TUESDAY'S CHAT WITH JERRY MAC OF THE OAKLAND TRIBUNE. LOTS OF GOOD SHIT HERE:
12:55 jerrymac: Better to start early than late . . .
12:55 [Comment From JUGULATOR]
Any chance you think they try for Tank Williams ?
12:55 jerrymac: It's not the way they've operated so far. The Raiders have been looking for young players and not those with checkered pasts. A nice change, too.
12:56 [Comment From DB]
Should we sign SS Roy Williams, DT Tank Johnson, and WR Matt Jones?
12:57 jerrymac: All three into the above category. Williams would be the most intriguing, but not if he's going to command huge money. It should be the sort of deal they made with Donovin Darius a few years back _ if he doesn't have it during camp, they can cut him.
12:57 [Comment From Guest]
with the Raiders signing Barnes..I know now they will go power running. Will Bush be more incorporated into the running game? I hope more than Fargas? and I hope they drop down in the draft and go for maclin and harvin for cheap..instead of big money on crabtree.
12:59 jerrymac: Barnes is not purely a power player. He can move. It was one of the things that attracted Cable to him. Exactly how they mesh the power running game with the ZBS will be one of the more interesting aspects of minicamps and training camp.
12:59 [Comment From wildabeast]
have we shown any interest in veteran QB's Jeff Garcia or Trent Green?
1:00 jerrymac: I don't think so, and I'm not sure how interested they'd be in joining the Raiders _ particularly in the case of Garcia, who never wanted to come to Oakland in the first place because of Russell. Green's concussion issues are a concern.
1:00 [Comment From raider33]
With the additon of khalif barnes and mario hendersons play at left tackle last year, who do u see winning left tackle spot assuming we dont draft a left tackle or tackle in the draft also has khalif barnes been a left tackle his whole career at jacksonville
1:01 jerrymac: I'm sure they're hoping Barnes seizes the moment and claims the job. The good thing from the Raiders vantage point is he's not being paid so much that he HAS to win the job.
1:01 [Comment From JIMBO]
any chacnce of the Raiders drafting Malcolm Jenkins at #7 and making him their safety?
1:02 jerrymac: Not sure they'd go safety at No. 7 again after trying it with Huff.
1:02 [Comment From Guest]
Jerry could you explain to me what a trick offense is and why does everyone keep saying Crabtree comes from a trick offense? There are plenty of teams that open up their offense and spread the ball around.
1:03 jerrymac: An offense that relies almost exclusively on myriad shallow pass routes with the occasional medium and deep strike, and puts up numbers against poor defenses that is better than the sum of its parts in terms of talent. Think Andre Ware/David Klingler and Houston. Do you remember any of those receivers? I know I don't.
1:03 [Comment From Tenacious D]
Any chance of Louis Rankin getting off the practice squad this year? he looked good in pre season last year.
1:04 jerrymac: A chance, but the Raiders have three running backs and may not need a fourth on the 53-man. His best bet is being a core special teams player.
1:04 [Comment From Mike]
should we draft Raji or WR with the 7th pick now that we have Barnes at left tackle?
1:06 jerrymac: Depends on how the first six picks play out and which player they think can be a major contributor - and fast. Even with Barnes, I'd have a hard time passing on Smith and Monroe as tackles. Don't think they'll be around so it won't be a problem. Took Crabtree in a mock draft today largely because of Maclin's similarity with Higgins in terms of style. But the Raiders will have far more insight as to Crabtree's true play-making ability, speed and the condition of his foot than I'll have sitting at a computer.
1:06 [Comment From JIMBO]
Dont you think Henderson will make a better LT then RT? Given who he shut down towards the end of the year, shouldnt he be given the benefit of the doubt and put BArnes on the Right side?
1:07 jerrymac: For whatever reason, Henderson has never won over the coaching staff _ first Kiffin, and then Cable. Even when Mario was playing well, Cable sounded as if he had to stay all over him to prevent a slide. Never sounds as if he's got complete faith in him. Sure it has to do with practice habits and aggressiveness.
1:07 [Comment From mark]
franchise tackles do not along too often,we missed out on jake long and we took russell instead of joe thomas not that i disagree but do you think we should take andre smith if he falls.
1:08 jerrymac: Not sure everyone thinks Andre Smith is of that mold. I think there's at least room for concern that his conditioning has been suspect and his judgement hasn't been good in terms of being prepared for the whole draft process. I mean, this is the most important time of his life.
1:08 [Comment From Kyle]
Are the offseason workouts a closed event, or open to the media?
1:08 jerrymac: Closed. They have an occasional day with some access, or at least they did last year. Not sure about this year.
1:08 [Comment From RaiderRockstar]
Jerry, nice job in picking Crabtree & Mack as two guys who would benefit the Raiders greatly. Who would be your 3rd option if we get a center in free agency and Crabs is gone by #7 ?
1:09 jerrymac: I'm not sure if signing Duke Preston would preclude the Raiders wanting someone like Mack or Unger. It would be a stopgap move. Preston wasn't that impressive in Buffalo.
1:09 [Comment From Kyle]
Not many teams are showing much interest for Orlando Pace. Rumors before he was released were that the Raiders were looking to acquire him. Any word on this?
1:10 jerrymac: I would think the Barnes signing rules that out. And for far less money than Pace wanted, I'm guessing. Pace's ability to stay healthy and practice consistently are legitimate concerns, and that is a big deal to Cable and the Raiders.
1:10 [Comment From Trenton]
Any chance Tim Brown will make it into the HOF in his first year of eligibility? If not, when do you see it happening?
1:11 jerrymac: The fact that Cris Carter wasn't a first-ballot player doesn't bode well for Brown. I know there are voters who believe Brown is like a 25-ppg scorer on a bad basketball team. He gets stats because someone has to get stats, an they're not contributing to a greater good. Not saying it' right, but the feeling is there.
1:11 [Comment From Chrisram73]
Jerry, are reporters allowed into Voluntary practice sessions? If so, what are you seeing from the players? Why is J. Russell not in? He should be doing laps around the facility, no?
1:13 jerrymac: No access to voluntary practice sessions as of yet, and no guarantee there will be. Russell will be there plenty, I believe. They're fairly casual. Each player is supposed to make a specific percentage of the workouts if possible. Not going to start worrying about Russell's commitment level until there is evidence its an issue. I liked the way he finished the year, his demeanor, etc.
1:13 [Comment From Taurus]
Do you think the Raiders will pick up any veteran recievers?
1:14 jerrymac: Probably, but bringing back Walker means it would probably be a player just hoping to latch on to a fourth or fifth spot. And the Raiders I'm sure are hoping that Arman Shields grabs a spot. That would mean Higgins, Schilens, Shields and Walker (since he's being paid for two years). Plus one more.
1:14 [Comment From Moose]
Jerry...a question related to your earlier blog,about the shyness of the Raiders......do you think the team loses its competitive edge,by not allowing fans to attend training camp? and do you think the Raiders will ever change this policy??
1:16 jerrymac: Raiders camp in Napa is not set up for a huge crowd. It's simply not big enough. And no, not sure it's a big deal in terms of getting them ready. It might break up the monotony a little to have fans there, but mostly it's drudgery for the players. Think it's unfortunate the Raiders can't find a way to the practice at a local high school as they once did. The Coliseum Raiders day isn't intimate enough of a setting.
1:16 [Comment From Rob from LA]
Who in our division would you say looks like the favorite so far ?
1:17 jerrymac: Probably San Diego based on their division title from last year, and I think teaming Tomlinson and Sproles will give them a good 1-2 punch and lengthen Tomlinson's career. The big thing is getting Merriman back. If he's anything close to what he was, they're the favorite.
1:18 [Comment From Ray Guy]
What's the word on draft position for Alex Mack? I hear he will be gone by our second pick. He seems like a very good choice to me and IMO we should do whatever we have to to get him.
1:19 jerrymac: Seems unlikely he would fall into the second round. He could be a guy you put at center and forget about the position for seven to 10 years. But I just don't see it happening at No. 7.
1:19 [Comment From Rick (SpringTown)]
Maclin? Harvin?? Why? That doesnt make any sense. Give Russell a great target with hands.
1:20 jerrymac: Can't say I disagree. Seems like no one looks for the guys with really great hands anymore, it's all about the speed, etc. That's why Fitzgerald is so good. He catches everything.
1:20 [Comment From Raiderdave]
I like the one-year deal for Barnes as Henderson needs camp competition for LT. Instead, why do I continue to read that Barnes seems like a lock at LT. Are the Raiders headed down the same road again (the K. Harris vs Mario Henderson deal). Mario DESERVES a shot!
1:20 jerrymac: I think he'll get a shot and that's the whole point. Pushing him. Cable and co. are convinced he needs to be pushed. Barnes is only on a one-year deal and getting money which would justify being a backup if that were to occur.
1:21 [Comment From Jason]
If both Monroe and Smith are gone, wouldn't the smart pick be Raji? I mean, for the last 4 or 5 years we have been among the worst vs the run. Need to address it at some point. Plus, Crabtree and Maclin have a lot of questions
1:22 jerrymac: Have to admit I haven't seen enough on Raji, although I've read up on him. The first thing that jumps out at me is he plays alongside another huge DT who is draftable and the trick is determing how much the other player made Raji better by his presence.
1:22 [Comment From Kyle]
Julian Peterson, LeRoy Hill and Lofa Tatupu all had years where they had quite a few sacks under Marshall, but not over the past couple years. Did Marshall start dropping them back in zone like Al loves?
1:23 jerrymac: Marshall will run his defenses with full knowledge that there is a certain way the Raiders are expected to play. If he strays from that and the defense plays well, he's OK. If he strays and the defense plays poorly, he'll hear about it.
1:23 [Comment From Dave from N.J.]
What is the story on CB John Bowie ? If he makes the team and stays healthy. Is he a special team player or can he help out in the secondary ?
1:24 jerrymac: No way of knowing because he was on IR all of last year. I suspect he was kept around simply because he was the guy that got for Moss. Perhaps he'll prove me wrong.
1:24 [Comment From willy in reno]
have the raiders made any attempts to bring a veteran wideout like harrison or holt to develop these young guys we have what about matt jones at a cheap price
1:26 jerrymac: First thing that has to happen is that the veteran has to WANT to develop young players. Don't kid yourself _ many of them don't. They want to play themselves. As much as I like Holt, not sure I'd want to sign him given nine games on grass at minimum (coliseum plus AFC West road games). Jones' decision-making has been awful off the field.
1:26 [Comment From gr8 1]
Do you think Michael Huff and Tyvon Branch would be a good safety combo? I think they have good man coverage skills to cover tight ends but can they tackle?
1:27 jerrymac: Always liked the way Huff conducted himself since he arrived. Seemed like a veteran when he was a rookie. But he simply hasn't made plays on the field. I'd have to see it to believe it. As for Branch, he didn't play enough last year to make a judgement.
1:27 [Comment From RaiderRockstar]
would you rather have Boller, Frye or a disgruntled Walter to back up Russell and compete with Gradkowski?
1:28 jerrymac: I prefer to have a QB who is a change-of-pace from the starter, rather than a guy who does the same things. Gives the offensive a different look _ rather than a guy who does the same things, only not as well. So within that context, I'd prefer Frye because he's not strictly a dropback passer.
1:28 [Comment From Kev]
Should the Raiders consider Cutler? I mean, we all want Russell to succeed, but this kid Cutler is there now.
1:29 jerrymac: I think Raider fans ought to really hope Cutler remains in Denver. He's got the arm and the stats, but he's only good when he's flying high and he pouts and blames others when things go poorly. Not a good leader at all, it appears.
1:30 [Comment From 16 to 88]
Do you know if they kept some of the Kiffin playbook and incorporated it with Tollners or is JaMarcus learning a completely new offense?
1:30 jerrymac: Kiffin's play book essentially morphed into Cable's offense last year, and Tollner is building off that in temrs of the passing game.
1:30 [Comment From M.Valentino]
Hey Jerry, any other possible FA that are in the Mix that you can let us know of?, other than Barnes its been kinda quiet in The Nation and Im gettin worried
1:32 jerrymac: Think they're merely waiting to see prices come down on guys they like (hell, they may have secret agreements with some) . . . but I wouldn't be worried. In fact, I'd be worried if they were signing a bunch of free agents. They're out there for a reason. They found that out last year the hard way.
1:32 [Comment From MikeNJ]
Just how many years do you think Jamarcus gets to not be considered a bust? if he struggles this year, how much longer do the Raiders have to stick with him since he was a top pick?
1:32 jerrymac: He gets three full years, minimum. Or at least he should. I would consider 2009 Year No. 2.
1:32 [Comment From bill]
Contrary to your own article yesterday, I am intrigued by the absolute lack of leaks on anything raider this offseason. Last one every other reporter *eg. Mortensen knew everything inside. Isnt it a good sign?
1:34 jerrymac: There is no problem with keeping your intensions to yourself. That's something a good organization should do. What doesn't make any sense is having transactions completed and then deciding you don't want to tell your own fans. It's not going to hurt them on the field. It's just plain dumb.
1:34 [Comment From James]
We re-signed Ricky Brown. Do you think the Raiders are comfortable with their starting Linebackers?
1:34 jerrymac: I think they're pretty comfortable, and I'm not sure that's a good thing. LBs are at least part of the problem vs. the run.
1:34 [Comment From MikeNJ]
Sure would love to get Amani Toomer in the Silver and Black for a little leadership and concistency.
1:35 jerrymac: Agree he would be a good choice and probably would want to mentor young WRs.
1:35 [Comment From Manuel]
Some draft "experts" think Maclin's the pick (over Crabtree) because of his speed, but was Tim Brown that fast?
1:35 jerrymac: Very fast when he was drafted. Severe knee injury slowed him down early on. Was quick more than fast after that, relied on know-how in later years.
1:36 [Comment From Rick (SpringTown)]
Can the Raiders win the AFC West? Most of the division is in shambles. We made strides last year and with a good draft and some breaks
1:37 jerrymac: I've said before I like this offseason a lot in contrast to last year.
Two biggest issues 1) How good will Russell be?; 2) Can they stop (or at least slow) the running game? Keep giving up 20-plus rushing touchdowns per year and playoffs won't happen.
1:37 [Comment From Greg S.]
Have the Raiders expressed any interest in Michael Crabtree or is it all a secret as usual?
1:38 jerrymac: Crabtree is a Top 10 talent. So sure, they're interested. But there is a lot to determin in terms of his health, etc.
1:38 [Comment From James]
Any luck getting the blog users registered?
1:39 jerrymac: It's been discussed. Have been told it should happen in some way, shape or form. But I'll believe it when I see it because I've heard this before.
1:40 [Comment From rayguy4hof]
With Gibril Wilson and Rashad Baker gone, we have no depth at S, why haven't we tried Jon Alston at SS?
1:40 jerrymac: Don't think he's been a safety since Stanford. A tough time in his career to make a full-fledged change to safety.
1:40 [Comment From James]
Do you think the "Special Position" Al Davis spoke of is already in place, our offseason is making too much sense...
1:41 jerrymac: I would instead give Davis credit for realizing last year was a disaster and acting in that regard.
1:41 [Comment From dannyo]
what happened to ashley lelie
1:42 jerrymac: Still an unrestricted FA. Heard there was still some level of interest in him but frankly I don't know why.
1:42 [Comment From bill]
We need to stop the run, and the national leader in TFL played for San jose State. A great athlete. Any rumors regarding Jarron Gilbert?
1:42 jerrymac: No, but I'll always pull for a fellow Spartan.
1:42 [Comment From Foust]
Any news on the Davis/Kiffin depositions?
1:43 jerrymac: Nothing other than they occured. Sure they're blaming each other for something they both had a hand in.
1:44 [Comment From Cris]
how high are the raiders on morrison? it seems like he's always getting trucked whenever it'sa running play. do they think it's more an issue with substandard d-tackles or is that just morrison?
1:45 jerrymac: Ryan talked up Morrison a lot. I would like to see the MLB be a bigger guy, more stout, seal off the run better. He is entering the final year of his contract, so this is a big year for him.
1:45 [Comment From RAIDER619]
what do you think about darrick brown? he is a huge safety
1:46 jerrymac: He played both safety and corner last year, as a practice squad guy. Your classic Raider. No one looks better coming off the bus as a DB _ in the entire league. No evidence he can play as yet.
1:46 [Comment From Colorado]
Hi Jerry, if the Raiders were going through this Cutler-McDaniels fiasco, they would be lambasted in the media as "dysfunctional". How come the Broncos aren't being labeled as "dysfunctional"?
1:47 jerrymac: If it happens for a few years running, then they probably will be.
1:47 [Comment From R8drfan-n-SD]
What rookie wr is gonna force Javon to step his game up this season, if none, why aren't we sparking competition at the wr spot by picking one of 2 quality wr in fa? Seems like as long is Javon is the Vet, he's comfortable.
1:48 jerrymac: Walker resides on his own planet, in his own solar system. It will be entirely up to him.
1:48 [Comment From Cris]
are 7 wins next year realistic or can 6 be considered solid considering the schedule?
1:48 jerrymac: Going from five to six wins isn't enough. Certainly not enough for the owner.
1:48 [Comment From stags]
Due to the economy do you think the raiders will have a tough time selling out games? Any word on season ticket sales?
1:49 jerrymac: They kept prices the same, a wise move. They don't release any ticket info at this time of year. It's going to depend on how good the product is. If they start anything lik they finished a year ago, there will be butts in the seats. Interesting to see the order of the games when it comes out next month.
1:50 [Comment From oakland raid]
do you see the raiders picking up samari rolle or do you think he is past his prime
1:50 jerrymac: If he came cheap, it would beat taking another run at Duane Starks.
1:50 [Comment From Samhain]
Hi Jerry, if Crabtree is gone, do we take Maclin at #7?
1:51 jerrymac: That's what most mocks seem to think (many have them taking Maclin over Crabtree). I would renew my issue with him being too similar to Higgins and instead look at a pass rusher (Everette Brown, perhaps).
1:51 [Comment From Raider Nation 951]
Can you see Marshall making enough of a difference as a DC to improve the Run Defense since the Raiders haven't improved the talent on their defense?
1:53 jerrymac: It's not impossible. The worst defense the Raider ever had (1997) was last against the run, last against the pass. Pretty unbelievable when you think about it since teams that run well usually continue to run. Willie Shaw came in and they turned it around in one year _ and the main upgrades were outside at CB with Woodson and Eric Allen. You get a team to play together and feed off each other and a lot of things can happen.
1:53 [Comment From tonyt]
Hi Jerry, any chance of trading one of the 3 top running backs to detroit for one of their #1 pick or top 2 pick?
1:53 jerrymac: Don't see any of the RBS going anywhere, Bush trade rumors to the contrary.
1:54 [Comment From rayguy4hof]
Is Michael Huff a bust? The guy can't tackle.
1:54 jerrymac: Looks like a bust to me, although I'd love to be wrong.
1:55 [Comment From FIREKIFFIN]
What are the chances of the Raiders trading the 7th pick for multiple picks?
1:55 jerrymac: Based on past history, not much of a chance. Raiders don't trade down, although Al says ``it's better to be right than consistent.''
1:55 [Comment From The Big Ugly]
Will Gallery ever become a Pro Bowl guard, or will he always be an average lineman with "above average" being his ceiling?
1:56 jerrymac: Offensive linemen's reputations rise and fall with wins and losses. I think you'll find that if the Raiders won 10 games, Gallery playing at roughly the same level as he did last year would be a Pro Bowl guard.
1:56 [Comment From Vilapiano41]
Jerry - Crabtree at #7 is an outrage. If Raji is still there we have to take him and try to shore up the run defense once and for all. There's a big correlation between our record over the last 7 years and the poor run D. Your thoughts please.
1:57 jerrymac: Raji hasn't graded out as high as Dorsey did last year. Dorsey (I admit, a smaller player) didn't do much in KC. Nothing is automatic.
1:57 [Comment From Lee]
Jerry, it looks like the Niners don't want Issac Bruce do you think he would be a good mentor for the young guys.
1:58 jerrymac: Same issue as Holt. Too many games on grass. Realize niners have grass at home, but usually have more road games on turf.
1:58 [Comment From rikiramone]
I came in late sorry,,any chance the Raiders will use the 1st or 2nd round of the draft to shore up the O line?
1:59 jerrymac: Wouldn't be surprised if they wound up with a center.
1:59 [Comment From mike 323]
Do you think Al Davis will let Tom Cable coach??? He said he made mistakes in the past?? Has he really evaluated himself
2:00 jerrymac: In his first year as a coach, Cable is in what Lane Kiffin called ``the honeymoon'' period. Meaning he'll get his way, have a lot of latitude with the offense in particular and in terms of personnel, and see how it goes. If things go poorly, things tighten up considerably. Should be better for Cable, however, because he actually attempts to work with Davis and isn't looking for his next job.
2:00 [Comment From Raider Central]
On a scale of 1-10 how would you grade the Raider Coaching staff? I know what matters is what they do on the field, but just from your observation.
2:01 jerrymac: Will have a better idea when I watch training camp. We've learned a lot about the Raiders at each of the last few training camps, strengths and weaknesses that have panned out during the course of the season.
2:01 [Comment From Al LoCasale]
Jerry Im hearing the Raiders might quietly shop Russell around draft day and draft Sanchez,..what do you think about that?
2:01 jerrymac: Real quietly.
2:02 [Comment From thetruth]
Give a break, this whole team is a bust so far..
2:02 jerrymac: That's the spirit.
2:02 [Comment From raiderace]
Can JaMarcus ever fix his accuracy problem - or is that something that can't be fixed?
2:02 jerrymac: He was over 60 percent in the last several games. He got much better, albeit his best games came with heavy run emphasis.
2:03 [Comment From RaiderRockstar]
Should Raider fans be concerned if we go with just Wade & Morris at center?
2:03 jerrymac: Yes, they should. But I don't think that will happen.
2:03 [Comment From RaiderJack]
How'd baseball go this weekend? Any success as coach?
2:04 jerrymac: We're 1-0. Going for 2-0 tonight. One of the assistant coaches for the opponent tonight is former Raiders tight end Jeremy Brigham.
2:04 [Comment From NoMoreFargas]
Jerry how many games does cable have if we start this season like the last 6?
2:05 jerrymac: Cable is not in Kiffin's situation because he is trying to work with Davis and seems to like working for him. He's not trying to get fired. As long as they don't duplicate the Atlanta game a few times, he'll be OK for the year.
2:05 [Comment From SCRaider]
The Raiders MVP for next year will be......
2:06 jerrymac: They're MVP is JaMarcus Russell. If he is instead their most disappointing player, it's probably another 10-loss year.
Talk to you next week.