At least their listening to his music.... Because they wouldnt of heard of him w/o the d/l.
now lets say this SAME PERSON tomorrow somehow downloads a bootlegged copy of Sickology 101.
worst case scenario... he dont like the music and junks it.
best scenario.... he loves the music, tells his friends, generates more buzz
now it doesnt 'physically' cost money because there is no cd/artwork/plastic/ink. I just feel like it is a NO-LOSE situation when it comes to file sharing. if i was an indie artist and felt my music was quality and original.... i would push it ANY WAY I COULD. $$ is generated all sorts of ways including the live shows and merchandise. Album sales still can be generated!! especially if some sort of bonus disc or artwork was included. Ultimately its all about the music.. IF ITS GOOD. PEOPLE WILL PAY FOR IT