ThaG said:
I can argue that the bad religions have done vastly outweighs the good, but that's not my point, true, I am criticizing religions based on what they've done
BTW I just wanna to say something to this real quick. You know I'm agnostic but I would argue that religion itself is responsible for the very progression of civilization. I would dare say if it wasn't for religion we would be living fairly primitive lifestyles. Let me explain...
The first civilizations implemented laws/rules to govern their populations (Hammurabi's Code being the first documented example) these laws made their society more efficient if you will. Laws that made their populace refrain from selfish/primitive behavior (such as rape, murder and theft) which allowed them to act as one, instead of as individuals.
These first civilizations had nothing more than fear of God(s) or deities to enforce their laws, the governing forces were neither omnipresent nor almighty which a "God" therefor could be. If the populace would have disregarded these laws, they could have never acted as one and progressed, they would have acted as individuals against each other. Fear of an invisible, almighty force was the only solution which could have caused large masses to obey a set of laws (which unified the society).
I would even suggest that the very reason why religion is so popular today, is because these groups (with their laws and "fear of god") grew and became stronger while other smaller groups with no laws or religion were unable to compete in survival against the unified societies.
You could say religion has already served it's purpose, governments have long since been able to enforce laws without fear of god. But to say religion has caused more harm than good is a stretch. Though true, countless wars and conflicts have been based on religion (and it could be argued it was used as a justification, but not the basis of). I would say the good religion has done far outweighs any negative aspects of what "Fear of God" has caused. Religion and "Fear of God" was the very foundation of the first civilizations, once again I reiterate that it is responsible for the very progression of civilization itself. Keep in mind I myself do not believe in any such God(s).