well put ,cause in hip hop the word producer is thrown out very loosely, but majority of time the producer is a beatmaker, dr dre is a producer, dj quik is a producer, my homies I get beats from are beatmakers( even though they can run the boards and outboard gear).There was once a conversation where daz was sayin during those deathrow days I was producin most of the hits etc, question is if you was doin all that then it wouldnt be nothin to do it now.I think he makes cool beats,but it was dre that made them hits(along with other factors.
another scenario. I make a beat( for this example lets just say its hot) I engineer the vocals etc to the finished product.Now dj quik takes that same beat(not altering the sequences) and engineers the same rapper same lyrics to the finidhed product
I guarantee you will almost think they were two different songs with only the same structure.There are to many people who are good at many things but dont want to be a master at one, and again not everyone is capable,its a gift.look at the dave moss beat on young sicc album, yes it was a remake of a beat used often but not only is it in tune,he didnt overplay it, it has a distinctive sound that sets it apart from the otthers in the past who tried to do it.Again my questions were to more or less get an answer from cricet as far as him saying he dont play the instrument parts he just does the beat, and I mean no disrespect, shit do what you do,Me personally I think he is a better rapper then beatmaker, Its not that he excells lyrically its just he knows how to get his point across on the mic and its convincing