1 is always greater than 0.9999 recurring. Regardless of how many 9's you tack on the end, it will never equal 1.
After all, if 0.99999 recurring = 1, then 0.89999 recurring = 0.9 and 0.6499999 recurring = 0.65. I know the human mind loves round numbers and hates the concept of infinity, I personally can't justify believing in the "0.9999 recurring = 1" argument though. The worlds not that elegant.