The mysterious departure of Alex Gibbs
Of all the offseason hires by Pete Carroll, the biggest and most ballyhooed was the addition of offensive line coach Alex Gibbs to his Seahawks coaching staff.
Gibbs, 69, was heralded as the guru of zone blocking and one of the most-respected assistants in the NFL.
He was the guy who could take late-round draft picks of marginal talent and mold them into a lean, mean fighting machine that would mow down opposing defensive lines with their cut-blocking skills and open up creases to revive Seattle's ground game.
He was the man excited about the potential of first-round draft pick Russell Okung, the fellow whose familiarity with veteran guard Ben Hamilton made him a perfect fit, the perfectionist who was cussing and yelling and setting a tough tone for Seattle's rebuilding line at every practice.
And then he up and quit, eight days before the regular season opener.
Explanation please?
The Seahawks communications director passed word that Gibbs was "worn out." Carroll said Gibbs merely did what he had to do, but the team and everyone involved was better for the time spent with him this offseason.
GM John Schneider sung his praises and indicated the hard-wired assistant just felt he didn't have enough left in the tank to get through the season.
"What I can tell you is he's a hard-charging, proven, grizzled vet that just felt like he wasn't going to be able to push through," Schneider said.
But there's more to than that, of course. There is a reason Gibbs is worn out. The Seahawks' line is in far more transition that surely he bargained for when he took the job.
The coach who has a reputation for taking players and molding them into his way of doing things kept getting new parts he needed to start over from scratch with.
The club traded for tackles Tyler Polumbus and Stacy Andrews just in the last week, then signed guard Evan Dietrich-Smith. Getting new players ready in short order puts an added burden on assistant coaches who have to tutor and help those newcomers catch up.
Asked about the challenge of so much roster churn, Schneider noted that "if you have a coach and coaching staff that are willing to move forward and teach and put in the extra time to get new players ready, then it can be an extremely exciting period to add players."
That response wasn't specifically about Gibbs, nor was the veteran coach new to the notion of late additions on an NFL roster. It happens everywhere, but rarely to the level the Seahawks are attempting this late in preseason, so it's reasonable to wonder if this situation wasn't exactly what Gibbs thought he was signing up for when he joined Carroll's staff.
It's also worth asking if Gibbs was displeased with the addition of two tackles in Polumbus and Andrews who don't fit his preferred mold of smaller, more athletic types who can run and cut block.
Polumbus is 6-foot-8 and 300 pounds. Andrews checks in at 6-7, 340, and his trade to Seattle was coming down just about the time Gibbs checked out.
Schneider was twice asked Monday during a group interview at Seahawks' headquarters whether that acquisition created a problem for Gibbs. His answers seemed revealing in what he did and didn't say in that regard.
"Alex obviously has a specific criteria for what he believes makes his zone scheme effective," Schneider said. "But there's also bigger zone teams out there. We went through it in Green Bay. We added a guy named Josh Sitton who is 320-some pounds.
"With Stacy, it's a matter of getting bigger and stronger. If you watch the Philadelphia Eagles, they knock people off the ball. In terms of that trade specifically, it kind of kept coming to us and it came to a point where we just felt it would be silly not to do it."
But did Gibbs ever express a desire for a different type of player?
"Sure. Like I said, Alex has a certain criteria," Schneider said. "But you also have to go play football games. So ideally, you know how it is. Ideally I'd have liked to have been a bigger running back. You have to go with what you have to be able to win games."
Gibbs, for all his genius, has a history of not staying anywhere too long.
His NFL resume: three seasons with the Broncos, two with the Raiders, two with the Chargers, one with the Colts, two with the Chiefs, nine with the Broncos again, three with the Falcons, two with the Texans and now six months with the Seahawks.
He's also become more of a consultant in recent years than a full-time assistant coach. His last two seasons with Atlanta were as a consultant, not a coach. He had a similar relationship, though not title, with the Texans.
He got to know Carroll by acting as a consultant at USC about the installation of the zone-blocking scheme.
So it's quite likely that the day-to-day challenges of coaching were grinding down Gibbs, as several people in and around the Seahawks organization say he'd appeared worn down recently.
Now that he's gone, we may never know the exact reasoning. Gibbs disliked talking to reporters even in the best of times, which was too bad because the one occasion he spoke to the media in Seattle was the day of the draft after Russell Okung's selection and he was colorful, entertaining and informative.
For his part, Carroll sung Gibbs' praises as "one of the greats that ever coached in this league," but then said dealing with his departure is "not as drastic as you may think."
Carroll had only figured Gibbs would coach a few years in Seattle, so he'd also brought in long-time NFL assistant Art Valero to be his assistant. Now he's hired former USC assistant Pat Ruel to work with Valero.
Schneider acknowledged the situation "is not ideal," but noted Ruel has background both with himself in Green Bay and Carroll and offensive coordinator Jeremy Bates at USC.
Ruel, who was coaching with the Omaha Nighthawks in the UFL, wasted no time accepting Carroll's new offer, which came Friday night ... just hours after Gibbs said he was quitting.
That's the way the coaching world works. Ruel himself had been jettisoned from Carroll's old staff when Carroll hired Gibbs instead of keeping him on after five years together in Los Angeles.
"I felt like a girlfriend that got left behind, but there were no hard feelings," Ruel said with a chuckle. "There are other dates out there you know? But I love coach. He and I go way back. Sometimes things just work out. Sometimes we all have to go our own directions and I was just fortunate he re-routed my path."
Ruel's response when Carroll got ahold of him in Omaha?
"I told him I was in a three-point stance and my hand was back," said Ruel, referring to the takeoff of a defensive lineman.
As for Gibbs? He's more like a wide receiver at this point, running a fade route into oblivion.
http://blog.seattlepi.com/football/archives/220590.asp