SF GIANTS' OFFSEASON

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.
H

herm96

Sicc OG
#42
Sep 12, 2002
3,030
5
38
#42
the numbers that really count are hr and rbls

finley 12, 54 rbl

and i dont about alonzo but its was low, i read in paper he had 26 in 3 years.

how many hr and rbl did alonzo have last year?

also take in consideration both players were hurt last year. finley is better gamble?
 
G

G-Dubb

Sicc OG
#43
Apr 25, 2002
6,082
2,253
113
46
#43
RBI's are situational... Those numbers don't mean anything. Finley has hit more HR's but Alfonzo's been the more productive hitter.

Finley wasn't injured all year, he was bad all year. Even when he was healthy he couldn't hit for shit.
 
H

herm96

Sicc OG
#44
Sep 12, 2002
3,030
5
38
#44
if you say so? Giants cant manufacture runs like the A's can. they need a third baseman and first base that hit at least 20 hrs and drive in 80-90 runs. i take Finley over alonzo any day.
 
G

G-Dubb

Sicc OG
#45
Apr 25, 2002
6,082
2,253
113
46
#45
If last year wasn't a fluke for Winn and Alou & Bonds are healthy, you're gonna get at least 100 HR's from your outfield... Is Finley and his 10 extra home runs worth it considering he only gets on base about 20-25% of the time, when Alfonzo can get on 30-35% of the time? And that's not cuz Alfonzo walks a lot more, he just hit better last year...
 
S

Silent-One

Sicc OG
#46
Sep 28, 2002
1,633
3
0
45
#46
Finley will be a great addition to the Giants. If everything goes as planned, Bonds and Alou will play around 120 games and Finley will get to play around 100. Also he would be useful off the bench. Last year was a bad year for Finley due to injury, I don't predict a repeat year. Now Sabean looking at a backup infielder (possibly Aurilla) and a backup catcher. A fifth starter would be nice but there is little to pick from, Wade Miller is now available??? Anyways, the Giants and the Dodgers have improved dramaticly, especially with the Dodgers adding Tomko. HAHA
 
G

G-Dubb

Sicc OG
#47
Apr 25, 2002
6,082
2,253
113
46
#47
Silent-One said:
Last year was a bad year for Finley due to injury
Click to expand...
What injury? He crashed into a wall and hurt his shoulder about halfway through the season... But he sucked before that and sucked after that.
 
BROWN GUERRERO

BROWN GUERRERO

#SFUNITE
#48
Feb 12, 2004
7,488
886
0
38
#48
EVERYONE WANTED ALFONZO GONE. THE DUDE HAS LOST ALL POWER IN HIS SWING AND HAS NO HEART. THAT IS WHY HE IS GONE!! HE IS HORRIBLE AND NOW FELIZ CAN PLAY 3RD FULL TIME!! IT WAS A GARBAGE FOR GARBAGE TRADE.
 
H

herm96

Sicc OG
#50
Sep 12, 2002
3,030
5
38
#50
G-Dubb said:
What injury? He crashed into a wall and hurt his shoulder about halfway through the season... But he sucked before that and sucked after that.
Click to expand...

are saying he sucked when he was dodgers when hit 30 hrs and 90 rbls?
 
H

herm96

Sicc OG
#51
Sep 12, 2002
3,030
5
38
#51
G-Dubb said:
If last year wasn't a fluke for Winn and Alou & Bonds are healthy, you're gonna get at least 100 HR's from your outfield... Is Finley and his 10 extra home runs worth it considering he only gets on base about 20-25% of the time, when Alfonzo can get on 30-35% of the time? And that's not cuz Alfonzo walks a lot more, he just hit better last year...
Click to expand...
yeah it is worth because pedro feliz will get to play full time and have a chance to hit 30 hrs and 100 rbls if BONDS AND ALOU IN LINEUP FULL TIME. if alonzo wasnt traded he would platoon with feliz. you cant sit a 7 million a year player - good or bad.
 
G

G-Dubb

Sicc OG
#52
Apr 25, 2002
6,082
2,253
113
46
#52
Silent-One said:
He hurt his shoulder on the second game.
Click to expand...
He didn't go on the DL til June or July.
herm96 said:
are saying he sucked when he was dodgers when hit 30 hrs and 90 rbls?
Click to expand...
No, but at this age you can't really look back to year before last and expect him to get back to that after a bad year.
 
H

herm96

Sicc OG
#55
Sep 12, 2002
3,030
5
38
#55
yeah it did hopefully finley will do the same to dodgers this year. good luck wiith bret tomko. if he thinks Giants did score any runs fo him, with dodgers it will be worse.
 
H

herm96

Sicc OG
#56
Sep 12, 2002
3,030
5
38
#56
LA Dodgers said:
why not?/

the dodgers sat Todd Hundley a few years back

they also outright released Carlos Perez

and thoswe contract were pretty big
Click to expand...

are u serious, you rather keep bench alozono than have finley. i take my chances with finley.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom