Ben Roethlisberger HOF?

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.
MrNick40831

MrNick40831

Sicc OG
#1
May 2, 2002
2,245
65
48
43
#1
Is he gonna go now that he has two superbowl wins.
Only other players with more than one win that aren't in canton are Jim Plunkett & Tom Brady.
I think one more and he's a definite, but its a tough call, because sometimes he looks incredible and sometimes not so much.
what you guys think.
 
Tha Mack

Tha Mack

Sicc OG
#2
Feb 21, 2006
2,181
10
0
40
#2
little too early man.......... if he got hurt this offseason and never played again, i would say definately not, but hes certainly on pace to go
 
SLRider510

SLRider510

Sicc OG
#3
Dec 30, 2003
4,215
120
0
38
#3
hes really 50/50 imo.... sometimes hes fuckin unstoppable.... and sometimes he looks shitty... but to bounce back from a motorcycle accident... and win another SB.... pretty impressive.
 
DUTCH-F.E

DUTCH-F.E

Super Moderator
#5
Apr 25, 2002
7,029
8,094
113
43
WWW.myspace.com
#5
he has only played 5 years. he hasnt put up numbers like elway or montana. but he has 2 rings. there is an arguement but remember, the hall of fame is about what YOU do as a player. team accolades are bonus points. i.e. super bowls and play off wins and division titles. but what you do a s a player makes you a hof'er.

if he plays another 8-10 years and makes the playoffs 6-7 more times int hat span and stays on his average numbers. i could see it. but if he blows a knee next season he aint getting in.
 
Jazzo

Jazzo

Master of Debauchery
#11
Aug 18, 2003
2,582
490
83
Off the Grid
#11
Big Ben = Future Hall Of Famer

Ben has accomplished so much at such a young age and has gotten the hard part done. That's winning two Super Bowls already! As long as he stays healthy and continues to play the way he has, he'll definitely get in the Hall Of Fame with no question. All of his scrambling, breaking tackles and extending plays doesn't always show up in the stats. So for you square ass stat nerds, your argument is squashed! Again, Big Ben already has two championships and that's more than some Hall Of Fame QB's who wished that had... :classic:
 
Chree

Chree

Medicated
#15
Dec 7, 2005
32,363
13,861
113
39
#15
Okay, well then, the Refs deserve a HOF spot before him, cuz they sure as hell helped the stealers win both those rings

The Defense "stops" Warner from making the comeback and winning, the Defense took back a INT for a TD
 
T

Tony

Sicc OG
#18
May 15, 2002
13,165
970
113
47
#18
There's no way his defense won him them SuperBowls. The first SuperBowl, the refs won it. The 2nd SuperBowl he came through when needed. You can't say his defense won him the 2nd SuperBowl though because that defense damn near cost them the game. Warner damn hear had 400 yards passing and 4 TD's.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom