The only parts that bugged me were the owl parts and the hypnosis parts, even though it was easy to tell they were staged. I thought it was a pretty good attempt. The whole God thing was over the top, though. Also, big plot hole I noticed. If, after the guy had supposedly seen the UFO over her house, what did the fucking emergency call sound like?
"Uhh, something just flew over her house!!! It's taking them!!!"
Later on...
"Where's your daughter? Don't give me that alien bullshit!! Our guy just said something was flying over your house and abducted someone. NOW WHERE IS SHE??"
...........