I do understand what you're saying bro, especially b/c I now live in the Midwest which really is a hell of a lot more gangster than the 206.
Couple things:
1) I think rap music has evolved to the point where it doesn't matter how gangster the place they come from is, what race they are, etc. It is 100% all about the music. If a guy was rapping about pink bunny rabbits and it sounded hot I would bump it. The best producer from our area is a white guy who grew up in one of the northern suburbs.
2) You're simplifying the geography and crime scene in Seattle. I am a geographer and I am also very interested in crime data. Unlike a lot of cities, some of the more "ghetto, hard areas" are actually located outside the city limits of Seattle, whereas in other cities you see a couple rough areas within the city but outside the city it's ALL safe. Not the case here, I don't mean to give some areas a bad name but places like White Center, Tukwila, Sea-Tac, Burien, Skyway and others are outside the city of Seattle but have a crime index of over 100 (the national average). You don't see this model in other cities. Furthermore, the Seattle-Tacoma area is among the nation's leaders in car thefts (if that makes you feel better?). Washington State is #15 nationally out of 51 (including the District of Columbia) in crime. Outlying areas and cities like Tacoma and Yakima help Seattle bring this up.
As for race and its connection to crime, you're right about Seattle not being nearly as black as cities further east. But Seattle does have essentially the same percent black and crime rates as cities such as Los Angeles, San Diego, San Francisco and Long Beach, all cities who have been telling the world how black and how gangster they are for 10, 15 years. And besides, I think everybody on here will tell you that atleast in our city, the face of criminals is of all different races. And even the simple question of race isn't perfectly clear here, 1 out of 4 babies born is of more than one race. Lots and lots of people around here are mixed man. BTW, Seattle does have a higher per capita crime rate than New York City. Generally it ranks among the middle of cities in this category.
3) I agree, even if Seattle aint gangster and even if the rappers are saying it is (therefore lying), I don't think it makes them that much different than people from other cities. Do you honestly believe that every punk you see on BET or hear on the radio has lived the life they talk about? I don't care if they are from the most gangster city in the country (aka Detroit by most quantitative accounts), they are not necessarily telling the truth. People are catching on to this, as D-Sane was saying the other day, 'realness' is a big concern that is why he's trying hard with the Crytical album to make it appear as authentic as possible, and I do believe him when he says Crytical's story is authentic.
So above all this gibberish I have typed, bottom line is that a) Seattle is not a hard city but it's also not a soft city b) your geography is pretty much correct about the city of Seattle but is shortsighted b/c it doesn't bother to compare Seattle to its surrounding Metro Areas and other cities that have through rap music, achieved so-called gangster credibility and C) even if it was the softest city in the country it wouldn't matter b/c EVERYBODY lies
BOTTOM LINE : It's 100% about the music