Year Pick Team Name University YS G SR
2009 1 DET Matthew Stafford Georgia 1 10 n/a
Comment: Too early to include in this analysis. But not playing as well as last year's seniors Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco.
2009 5 NYJ Mark Sanchez USC 1 12 n/a
Comment: See Stafford note.
2007 1 OAK JaMarcus Russell LSU 2 ½ 28 0
Comment: No. 1 overall pick now benched. 2009 passer rating: 47.7.
2006 3 TEN Vince Young Texas 2 ½ 41 1
Comment: Davey O'Brien Award winner as top college QB. Resuscitated career after last year's benching. Has the potential to be a franchise quarterback.
2005 1 SF Alex Smith Utah 3 39 0
Comment: 2004 Mountain West player of the year. Has had mixed reviews in 2009 after multiple benchings in prior years.
2004 11 PIT Ben Roethlisberger Miami (Ohio) 6 83 1
Comment: Signed 8-year, $102 million contract in March.
1999 1 CLE Tim Couch Kentucky 3 62 0
Comment: 1998 SEC player of the year out of the league after 4 years.
1998 2 SD Ryan Leaf Washington State 2 25 0
Comment: Some publications list Leaf as the No. 1 all-time bust.
1994 3 WAS Heath Shuler Tennessee 2 29 0
Comment: 1993 SEC player of the year out of the league after 4 years. No, this is not an accidental paste from the Couch comment.
1994 6 TB Trent Dilfer Fresno State 6 130 ½
Comment: Struggled at Tampa Bay, then credited with managing offense of Super Bowl champion Baltimore Ravens.
1993 1 NE Drew Bledsoe Washington State 12 194 1
Comment: In March 2001, signed a 10-year, $103 million contract.
1992 SD NYG Dave Brown Duke 3 73 0
Comment: Led lowly Duke to share of 1989 ACC championship. Seven of 10 NFL years as backup.
1990 1 IND Jeff George Illinois 8 131 ½
Comment: 14-35 record and 72.0 passer rating with Colts.
1990 7 DET Andre Ware Houston 0 14 0
Comment: 1989 Heisman Trophy and Davey O'Brien Award winner out of league after 4 years.
1989 SD DAL Steve Walsh Miami (Fla.) 2 80 0
Comment: All-American and national champion. Nine of 11 NFL years as backup.
1989 SD PHX Timm Rosenbach Washington State 1 26 0
Comment: Led nation in passing efficiency and was 1988 Pac-10 player of the year. Out of league after three years.
1981 SD NOR Dave Wilson Illinois 2 53 0
Comment: Set NCAA record with 621 yards passing vs. Ohio State. Five of seven NFL years as backup.