Roy Jones Jr. vs Anderson Silva

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.

who wins in a boxing match?


  • Total voters
    25
May 13, 2002
49,944
47,801
113
44
Seattle
www.socialistworld.net
#1
Well it looks like this actually might go down. Keep in mind while voting that this will be a BOXING match, Not MMA.

:::::
:::::

It seemed like a fantasy, but representatives for UFC middleweight champion Anderson Silva, and former four-division champion Roy Jones Jr., have confirmed to the Associated Press that talks are ongoing for a possible boxing match between the two fighters. The reports notes that negotiations are in the preliminary stages, but both fighters are pushing for the clash to happen.

Alan Hopper, the PR director for Don King, informed the AP that talks are ongoing and Jones is interested in making the fight. According to a report by NBCSports.com, the fight will be an official boxing match and not an exhibition. They would likely meet at a catchweight between 170 and 185-pounds.

The report said a few big hurdles exist. The UFC would have to sign off on the fight, Silva would have to obtain a boxing license from the athletic commission of the hosting state, and both fighters would have to agree on the revenue split. No date or venue has been mentioned. The fight is a lock to land on pay-per-view.

The likely venue would fall in Las Vegas. The executive director for the Nevada State Athletic Commission, Keith Kizer, told NBC Sports that the commission would have to gather a lot of information about Silva's capabilities as a boxer in order to grant a license for a dream bout with Jones.

"It's [Silva's] burden to prove," Kizer said. "He'd be taking on a future Hall of Famer in Roy Jones. There's no question he can get licensed to box, the question is the matchup. We'd have to look at his training, his background, his history and gather the facts before a decision."

Silva has a mixed-martial-arts record of 21–4 (which includes a 6–0 run in the UFC). Jones has a career record of 52-4 with 38 knockouts. He's a former middleweight, super middleweight, light heavyweight and heavyweight champion.
 
May 13, 2002
49,944
47,801
113
44
Seattle
www.socialistworld.net
#2
Seems like this would be a pretty big event. Would you be interested in the PPV?

Personally I think Roy Jones is waaaaaay past his prime, but still good enough to kick the shit out of a non-professional boxer. Silva is the best at what he does and he is a good boxer (his pro record is 1-1) but I don't see him beating jones unless he lands one luck shot
 
Dec 9, 2005
11,231
31
0
41
#3
Just for the sheer premise of the fight: One of the best MMA fighters on the planet, with one of the best boxers to ever lace 'em up..

Yes !

I would order this..

I don't think Silva stands a chance, but I applaud him for being willing to take the fight. Roy hasn't looked too bad in his last few...I wouldn't say he's over the hill at all...he's in great shape. And Silva is pretty much in his physical prime as well.
 
Nov 24, 2003
6,307
3,639
113
#4
I think this could be pretty interesting but I think its stupid that its only boxing.

IMO, if anything they should should fight MMA because its more of a pure fight vs boxing which has more regulations namely only being able to punch.

It would be tight (pretty unrealistic though) if they traded off rounds.
1-boxing
2-mma
3-boxing
4-mma

The fighters would have a hell of a time remembering what round they were in lol.
 
Dec 9, 2005
11,231
31
0
41
#5
I don't think it would ever be MMA...and only think its boxing because Silva was a pro boxer, I believe he even has a couple wins to his name...so its not that much of a transition for him, as it would be if Roy were to have to learn MMA from scratch.
 
Mar 25, 2005
3,801
2,001
113
#7
ALSO KEEP IN MIND THAT WITH STRIKING HIS KNEES AND KICKS ARE HIS STRONG POINT NOT HIS HANDS....THAT AND THE FACT THAT THE BIGGER GLOVES IS GOING TO DIMINISH ALOT OF HIS POWER = LOSS FOR SILVA.....IF HES ANY GOOD AT BOXING HE MIGHT MAKE IT PAST 4.
 
May 13, 2002
49,944
47,801
113
44
Seattle
www.socialistworld.net
#8
Imagine if Silva beat him. It would make boxing look bad.
yeah it would. That's why past his prime Roy Jones isn't exactly the greatest ambassador of the sport at the moment. Imo, Bernard Hopkins or Chad Dawson would be better suited since they are at the top of the Light Heavyweight division. But still, I think Jones shouldn't have any problems since he's been boxing for close to 30 years. Other than a huge pay day, it's a no win situation for Jones - if he wins the fight, well it only proves that MMA fighters cant win in boxing, everyone will just shrug it off and know if it was MMA Silva would have one, if Jones loses he'll get clowned on and it will damage the sport of boxing (probably).

@Mr. Nice Guy, it wouldn't work for mma because Jones has zero experience with that whereas Silva was a pro boxer for a short period of time and is one of the better, if not best, boxers in MMA. Plus, he's the one that called out Jones and challenged him to a boxing match (actually I think he said at first he wanted to fight the champion (Jones isn't a champ) and eventially Roy Jones name came up).
 
May 24, 2006
6,242
8
0
36
www.fucku.com
#12
daaaaamn, id def watch it!

yesterday they was playin all the old fights n shit, it was pretty dope to watch. roy jones jr fought but i forget who? same wit holifield too.

im not that big into boxing but i still like to watch it whenever i get a chance.
 
Jan 5, 2006
13,536
3,427
0
36
#15
i think silva can win by decision... silva is younger probably has better conditioning.. but roy jones likes to taunt alot if silva doesnt fall for most of it he could pull out a decision.

wouldnt it be a fucked up fight to have a draw? haha.
 
Aug 31, 2003
5,551
3,189
113
www.ebay.com
#16
I think this could be pretty interesting but I think its stupid that its only boxing.

IMO, if anything they should should fight MMA because its more of a pure fight vs boxing which has more regulations namely only being able to punch.

It would be tight (pretty unrealistic though) if they traded off rounds.
1-boxing
2-mma
3-boxing
4-mma

The fighters would have a hell of a time remembering what round they were in lol.
Anderson is the one that pursued this fight not the other way around. He said he wanted to fight Roy Jones. Jones never mentioned Anderson at all before that so they should fight boxing.

That being said I don't think there's any way possible for Silva to win this. Look what happened to Ray Sefo, an elite level K-1 kickboxer who was known for having a monster chin in K-1 ..



^~~ Got completely blasted in one round by Chester Hughes.

.. Mark Hunt couldn't make it past 3-6 boxer and then fought to a draw in his next bout.

.. Marcus Davis fought to a draw with a 10-11-4 boxer and then got stopped by 10-6 Ed Bryant.

Anderson Silva is great at what he does but when you take out his knees/elbows/kicks he's just a guy with decent. If Silva could find some kind of way to beat Jones even with his age I would be highly impressed.
 
Jan 5, 2006
13,536
3,427
0
36
#17
cant really say that offa one dude tho.. everyones different thats why upsets happen.. because people think one thing happened to this guy so it will for the next guy. It all depends on the person's training, motivation and hunger to win.
 
Aug 31, 2003
5,551
3,189
113
www.ebay.com
#18
cant really say that offa one dude tho.. everyones different thats why upsets happen.. because people think one thing happened to this guy so it will for the next guy. It all depends on the person's training, motivation and hunger to win.
I listed several examples and there's plenty others. I'm not saying Anderson Silva can't beyond the realm of possibility win I just think it's highly unlikely and the odds are against. Roy Jones has trained boxing and ONLY boxing for years and years. Anderson Silva has trained several different forms of combat throughout his life while Jones perfected one.

I don't expect Anderson to compete in Abu Dhabi and submit Jacare or even beat him on points just because his grappling has been great recently in MMA competition.
 
Dec 9, 2005
11,231
31
0
41
#19
Roy is in phenomenal condition, not just for his age. He went 12 rounds in his last fight, granted it was against a much smaller Tito, but he didn't seem the least bit tired.

I do not think conditioning will be a factor for either guy.
 
Feb 12, 2004
7,488
886
0
38
#20
Even if RJJ beat Silva by a close decision i'd consider it a victory for Silva. Remember Silva challenged the "185 boxing champion" because he was tired of critics saying MMA fighters were not technical. I don't think any MMA fighter can go in the ring and out box a boxer(vice versa with MMA), but if anyone can do it for sure it's Anderson Silva.



I doubt Dana lets this fight take place any who.