brady vs manning
- Thread starter phil
- Start date
I know hate shouldn't affect my judgement. I don't like either team those 2 qb's you mentioned play for (actually come to think of it, all 3 teams, denver sf & kc) but I do admit that they are phenomenal qb's and I think montana is one of if not the greatest qb that I've seen (I don't judge prior qbs cuz all I'll ever see is highlights). I've always thought that brady just managed games, he was never great and he just had a great defense and was able to play mistake free. this year he's got alot of weapons and his running game ain't really there, but when you have 10 minutes to sit in the pocket and decide what wr to throw to then it can make any qb look great...I could've sworn I seen him stop & tie his shoe during a play and his O-line was still blocking....lol, nah.....I mean if they do run the board and go undefeated I'll be happy I witnessed history, but I dunno if I'll be able to admit that this foo is the greatest ever.....maybe down the road if I never see a team that great, but who knows.....all I know is I think he is a very good qb, which is hard for me to say because I hate him and hope he dies. that is all.
peyton mannings line is every bit as good as bradys. youre right. qbs are overrated. very few qbs with an awful offensive line have been productive throughout history. you can count them on one hand and have fingers left. when it comes down to it though brady has proven himself time and time again in pressure/clutch situations. peyton just now shed that tarnish of his image last year.
It's impossible to deny how stellar Brady is; he's looking as good right now as any QB I've seen in my lifetime.
But, with that said, I'd take Manning over him, but that's just a matter of opinion and preferance. I think the arguement is funny, though...
"It's only your opinion, but Brady is better, so that's that!"
Hypocrites.
But, with that said, I'd take Manning over him, but that's just a matter of opinion and preferance. I think the arguement is funny, though...
"It's only your opinion, but Brady is better, so that's that!"
Hypocrites.
i've liked brady since the day he started for one.
2. ive seen brady have a great year with all the key players injured on his team (he actually came close to mvp one of those years) and now that its happened to manning look at him he aint shit right now.
3. to everyone that says colts would beat the pats if they had harrison then that means the colts wouldnt of went to the superbowl if the pats didnt lose there 2 best recievers not 1 but 2.
brady got the same weapons this year (Moss, Welker, Stalworth & Watson) this year as peyton had (Harrison, Wayne, Stokley & Clark) when he got his record and brady bout to smash it.
all the NFL is bout is championships and Brady got more. yeah he did it with key role players but he did it when alot of ppl were injured and if it wasnt for him then the pats wouldnt of won them champs.
the colts coulda won tat superbowl without manning cause he sucked and always does in the playoffs so that alone makes brady better regardless of anything else cause thats when the real games are played
lol @ never be better then favre and Brady, hes already on pace to being considered the greatest qb of all-time. So what happens if the Colts win the superbowl again? Apparently thats all that matter even there should be an asterik for that first year the Patriots won it cuz of the tuck rule but we wont get into all that.
You cannot ignore the 3 rings stat.
you cannot ignore how Mannings total numbers outshadow Brady's with only 3 years more in the NFL.
BUT
Check the stats on football-reference.com
What I think is the most revealing stat is their postseason numbers. Go look at those and see what you think about this argument.
Brady. No question.
you cannot ignore how Mannings total numbers outshadow Brady's with only 3 years more in the NFL.
BUT
Check the stats on football-reference.com
What I think is the most revealing stat is their postseason numbers. Go look at those and see what you think about this argument.
Brady. No question.
Yo rip if u think manning is better good for u!! Most of us are sayin it aint close!! Thats just how it is!! We tried to explain why we think that but u seem to not get it!! The only thing Manning had on Brdy comin into this year was better numbers because of better weapons! Now that Brady has the sme type weapons he shits on Manning and now Manning now has nuthin on Brady case closed!! Got Em!!