Gamefly can eat a dick IMO. I tried to join up with them back in the day and they told me that I couldn't open an account with them because someone at the same addy had a dispute with them over a game years previously. Turned out it was my cousin and the "dispute" was that they hadn't received a game following him canceling the service. He says he definitely sent the game.
With a neon colored, clearly labeled envelope like Gamefly has, and with it going through so many hands before it reaches its destination, it's no wonder those 60 dollar items get stolen. Meanwhile, they told me at first that they couldn't ship to my addy because of the "dispute". I was like "so for as long as this address exists, nobody that lives here will ever be able to use your service? She said that my last name was too similar. I got out of her the name, the issue in dispute, and the year.
So I got a whole grip of private information from this woman just by asking a few questions. There were times in the discussion that I could tell she wasn't allowed to answer some of the questions, and when I said "Basically you're not allowed to give out that info and so you can't tell me", I was told "yes", and just by her tone I was being given answers.
So that service is pretty sketchy for a number of reasons.
Either way I'm still think the BB service sounds worth it for 9 bucks a month. Even if the supply of new releases is low, there's always going to be at least one decent older game I haven't played that I'd pay more than 9 bucks for at Gamestop.