Yes they hold true, imo, all it takes is one success story.
All it takes is one success story? There have been many success stories yet people in urban areas have limited social mobility. Why is this so? Well, if we go with your original claims it is due to choice, yet what are you using to validate your claim that this is a matter of choice? If you aren't getting the same education as others, jobs are being outsourced to other countries and you've been economically and socially deprived, with little to no representation, what exactly can you do?
The most economically depressed area in this country has nothing on the poverty experienced in third world countries.
Who said it did? But we're talking about this country, not other countries.
Obviously they don't always yield the desired results though.
You're starting to contradict yourself.
Yet you didn't take it upon yourself to set the situation straight. Why is that?
Our definitions probably differ. Regardless, I think he felt the government of this country dictated our society, every facet of it.
Someone obviously dictates every aspect of our society, that is a given. However, if we go with your definition most, or even all, people are outlaws by direct or indirect action. Do you agree with this? I ask because one can easily infer such a thing by reading your definition.
I think that much is obvious.
To some it isn't.
Yet no one has identified exactly who "the government" is...
Well if I was doing an actual study or report, then yes I would. But in this instance, all I have to do is look at my life and a few of my folks growing up to easily conclude that our decision making was the sole contributing factor in our life's evolution process, if you may.
And all I would have to do is look at the hundreds of thousands of black males in prison and consider the fact that maybe they had no choice at all. You are making a HUGE leap when you make the claim that ones decision making was/is the sole contributing factor in our life. In fact, if we go with your train of thought, you've completely exonerated the government from any wrong doing whatsoever!
"The government didn't kill Tupac. His choice to live the life of a thug, outlaw and gangsta rapper is what killed him."
See how that works?
Because they made the decision to facilitate/use an illegal substance for economic gain/pleasure. That decision rests solely on an individual, regardless of where it came from.
What other options were available? Do you think, if given the choice or other options, that the majority of people in urban communities who sell drugs would sell drugs?
They are being held down in the form of knowledge and educational resources.
So how do you expect them to make the right choices if they don't have knowledge or educational resources?
You may be right, but does black leadership look to hold back their people from the American dream, or do they want their piece of the pie too?
That depends on the people in question, and just so you know the leaders I'm talking about aren't Jackson and Sharpton. You ever heard of the Jack and Jill Club?