@already dead,
Firstly, I would like to state that I appreciate the fact that you responded kindly to my post...Unlike others who feel it necessary to insult one for their beliefs.
Secondly, I respect all of your opinions.
Next, I think we need to get one thing straight before we continue any further. When I speak of “communism” I am referring to what Marx/Engles created. I am also speaking of what Lenin/Trotsky fought so hard for. I am not speaking about Stalin, Mao, Castro, or any current communist leaders/countries.
“206, You sound good in theory. The problem is poverty, ignorance, racism, and inequality have existed since the dawn of man. And no economic system has ever changed that. Look at communist China. They posess the largest surplus of labor and human resources ever in the history of mankind, however they don't do more than get by. The promise of bread and water does not drive technology and advancement upward.”
Communist China is not a communist country. They may claim to be, but the fact is they are far away from the original beliefs of Marx/Engles.
I agree that poverty, ignorance, racism, and inequality have existed since the dawn of man and no economic system has ever changed that. That is why I label myself a “communist.” I strongly believe that in a communist society, much of those problems would be dramatically decreased. In a capitalist society, it is essential that these factors exist.
“How would communism be implemented in the U.S.? It wouldn't.”
It could only by revolution. I have stated before that communism is a long process. It isn’t something that can just happen over night. Karl Marx preached this. Lenin and Trotsky knew this.
“Communism has never been successful on a large scale. It may not have totally collapsed in the case of countries like China or North Korea, but it doesn't exactly produce the most industrious and successful societies ever, like you are saying.”
The simple fact is never has a communist country existed. The closest thing to it was the USSR for a very short time before Lenin died. The collapse of the Soviet Union did not start in the 80’s; it was in fact when Stalin took over.
“Communism would only really benefit the dirt poor. And the U.S., per capita, has the least poor of any country in the world. And those poor have it alot better than anywhere else. They have options like recieving welfare, sitting on the street and begging, or living on AFDC housing. Compare this to any third world country, where getting a meal involves beating up the kid down the street for it, making a weekly wage that is comparable to the wage for one half hour of work in America. That is the reality of the rest of the world. The fact that America is so rich just allows us to sit around and look at our poor like they have it the worst of anyone ever, when in fact this is not the case at all.”
I disagree. I believe communism would benefit mankind. If in fact the U.S has the least amount of poor people in the world, per capita, (Which I do not believe) and these people have so many benefits, (Which I also do not believe) why is it such a problem in our society? Wouldn’t you prefer a country that takes care of these people and does there best to make sure that there are not poor people?
“You seem to be someone with good ideals. You have a good goal in mind in supporting Communism. The problem is, how are you going to know that everyone in our new communist government is going to feel the same way.”
I would know the majority of the people “feel the same way” because it would actually be the people of amerika that implement it. Like I said, communism isn’t something that just happens. It occurs when the working class unites and has a revolution.
“If Communism produces the largest sharing of information and technological advancements, then why aren't all communist countries advancing at speeds faster than capitalist ones?.”
Two reasons; a true communist country never existed, and the countries that claimed to be communist sure as hell didn’t get any help from amerika. Quite the opposite occurred. Amerika did everything that they could to make sure they did not advance. Don’t you remember the “War on communism?”
“Money makes people work harder. Greed makes the world go round. What is likely to motivate someone better, a hundred dollars, or the opportunity to help an old lady accross the street? Yes, some people would like to help the old lady, but in the long run, humans are really concerned with their own situation. Does this mean all capitalist societies are greedy, uncaring, and diabolical? No. They just know how the system works, and how to use it.”
In our society, that is true. Money and greed are the key tools to survive. It might be shocking to you, but not all humans feel the same way. And I’m not talking about just people here in Amerika, I’m talking about people all over the world, especially ones who live in completely different cultures then ours. Money and greed are not something that humans are born with. They are only taught that money is everything. It is in fact Capitalism that teaches this. Dog eat dog. Kill or be killed. Wouldn’t you rather live in a “Man help man, Son teach son” world?