First of all, Russ Ortiz was not the most consistant pitcher in the Giants rotation last year (I can show you with last year and this year's numbers), it was and still is Jason Schmidt. Just this year, Schmidt has started in 2 less games then Ortiz, yet has 54 more strikeouts and 20 less walks? Schmidt has an ERA of 2.43 compared to Ortiz' ERA of 3.56. Schmidt just completed his 3rd shutout of the year throwing a 3 hit complete game shutout against the red hot dodgers, let me add that Ortiz has thrown one shutout in his 5 year career. Schmidt throws harder, strikes out more batters, walks less batters, and wins just as many games, not to mention ranks in the top 5 in major pitching catagories. Batters are hitting .198 against Schmidt and .222 against Ortiz... I can go on forever, so someone elaborate on how you think Ortiz is in any way better then Jason Schmidt. Lets not worry about how the pitchers were fairing 5 years ago, lets talk about last year and the current season because thats what matters. I have trouble finding a single catagory that Ortiz has out-pitched Schmidt in... it's no contest in my eyes.
I will say the Ortiz is a pretty solid pitcher, I would love to have kept him on the Giants. The main reason we let him go was money, but we also took a gamble. By letting him go we welcomed some new young hopefulls to take the mound, which if they played better then expected, would prove to be a much better choice then to keep Ortiz, its not turing out as good as we had hoped, but it could be much worse.
All im saying, is watch Schmidt, because he is probably the most under0rated pitcher in the major's. Mark my words.