1 P
2 M
3 P
4 M
5 M
6 P
7 M
8 M
9 P
10 P
11 P
12 M
P = Pacquio and M = Marquez
6 to 6 for the draw.
Both men had flaws in their game but before we even go into how the flaws contributed to the wrong descision, you have to remember that styles make fights. Now look at the two styles. One guy is constantly coming forward and throwing while the other guy is waiting and moving to the side and countering or waiting and moving backwards while trying to counter. When refs see this, especially in the later rounds, they don't think the person counterpunching and fighting at his pace is the aggressor.
Marquez made Pac fight his fight but he wasn't able to dismantle Manny as he should have. With all the body punching and all the countering he did, he should have knocked Pac out. However, in saying that, I'm not taking anthing away from him because he fought a very defensive fight, controlled the pace for the majority and forced Manny to fight his fight.
Concerning Manny, constantly coming forward makes you a target. Constantly going for the head, instead of the body, makes you a target as well and shows a lack of discipline or a flaw in your fight plan. At times he cut the ring off well, but then Marquez would move to avoid the left, Manny would throw a punch, and Marquez would counter. What I did like about Manny however was the fact that he didn't try to coast in and started to step up int he later rounds and this is what I think swayed the fight.
It was a draw to me, I can see why people say Marquez won and I can see why they say Manny won. But, what Manny needs to do is FIRE Arum. Fire that no good sonofabitch, go to the table, sign the contract, take the test and fight Floyd. That, "Talk to my promoter" and "Talk to Arum my promoter" bullshit is old. Manny, Arum has raped you, he owes Floyd millions of dollars (according to Floyd) so if you REALLY want to fight Floyd, and rectify the fact that your net worth is low (based on how much you generated) fire the guy and do what needs to be done. If not, you'll fight Marquez 23 more times with janky ass descisions in each and every one of them.