Can we get some real Raider fan's opinion on this?
YES:
IMO THEY WERE BOTH A PART OF THE PROBLEM. OBVIOUSLY AL AND HIS EGO/PRIDE IS THE BIGGEST PROBLEM THE RAIDERS FACE AS AN ORGANIZATION. THIS LETTER PROVES HOWEVER, THAT AL WAS LOOKING FOR A WAY TO RESOLVE THE SITUATION WITHOUT FIRING KIFFIN. KIFFIN KNEW WHAT IT WAS WHEN HE CAME TO OAKLAND. IF HE WANTED COMPLETE AND UTTER AUTONOMY THAN HE SHOULD NOT HAVE TAKEN THIS JOB. YOU CAN TELL THAT AL WAS WILLING TO GIVE KIFFIN MORE AUTONOMY THAN HE HAD GIVEN COACHES IN THE PAST BECAUSE HE IS GETTING DESPERATE TO WIN. I THINK IN THE BACK OF HIS MIND HE KNOWS THAT HE NEEDS TO COMPROMISE IN ORDER TO SUCCEED.
IMO KIFFIN WENT ABOUT THINGS IN THE WRONG WAY. RATHER THAN ATTACKING AL THROUGH THE MEDIA INDIRECTLY, HE SHOULD HAVE WENT TO AL AND VOICED HIS ISSUES. THIS WAS THE STRAW THAT BROKE THE CAMELS BACK. AL IS BIG ON LOYALTY AND KIFFIN COMMITTED A MAJOR SIN IN AL’S EYES BY PURSUING THE JOB AT ARKANSAS LAST SEASON. HIS RELATIONSHIP WITH AL WAS STRAINED EVER SINCE THEN, AND THAT IS KIFFIN’S FAULT AND KIFFIN’S ONLY.
I THINK AFTER KIFFIN DID THAT HE FELT ASHAMED AND PROBABLY ASSUMED THAT AL ALLREADY HATED HIM AND WAS GOING TO FIRE HIM. HE WAS WRONG. AL FELT BETRAYED BUT WAS WILLING TO PUT HIS FEELINGS ASIDE IN AN ATEMPT TO WORK IT OUT.
KIFFIN MADE THE DECISION FOR AL. HE DIDN’T WANT TO COACH HERE ANY LONGER BUT HE WASN’T GOING TO QUIT AND FORFIT HIS MONEY. HE FORCED AL’S HAND BY ATTACKING THE ORGANIZATION THROUGH THE MEDIA.
ONLY TIME WILL TELL IF KIFFIN CAN REALLY BE A GOOD COACH IN THIS LEAGUE. THE FACT THAT AL IS SO DAMN CONTROLING IS THE REASON WHY WE CAN’T ATTRACT A GOOD/ESTABLISHED COACH INTO OAKLAND. MOST OF THE BLAME FOR THE RAIDERS DOING SO BAD LIES WITH AL.
BUT ON THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE: THEY ARE BOTH TO BLAME.