The Best Weight Division in Boxing - Part One
By Cliff Rold
Welterweight.
That seems to be the unanimous answer these days when anyone asks about the best division in Boxing. It’s a powerful argument. Is it the truth? After all, with seventeen weight divisions, there’s plenty of talent to go around and divisions are more than just the names at the top. Looking top to bottom, there are a few divisions that give Welterweight a run for its money.
In examining the most recent BoxingScene divisional ratings (
http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/view.php?pg=boxing-ratings), there emerge three weight divisions right now that have the combination of talent, momentum and matches to compete with Welterweight claim. What happens when each division is laid side by side, fighter for fighter, pound for pound?
This two-part analysis will look at what might be Boxing’s four best weight divisions, Welterweight, Middleweight, Lightweight and Jr. Bantamweight, all of which are off to a great start in 2008, all of which have strong casts of characters. Each position examined will list the fighters considered in order of where they place in a four-way dance with a corresponding point assigned (1-4) for each, lowest score to be crowned…
“The Best Division in Boxing!” Pretty dramatic, huh?
World Champions
Welterweight: Floyd Mayweather (39-0, 25 KO, Lineal/Ring/WBC)
Middleweight: Kelly Pavlik (33-0, 29 KO, Lineal/Ring/WBC/WBO)
Lightweight: Joel Casamayor (36-3-1, 22 KO, Lineal/Ring/WBO Interim)
Jr. Bantamweight: Vacant
Mayweather has yet to defend his title against a Welterweight. That said, he does have wins over former champions Zab Judah (currently #10) and Carlos Baldomir at the weight, and defending decisively against the reigning World Jr. Welterweight champ Ricky Hatton is his last outing is impressive as well. Casamayor looked good in March against Michael Katsidis (#10) but should have lost the decision last November to Jose Armando Santa Cruz (#6). There are also strong arguments against recognizing him, or anyone really, as the Lightweight champion today. Hopefully, a Casamayor-Nate Campbell fight will end the argument. That there is an argument is why Pavlik, who makes his first defense this June in a standard issue questionable mandatory, edges past the Cuban stalwart. There was no denying that he beat Jermain Taylor (#4) both times, and at two different weights.
#1 Contenders
Welterweight: Miguel Cotto (32-0, 26 KO, WBA)
Jr. Bantamweight: Cristian Mijares (35-3-2, 14 KO, WBC/WBA)
Lightweight: Nate Campbell (32-5-1, 25 KO, WBA/IBF/WBO)
Middleweight: Arthur Abraham (25-0, 20 KO, IBF)
The first two fighters listed above are current fixtures on just about every sensible pound-for-pound list but Cotto gets the edge. Cotto has been an absolute beast since rising from 140 to 147 lbs. with wins over Carlos Quintana (#2), Shane Mosley (#4) and Judah. His next assignment is Antonio Margarito (#3) and that sort of matchmaking doesn’t go unnoticed. Mijares is on quite a tear himself and might be the most talented of this crop but his resume lags just a step behind. With a recent unification win over Alexander Munoz (#3), a 2007 win over Jorge Arce (#7) and other notable victories like Katsushige Kawashima and Jose Navarro, he can gain on Cotto faster than anyone. Campbell is an internet darling of late and a damn fun fighter to watch, but his career has been streaky. He gets big credit for wins over Juan Diaz (#2) and Kid Diamond (#9) and his listing in third here is more a credit to the others above than a knock on Campbell. Abraham is a bruising, hammer-fisted puncher who suffered a terrible broken jaw in defeating Edison Miranda in 2006 and will fight him again anyways in June. Win and he’s on the road to Pavlik in one of the best action fights that can be made in the whole sport.
#2
Jr. Bantamweight: Fernando Montiel (36-2-1, 27 KO, WBO)
Lightweight: Juan Diaz (33-1, 17 KO)
Middleweight: Felix Sturm (29-2-1, 13 KO, WBA)
Welterweight: Carlos Quintana (25-1, 19 KO, WBO)
Montiel may be on the best run of his career. He retired long-time division stalwart Martin Castillo in February and outpointed Z Gorres (#8) on Gorres' Phillipines turf in 2007. A multi-knockdown war with Luis Melendez was icing on the cake between. Diaz may have lost to Campbell in his last bout, but that doesn’t erase the tear he was on before or that fact that, barely in his mid-20s, his best work may yet lie ahead. Strum did continue his career after the 2004 fight with Oscar De La Hoya even if few in America have seen it. Javier Castillejo (#6) provided him his first real loss, but he avenged it and is on the road to a July rematch of an entertaining draw with Randy Griffin (#9). Carlos Quintana is a one notable win (Paul Williams - #6), one bad loss (Cotto) guy who we’ll all have a better idea of after his June rematch with Williams.
#3
Welterweight: Antonio Margarito (36-5, 26 KO, IBF)
Jr. Bantamweight: Alexander Munoz (32-2, 27 KO, WBA)
Lightweight: David Diaz (33-1-1, 17 KO, WBC)
Middleweight: Jermain Taylor (27-1-1, 17 KO)
Margarito rates highest here because of his willingness to continually face top fighters in his class. Cotto is next, a compliment to the two wins over Kermit Cintron (#5) and rugged decision over Joshua Clottey (#9) and narrow loss to Williams. Munoz as well has made a habit of fighting his divison’s best. That didn’t work out well for him against Mijares a couple weeks ago, but he more than held his own in a narrow rematch loss to Martin Castillo, and decision wins over Kawashima and Nobuo Nashiro (#6). Diaz is a solid fighter, but not particularly stand-out. He came from behind to stop Jose Armando Santa Cruz, and retired Erik Morales and will be rewarded with a likely loss to Manny Pacquiao in June. Former World champion Taylor for all intents and purposes is out of the division but continues to be rated by various bodies.
#4
Welterweight: Sugar Shane Mosley (44-5, 37 KO)
Middleweight: Ronald "Winky" Wright (51-4-1, 25 KO)
Lightweight: Julio Diaz (34-4, 25 KO)
Jr. Bantamweight: Dimitri Kirilov (29-3, 9 KO, IBF)
Based on two 2004 wins over Mosley at 154 lbs., it may seem odd to see Wright rated below Mosley. Based on what each has been getting done recently, it’s not odd at all. Mosley was far more competitive in his last bout, November 2007 against a prime Cotto, than Wright was against an aged Hopkins a few months earlier. It also helps that Mosley picked up a win prior to Cotto against Luis Collazo (#8). Wright hasn’t faced a top ten Middleweight since drawing with then-champ Jermain Taylor and he hasn’t fought at all in going on one year. Diaz and Kirilov are pretty far behind Mosley and Wright, but Diaz gets the edge for a higher overall quality of competition. Losing to Juan Diaz is simply more impressive than drawing with journeyman Cecilio Santos. Those are the results in each man’s most recent outings. That doesn’t make Kirilov a bad fighter; he showed in defeating Luis Perez and Jose Navarro that he is not.
#5
Jr. Bantamweight: Vic Darchinyan (29-1-1, 23 KO)
Lightweight: Zahir Raheem (29-2, 17 KO)
Middleweight: Sebastian Sylvester (29-2, 14 KO)
Welterweight: Kermit Cintron (29-2, 27 KO)
Darchinyan should be on his way to his second alphabelt title in his second division when he faces the vulnerable Kirilov in July. Throw in a draw that should have been a decision win against Z Gorres earlier this year and Darchinyan shows little affect so far from his stoppage loss at Flyweight last year to Nonito Donaire. Raheem is a crafty veteran no one is in a hurry to face. Sylvester is interesting; his resume isn’t deep but recent fare has shown a fighter on the rise. His revenge knockout win against Amin Asikainen (#10) and most recent knockout win over former World Jr. Middleweight champion and recent WBA 160 lb. titlist Javier Castillejo stand him out as a dark horse challenge to Pavlik in the future. Cintron is probably rated too high but can’t be faulted too much for a second loss to Margarito. After all, only Paul Williams (#6) has been able to turn the trick at the top ten level for the better part of this decade, and then just barely.
And that brings us to the halfway mark. Through champions and their top fives, the divisions score out at:
Welterweight – 12 points
Jr. Bantamweight – 14 points
Lightweight – 16 points
Middleweight – 18 points
So far, Welterweight remains the answer but the other divisions aren’t that far away and the real test of any division is its depth. Does Welterweight hold up as well in slots 6-10