Some mentioned The Walking Dead.
I just picked it up for 360 after the PS3 version kept freezing on me. The 360 version lags in between scenes too. But at least it's playable. It was a rushed game for sure, but the story line is strong.
I gotta say, there aren't many games out there that will get me pissed off if I make the wrong decision. The Walking Dead is one of those games. Just hope you get a copy that plays.