Favre - Greatest QB of All Time???

[Tony]

I agree with those who said Montana or Manning. Personally I think that Peyton Manning is the best of all time... I know he's only won one SuperBowl but man he shredds defenses apart. And that comeback against New England last year put him up there with the best that has ever played.

 

[IronLungs420]

1. Montana
2. Young
3.John Elway
4.Tom Brady
5.Peyton Manning
6.Brett Farve
7.Troy Aikmen
8.ALEX SMITH-JK

 

[T-Rip]

When its all said and done Peyton will be at the top with Montana in 2nd then Elway, then Marino, then Farve. the main reason farve aint higher is to many ints.

 

[IronLungs420]

When its all said and done Peyton will be at the top with Montana in 2nd then Elway, then Marino, then Farve. the main reason farve aint higher is to many ints.

MONTANA>peytonTHEbitchMANNING

 

[AleX510]

^^ This coming from a guy who ranked Brady above Manning... I personally believe Brady is a bit over rated regardless of his 3 SB's.

 

[Solitary 1]

I knew somebody was gonna hate on Young in this thread.

CORRECTION: YOU KNEW I WAS GONNA HATE ON YOUNG. HE'S OVERRATED AS FUCK.

BEST EVER IMO:

MONTANA
FAVRE
MARINO
ELWAY
STABLER
AND MANNING IS WELL ON HIS WAY

 

[jay deuce]

Marino is better than Farve.

 

[Skizzy Ske]

ya, peyton is def climbing the up ladder, as well as brady.

 

[FATAL NYGHTMARE]

CORRECTION: YOU KNEW I WAS GONNA HATE ON YOUNG.

Well, you are somebody. Don't sell yourself short Solitary.

LOL

HE'S OVERRATED AS FUCK.

How is he overrated, but not Montana? They both had great surrounding casts. Young ended up with the highest passer rating in NFL history. Overrated? I think not. Montana did have 4 SuperBowls, but 3 of them were under the great Bill Walsh so that has to count for something.

I think they were both great QBs. You obviously don't like Steve Young for whatever reason, but he definately is not overrated.

AND MANNING IS WELL ON HIS WAY

The way Manning controls every aspect of his offense makes me think he already may be the best QB of all time. But I'll let his career play out first..

 

[Tony]

Well, you are somebody. Don't sell yourself short Solitary.

LOL



How is he overrated, but not Montana? They both had great surrounding casts. Young ended up with the highest passer rating in NFL history. Overrated? I think not. Montana did have 4 SuperBowls, but 3 of them were under the great Bill Walsh so that has to count for something.

I think they were both great QBs. You obviously don't like Steve Young for whatever reason, but he definately is not overrated.


The way Manning controls every aspect of his offense makes me think he already may be the best QB of all time. But I'll let his career play out first..

I am thinking the same about Manning.

 

[ColdBlooded]

^^ This coming from a guy who ranked Brady above Manning... I personally believe Brady is a bit over rated regardless of his 3 SB's.

This coming from the "guy" who wouldn't even post up a list of his ranked QB's.

 

[LurccH918]

1.Montana
2.Elway
3.Marino
4.Favre
5.Bradshaw
6.Staubach
7.Unitas
8.Namath
9.Aikman
10.Starr