The Best Weight Division in Boxing - Part Two
By Cliff Rold
Yesterday, a four-way debate looked to be turning out about as expected. The first part of an analysis looking at arguably the four best weight divisions in Boxing, from Champions to the number 5 spot, showed Welterweight to certainly be the strongest top half of any division in the sport. That’s only half of the test; depth in a division happens in the fielding of a solid top ten. Does Welterweight pass that test as well? For those who missed it, Part I can be found at
http://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=14191
Through that first part, the results for each division stand at:
Welterweight – 12 points
Jr. Bantamweight – 14 points
Lightweight – 16 points
Middleweight – 18 points
All of which dovetails into…
#6
Welterweight: Paul Williams (33-1, 24 KO)
Lightweight: Jose Armando Santa Cruz (25-3, 14 KO)
Jr. Bantamweight: Nobuo Nashiro (11-1, 7 KO)
Middleweight: Javier Castillejo (62-8, 42 KO)
Once again, Welterweights lead the pack but not necessarily by much. Williams was celebrated as the next big thing at 147 and may well turn out to be but first he has to avenge a loss to Carlos Quintana (#2) a little over one week from now. One loss doesn’t discount the work he got done last August against Antonio Margarito (#4) and, who knows, by the end of the years Williams-Margarito II could replace Cotto-Mayweather as the must-see fight in class. Santa Cruz hasn’t been all that visible since getting robbed against Lightweight champ Joel Casamayor last November, but his effort isn’t forgotten nor is the wide lead he held on the cards against David Diaz before being stopped late. Nashiro may yet develop into an elite fighter, but the possibility that his 2006 win against Castillo was as much timing as talent must be considered. Nearing 40, Castillejo has had a fine career, capturing titles at 154 and 160 lbs. but his recent stoppage loss to Sebastian Sylvester (#5) seems to signal the end of the road.
#7
Welterweight: Andre Berto (21-0, 18 KO)
Middleweight: John Duddy (23-0, 17 KO)
Lightweight: Yuri Romanov (20-2, 13 KO)
Jr. Bantamweight: Jorge Arce (49-4-1, 37 KO)
The seven spot isn’t the strongest spot in any division’s ratings, at least not yet. However, each of the first three listed are intriguing if flawed prospects. Berto hasn’t faced a serious top ten challenge yet but has the best athletic tools of this bunch and has faced solid veterans like David Estrada and Cosme Rivera. The only downside is that his chin, and stiff lack of head movement, look like a liability. Duddy is also vulnerable…to cuts, speed and probably anyone near the top at Middleweight in general. In his favor though is a bucket of guts and a win against tested veteran Howard Eastman. Romanov is coming along nicely but a loss to the chinny Graham Earl leaves a question mark and Arce, while still a great attraction among the little guys, looks about a bullet short of shot in the last year, including getting blanked by Cristian Mijares (#1).
#8
Jr. Bantamweight: Z Gorres (27-2-2, 15 KO)
Welterweight: Luis Collazo (28-3, 13 KO)
Lightweight: Amir Khan (17-0, 13 KO)
Middleweight: Giovanni Lorenzo (26-0, 18 KO)
Gorres is a tricky fighter, having taken Fernando Montiel (#2) and Vic Darchinyan (#5) to the wall while falling a hair short is a loss and draw. Only 26, stoppage wins over former titlist Eric Ortiz and Glenn Donaire both point to a fighter whose best may be yet to come. Collazo has his backers in the “who won the Ricky Hatton fight” debate but there was no debate about the one-sided nature of a loss to Shane Mosley (#3). Khan and Lorenzo are both undefeated potential future stars in their divisions, but of the two it is Khan who has been the more tested and who shows the better overall game.
#9
Welterweight: Joshua Clottey (34-2, 19 KO)
Middleweight: Randy Griffin (24-1-3, 12 KO)
Jr. Bantamweight: Kohei Kono (21-3, 7 KO)
Lightweight: Kid Diamond (25-1-1, 14 KO)
Clottey will have his shot at Zab Judah (#10 for the IBF bout this summer and he’ll be a strong dark horse pick. In December of 2006, he gave Margarito hell and he ended the career of the late Diego Corrales in a rough fight. Griffin doesn’t have a particularly deep resume, but his draw with Felix Sturm (#3) last October was an excellent account; he has the chance to go all the way and capture the WBA belt in a rematch in July. Kono is an all-Asian regional product whose opposition has been soft but it trumps a Diamond who looked just about ready for new employment in lucking out a bad decision win against Miguel Huerta in June 2007. He hasn’t fought since.
#10
Welterweight: Zab Judah (36-5, 25 KO)
Lightweight: Michael Katsidis (23-1, 20 KO)
Jr. Bantamweight: AJ Banal (17-0-1, 14 KO)
Middleweight: Amin Asikainen (24-1, 16 KO)
And finally we hit the bottom of the tens with some solid talent spread all around. Judah is a former World champion at 147 but suffers from big losses to Cotto (#1) and the current champ Mayweather. A loss to Clottey could be all she wrote for Zab. Katsidis can’t be knocked too much for a thrilling loss to the best Casamayor on display in years and holds an edge over a Banal simply by that competitive level. Banal though can not be discounted; expect him to be a major player soon based on the form he showed in stopping fellow undefeated Caril Herrera in his last outing. Asikainen rounds out the bottom, a one-big-win fighter who stopped Sylvester in their first 2006 outing only to have the favor returned in a rematch last year. His last bout came against the ancient Yori Boy Campas.
Having worked through the ratings, the results come out about as expected, with Welterweight the clear leader of the sport by final tallies of:
Welterweight: 18 pts.
Jr. Bantamweight: 28 pts.
Lightweight: 29 pts.
Middleweight: 32 pts.
That all could change is short order. Not rated because they have not yet arrived, Jr. Lightweight titans Manny Pacquiao and Juan Manuel Marquez are on their way to Lightweight and when they get there they’ll shake up not only debates about the best division in Boxing but the sport itself, adding two serious pound for pound players in a division currently without them. Conversely, Jr. Bantamweight’s hopes to further improve rely on a Mijares-Montiel fight that is far from guaranteed.
This doesn’t even factor in the strength at Light Heavyweight, Super Middleweight and Flyweight. Point being? For all those who shoo Boxing as less talented than in days past, all of these divisions point to a vibrant sport. Sure, maybe there’s no Robinson’s or Pep’s, but there was only ever one of each anyways.
For now, the obvious stands out as the tested and true…Welterweight is the best division in Boxing but there’s plenty of competition to go around