They should just do what SoundCloud does with their free vs. premium accounts. Give each account X number of minutes of videos that they can upload for free, and/or give them a cap of plays per week/month. Make them pay an annual subscription fee if they want to remove the limits. Keep the same ad system going and let the account holders use the ad revenue to pay for their account.
That way you make money off of the indie artists without cutting them out of the picture. Plus it would probably cut down on the amount of absolutely worthless shit that gets uploaded to YouTube.
Even though I agree with you, it's still bullshit on YouTube's part. That'd be like me offering to do something for you for free & out of the blue one day I tell you I'm going to have to start charging you.
It's simply Corporate America doing it's thing. The music industry is dying (close to flat line). The underground music scene even though it appears to be dying as well is still very much alive & kicking. A lot think the underground is dying because a lot of people are quitting rap, but those that are quitting were not built for this. Those of us who are still dedicated are still at it for one reason, the love.
We stepped into the game expecting nothing. It was all for shits & giggles. Then came the point of, maybe I can do something with this & on to the, "I'm going to blow up" stage. Now, most of us accepted what it is & are simply in it for the fun of it. The ones that quit are simply people who came in because they could do it on their home computer & thought they could blow up & make fast money. After one or a few attempts without making millions / blowing up, they moved it on out. Which I think it's a good thing.
The underground has dominated thanks to the internet. MySpace was the greatest thing to ever happen, but they lure us to Facebook etc. which have limitations & suck. YouTube was another great thing for us independent artist. Stars have been made from MySpace & YouTube, but what happens when something works too good? Corporate America buys into it to destroy the little guy. Much like what Clear Channel Radio has done.