As of your list I'd say...
Watchmen - sucked -- Agreed. It looked great but overall the movie was awful.
Star Trek - sucked -- I actually liked this and I'm not a Star Trek fan at all. Will I buy it, no, but I did like it.
The Hangover - funny -- Agreed. The funniest R-rated comedy this year so far.
Drag Me To Hell - pretty good -- I liked this a lot actually. I think a lot of people went in expecting something else.
Wolverine - sucked -- From what I saw of it (probably like 75%) it was awful.
Transformers II - pathetic -- Agreed 100%. It didn't surprise me that most on here thought it was amazing and I don't think I need to say why.
Angels & Demons - faggotry -- Didn't even bother watching it and won't be anytime soon.
The Unborn - pathetic -- Never had the desire to see it.
Terminator salvation - not impressed -- I thought it was "ok" at best.
Knowing - haha he made this movie like 8 times now -- Haven't seen it and thought it looked stupid as hell.
Observe & Report - FAIL -- I really wanted to like this movie but couldn't and thought it was awful.
Paul Blart: Mall cop - didn't I just watch this movie? FAIL -- Never wanted to see it.
I Love You, Man - haven't seen it yet -- It was better then I thought it would be which isn't saying much. Maybe when it hits the free movies on demand give it a watch.
Bronson - best movie so far -- I liked it a lot but I don't know if I'd say the best so far.
I'm not going to even get into what I didn't like but chances are I saw it as I watch almost everything that comes out. Here are movies worth checking that I've seen this year. I might be forgetting one or two.
Coraline -- I thought the film looked amazing and I liked it a lot in 3D which I usually hate. NOTE: This is not a Tim Burton movie.
Up -- Yes, another animated movie. Unlike Coraline this one is CGI and I thought it was great and I still feel that 90% of CGI should only be used in animated movies unless totally warranted.
The Brothers Bloom -- Great movie. Probably my favorite so far that actually came out this year (see below.)
Gomorra -- Amazing movie. Probably my favorite this year. It had very limited release in the US in 2008 and it came to the theatre by me in Feb. 2009 so I'm counting it for this year. Fuck you.
Dead Snow -- It's about Nazi zombies so what's not to love? Very cheesy but I enjoyed it and laughed a lot.
The Hurt Locker -- Really good film. Google it if you want to know what it's about.
Moon -- A very solid film by David Bowie's son of all people. Sam Rockwell is great in the movie.
Ummm, I think that's all I have to add.
Films that I'm interested in seeing are, Shutter Island, Funny People, Extract, Cold Souls, Inglourious Basterds, Fantastic Mr. Fox, Five Minutes of Heaven, World's Greatest Dad, Where the Wild Things Are, and Antichrist. Add Big Fan to that list.
This thread would go great in some sort of movie forum.