actually winning the fight.
But win he did throughout his 11 year career, scoring 39 wins, including 25 “by way of.” Even the most ardent haters can only come with two fights to argue about the final outcome – the first Castillo fight and the de la Hoya event last year. Both were examples of the subjectivity of scoring a prize fight, whether you prefer clean punching or aggression and the perception of the other fighter through the more telling punches.
The one common argument that surrounded his career from 140 on up was whether or not he any longer desired to test himself against the very best. A six-round bludgeoning of Arturo Gatti in June 2005 collected Mayweather a title in his third division, though at a time when Ricky Hatton was the division’s true champ, by virtue of a stoppage win over longtime junior welterweight kingpin Kostya Tszyu earlier in the month.
A Mayweather-Hatton bout would come about, only 2 ½ years later after the fact and one weight class up. A more objective view would reveal Hatton’s reluctance to sign on as the real reason the fight didn’t happen any sooner, but Floyd’s incredible self-confidence brought about disdain (and perhaps jealously) from enough fans to hold the superstar responsible for just about any major fight that didn’t come about.
The same could’ve also been said for a Mayweather-Cotto fight, a matchup Floyd personally asked for the moment he beat Gatti into submission. Cotto was in attendance that night, but questions about such a fight materializing was met with a response of “12-18 months away” from Top Rank regarding how long before the Puerto Rican would be ready for such a fight.
Already a troubled relationship, their inability to see eye to eye on the direction in which his career should go lead to the beginning of the end between Mayweather and Top Rank. Mayweather only wanted fights that would maximize his marketability, while promoter hoped to put in their star pupil with Antonio Margarito, a tough welterweight but not the type of draw that would further advance Mayweather’s star status, or so he believed.
The two split in November 2005 for one fight before hooking up in April 2006 for a fight with Zab Judah. Mayweather carried on the PPV on his own, largely due to Judah’s unwillingness to participate in the promotional end of the bout. That he won the bout, almost marred by controversy following a mini-riot at the end of the 10th round, made the financial success of the event that much sweeter. A final tally of 375,000 buys confirmed Mayweather’s star status, especially considering that Judah was coming off of a loss.
However, when the next step was discussed, it was Margarito’s name that resurfaced. Mayweather decided enough was enough, and eventually bought out the remainder of his contract with Top Rank. A one-fight deal with Goossen-Tutor Promotions led to an $8 million payday - $8,000,001 to be exact, barely exceeding the amount offered by Top Rank for a Margarito fight – and winning the linear welterweight crown with the Baldomir fight.
Mayweather showed signs of growing frustrated with the sport, announcing his retirement at the post-fight presser. Few believed it would stick, and proved to be right after Floyd accepted the de la Hoya assignment. The actual fight itself was anything but memorable, but the buildup to the event far exceeded any other in recent boxing history.
A cross-country tour was followed by the launching of HBO’s award-winning “24/7” series, a four-part documentary giving viewers an inside view of the training camps and – to a limit – the personal lives of the two fighters. It was such a success that the network brought back the series – and Mayweather – for the December event with Hatton.
The 850,000 PPV buys in that fight brought Mayweather’s 2007 tally to over 3 million, and the fighter himself earning upwards of $50 million on the strength of two events.
Still, being the best fighter in the world, as well as the best-known active fighter, came with a heavy price. Earning your way to the top is one thing; maintaining your ranking is another. When talks surfaced of a long rest followed by possible rematches with de la Hoya and Hatton, fans and critics vehemently spoke out, feeling that, as welterweight champion, it was his obligation to defend against the best of his division.
One name in particular was repeatedly mentioned – Miguel Cotto, who was taking on top contenders from the moment he arrived in the division in late 2006. The one exception came in his last fight, a 5-round destruction of overmatched Alfonso Gomez, though a tune-up for a summer showdown with Margarito.
Mayweather wasn’t biting, though. While acknowledging Cotto’s status as a top welterweight, Team Money May insisted that the Puerto Rican’s star was merely on the rise, and not to where the two would make history should they finally meet in the ring.
It now looks as if we’ll never find out, if in fact Mayweather sticks to his guns and forever remains on the sidelines. Only now, the rest of the division can move on, rather than continue to fight each other while its champion holds the title hostage.
With Cotto set to fight Margarito next month and Paul Williams – who defeated Margarito last summer – gaining revenge in emphatic fashion against prior conqueror Carlos Quintana this past weekend, there’s a direct path to the matchup that will produce the next linear welterweight champion.
Mayweather’s departure also puts promising young undefeated contender Andre Berto one step closer to his first alphabet title, and the rest of the division in position to one day soon challenge for the top spot
The more favorable scenario would have Mayweather taking on all comers and defending his reign with an iron fist (or at least a pair of Winning gloves). But stepping away from the game at this time is the next best thing. If Floyd no longer possesses the desire to face the very best, or even climb through the ropes for more money than the combined purses of any three fighters not named Oscar de la Hoya, then he’s getting out of the game at the right time.
Fans may seek the boxing version of James Dean, for its participants to live fast and leave a good looking corpse. Instead, Mayweather lived and played by his own rules, and from it carved out a Hall of Fame career – unanimous vote, first ballot - and collected enough ends to where many generations of his family are financially set for life.
Rather than complain about what could’ve been, boxing fans will now get to enjoy what will become. With the welterweight division thriving and the sport in need of developing new stars rather than always default to the names of old, Floyd Mayweather Jr’s retirement indirectly gives back to the sport, a feat of which he’s been accused for years of neglecting to perform.
With his departure, Floyd Mayweather Jr does right by boxing.