If Peyton wins the SB, will he be the greatest QB ever?
- Thread starter CHAPO GUZMAN
- Start date
bullshit. Montana is the G.O.A.T. like it or not....he won 2 rings without jerry so dont even try that. Montana was an undersized QB that played in a time where you were actually allowed to hit the QB. not only that, he played in one of the toughest Eras in the history of the NFL going against the likes of a lawrence taylor led giants team, or the mike ditka coached bears. Im sorry but anyone who argues against Montana bein the GOAT looks silly
No no no lol, wether YOU like it or not he is not the goat. Hilarious how you whiner fans are trying to somehow take a w out of this game lol
Props:
-corinthian and -corinthian
I agree 1hunnid on the team game comment.
On the other, Manning is not greater than Montana (AND I HAVE BEEN A HAWKS SUPPORTER SINCE 85 (long drought lmao)) or Brady (NEVER LIKED THE PATS), stop lyin to yourself, Their playoff records and SB records say otherwise. The regular season is just that, regular. If you can't produce Ws when it counts in the postseason, you are not so great. Like I said before, Warren Moon has thrown more yards in pro football than any othr NFL QB EVER, he is one of my all time favorites, but never got a ring, Randall Cunningham, also one of my all time favorites, also never got a ring- and in the scheme of things thats what all of the games are about. 11-12 postseason & 1-2 SB say Manning is not so great. Again, he had a memorable season, and it will now be tarnished by his failures in the SB, including the first snap which was his fault and led to a safety along with his other mistakes. Don't believe the hype. Bradshaw> 3ManningS
On the other, Manning is not greater than Montana (AND I HAVE BEEN A HAWKS SUPPORTER SINCE 85 (long drought lmao)) or Brady (NEVER LIKED THE PATS), stop lyin to yourself, Their playoff records and SB records say otherwise. The regular season is just that, regular. If you can't produce Ws when it counts in the postseason, you are not so great. Like I said before, Warren Moon has thrown more yards in pro football than any othr NFL QB EVER, he is one of my all time favorites, but never got a ring, Randall Cunningham, also one of my all time favorites, also never got a ring- and in the scheme of things thats what all of the games are about. 11-12 postseason & 1-2 SB say Manning is not so great. Again, he had a memorable season, and it will now be tarnished by his failures in the SB, including the first snap which was his fault and led to a safety along with his other mistakes. Don't believe the hype. Bradshaw> 3ManningS
Last edited:
take a w out of what game???this was a response to the topic of this thread, not the superbowl. and whos your team??? the chargers??? enough said. seriously though arguing for Montana being the GOAT is like arguing over whether or not the sky is blue. It is what it is , no matter how much u wanna cry over it .
Lol crying?? Not one bit but nice try. No doubt the whiners are a much better team then the chargers, never did I insinuate otherwise. Again nice try.
Yes whiner fans are trying to take a w out if this somehow.
"Yeah, see!!!!! Joe Montana is the goat not Peyton!!!!"
"Yeah, NFC West > rest of nfl!!!!!"
You get nothing out if this but a l
Yes whiner fans are trying to take a w out if this somehow.
"Yeah, see!!!!! Joe Montana is the goat not Peyton!!!!"
"Yeah, NFC West > rest of nfl!!!!!"
You get nothing out if this but a l
Then all the accolades Manning has mean shit by your measurement of success and greatness since those are individual stats. Were the 49ers better or worse with Montana on the field? It's not so much Broncos shit the bed, it's that Seattle's defense beasted the fuck out of it. Can't take anything away from that defense. No 49er fan is trying to dissect a W out of yesterday. If you refer back to my first post, this is a valid argument that has been brought up a lot... and other QB's were mentioned other than Montana or Manning too.
So basically you're saying you'd choose Manning for every Super Bowl everytime over Manning to increase chances of winning? Since he's the G.O.A.T. right? after last night's display two things were certain... Bronco's o-line got manhandled by Seattle, and Manning definitely throws ducks and Seattle made him pay. So much for being a pure pocket passer.
So basically you're saying you'd choose Manning for every Super Bowl everytime over Manning to increase chances of winning? Since he's the G.O.A.T. right? after last night's display two things were certain... Bronco's o-line got manhandled by Seattle, and Manning definitely throws ducks and Seattle made him pay. So much for being a pure pocket passer.
Not at all. Wins and losses are a team statistic. Like many others, I have always felt the QB gets too much credit when a team wins and too much blame when the team loses. Do you really think the ravens won the Super Bowl because of Trent dilfer? Lol. No need to answer that as I've made my point. Also Brady > Montana but it is completely pointless to have that debate with a whiner fan. Unbiased opinion here.
Only an idiot would overlook the fact that a QB won on their own... we are simply talking about overall success not dependent on statistic from the regular season. I'm biased because I'm a 49er fan but even non-49er fans are agreeing. It's clear you have something against the 49ers since you keep referring to me as a "whiner" fan...
Brady better than Montana? yeah let him win another Superbowl, he's not even 4-0. Even Brady would tell you he's not greater than his childhood idol. Behind closed doors or in front of a camera his response would be the same. It really comes down to two different eras. To me this is a Jordan vs Kobe/Lebron comparison... at the end of the day it's your opinion versus mine.
Brady better than Montana? yeah let him win another Superbowl, he's not even 4-0. Even Brady would tell you he's not greater than his childhood idol. Behind closed doors or in front of a camera his response would be the same. It really comes down to two different eras. To me this is a Jordan vs Kobe/Lebron comparison... at the end of the day it's your opinion versus mine.
I have nothing against the whiners. I will now refer to them and there fans as that in the future due to all the "whining" that went on after they lost to the seahawks. MysticOracle and a few others really made you guys look bad. That's why i said "damn, i guess they are called the whiners for a reason".
Manning > Montana
Brady > Montana
The end. Tootles.
Manning > Montana
Brady > Montana
The end. Tootles.
Lol nice try bud but that don't bother me one bit. Shit was 20 years ago. To be honest, aside from Kap, I like the 9ers TEAM a lot. I just think a lot of their fans are such "whiners". That was proven this year when they choked in the playoffs, again. So you fail with your attempt to take a jab at my team. Nice try though lol.
I said this.....but then I realized this:
11-12 in the post season is terrible. and 8 of those losses are one-and-done's, meaning they were eliminated the first playoff game they played. that's terrible...but he's still an unbelievable QB, anyone who wouldn't want them on their team is delusional. that's why I think Meta got it right
he clearly chokes when the big game pressure is on. and there was a lot of pressure on this game.....shit, the media practically awarded the super bowl to peyton before it started and were asking him if he's gonna retire when he wins.....I don't think I ever remember any media outlet ever talking about "what if they lose?"
11-12 in the post season is terrible. and 8 of those losses are one-and-done's, meaning they were eliminated the first playoff game they played. that's terrible...but he's still an unbelievable QB, anyone who wouldn't want them on their team is delusional. that's why I think Meta got it right
he clearly chokes when the big game pressure is on. and there was a lot of pressure on this game.....shit, the media practically awarded the super bowl to peyton before it started and were asking him if he's gonna retire when he wins.....I don't think I ever remember any media outlet ever talking about "what if they lose?"