brady vs manning

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.

phil

Sicc OG
Apr 25, 2002
7,311
27
0
115
#1
a thread inspired by defy

im just wondering if hes the only idiot that believes manning is even close to brady let alone "shits all over him" lmao
 

Defy

Cannabis Connoisseur
Jan 23, 2006
24,139
16,657
0
45
Rich City
#4
I never said peyton shits all over brady. I do believe brady on any other team with any other coach would've never gotten the recognition nor wins that he has with bellicik (however you spell his damn name) and their defense. when they first started winning bowls it wasn't brady that was taking them there, it was their defense. brady got better with time and went from not making mistakes to making good decisions. manning on the other hand could go to any team and succeed IMO. their defense was ass but he was out there winning games for them. I mean, c'mon, you remember that monday night game against tampa bay when brady scored 4 touchdowns in like 4 minutes? I haven't seen brady do no spectacular shit like that until they got some star recievers around him.
 

CZAR

Sicc OG
Aug 25, 2003
7,269
1,375
0
52
#5
Dog your points are weak!! And u sayin that Manning will be good on any team and Brady wont is just a opinion, a weak one at that but its still an opinion not a fact so it wont work!! 2ndly Manning has always had star recievers and Brady hasnt until this year and he shits on Manning when they noth have the same type of talent!! Keep tryin but that wasnt a favorable argument in mannings favor!! Got Em!!!
 

Quick

Active member
May 6, 2002
6,443
30
48
Yay Area, CA
#6
I never said peyton shits all over brady. I do believe brady on any other team with any other coach would've never gotten the recognition nor wins that he has with bellicik (however you spell his damn name) and their defense. when they first started winning bowls it wasn't brady that was taking them there, it was their defense. brady got better with time and went from not making mistakes to making good decisions. manning on the other hand could go to any team and succeed IMO. their defense was ass but he was out there winning games for them. I mean, c'mon, you remember that monday night game against tampa bay when brady scored 4 touchdowns in like 4 minutes? I haven't seen brady do no spectacular shit like that until they got some star recievers around him.
Spectacular is 3 super bowl rings.

Check bellicks records before and after Brady started at QB. You'll see who made who.
 

phil

Sicc OG
Apr 25, 2002
7,311
27
0
115
#7
defy, please dont tell me that manning took them to the bowl last year. INDYS DEFENSE DID THAT FOR THEM. or did you forget that? manning on any team would succeed? doubt it. his offensive line is stellar and when they have a bad game he does too. 6 ints???????? 6???? hes blown the big games while brady has been the mvp of them. keep tryin.
 

phil

Sicc OG
Apr 25, 2002
7,311
27
0
115
#8
manning was awful in the playoffs last year (like every year) bwahahaaa the defense carried them to the bowl. dont get me wrong manning is a beast but he is no brady.
 

Defy

Cannabis Connoisseur
Jan 23, 2006
24,139
16,657
0
45
Rich City
#9
you're right, their defense stepped up huge last year and was the reason they got to the superbowl, but manning is the one who brought them to the playoffs, their defense was playing like shit the first half of the season, don't forget that. both offensive lines are stupid loaded with good ass blockers. and IMO harrison is a star receiver and wayne is not, reggie is good, but not great. I don't think wayne is as good as dante stallworth and moss shits all over harrison. wes welker is a good ass player too.
 

Defy

Cannabis Connoisseur
Jan 23, 2006
24,139
16,657
0
45
Rich City
#11
and shit, it may just be that brady is the best qb of all time like y'all claim he is, but I would never give him that credit because I hate him so much. although regardless of my hate towards him & his gay ass team, I still feel that there are better QBs than him.
 

CZAR

Sicc OG
Aug 25, 2003
7,269
1,375
0
52
#12
^^^U make yourself look stupider as u speak!! And Wayne is a tight receiver who is havin a tight year without Harrison on the other side!! And Stallworth aint shit but butterfingers who never panned out as a high pick by New Orleans and Welker, come now I wont even talk about him! Moss is the man and he is the first tight reciever Brady has ever had!! U slippin homie!! Try to downplay the Colts recievers if u want to but u wont have no one siding with u there!! Funny shit judging a guy on hatred hahah!! Wow!! Got Em!!
 
Nov 7, 2006
7,383
36
0
39
#14
Brady is successful regardless who he has for weapons or not. we had no one last year and he did a very good job beating the so called best team in the nfl and he did it with no WR. Manning always had a great receiver and now he's injured manning isnt lookin too good. and regualr season dont mean shit compared to playoffs and manning is wack in the playoffs. ask ur self this actually, if ur in the NFL what would u rather win regular season games or playoff games? and then ask who would u rather have as a QB in the playoffs Brady or Manning? if u say Manning then u hate Tom brady for prolly some dumb ass reason or ur a colts fan
 

phil

Sicc OG
Apr 25, 2002
7,311
27
0
115
#17
I guess you "got me" cuz your opinion is shared by more than mine :rolleyes:
no its just that youre by yourself in yours. youre gonna be hard pressed to find someone to tell you manning is better than brady. brady has NEVER before this season, had a wr corps like manning. and when he finally does he dumps all over him. end of thread bro. give it up. hate shouldnt affect your judgement. i hated joe montana and john elway but i always thought they were the best i ever saw play HANDS DOWN. all hatin aside!
 
Nov 7, 2006
7,383
36
0
39
#18
alright how bout this

they always compared brady with manning and said brady got the 3 rings and manning got his name in the record books. well now brady might go undefeated with the most td's in a season and win a superbowl. not tryin to predict but all arguments between these two go out the window if all that shit happens this one year. and u can say its cause the weapons he got but when manning did that shit he had the same type of weapons in every aspect but with a better RB and brady's doin it with defenders knowin he'll pass cause our RB's are injured.
 
Jan 18, 2006
14,367
6,557
113
43
#19
This shit is all opinions, Patriots have always had the all around better team. Brady is definitely having the better year this year but what happens if the Colts beat them in the playoff is Manning all of a sudden the better qb again? I mean Colts should have beat them 2 weeks ago, if Harrison was playing they wouldnt have settled for field goals inside the 10. In my opinion Brady has the better o-line how come thats not a factor?
 

CZAR

Sicc OG
Aug 25, 2003
7,269
1,375
0
52
#20
Yea right!! Dont matter what Manning does in the playoffs even though they have no shot to beat the Pats! The argument aint even close to me even if a miracle happened and they did beat them! He needs to do alot more than that!! And we dont go off should, coulda, woulda so the fact is they didnt beat them 2 weeks ago and it was in Indy!! This shit aint close!! Got Em!!