Kelly Pavlik: Time to Step Aside, Vacate The Crown?
By Cliff Rold
Be careful of wishes which come true.
Heading into his 2007 defense against Kelly Pavlik, then-World Middleweight champion Jermain Taylor was taking his lumps. He’d captured and kept the title from modern legend Bernard Hopkins in controversial fashion. Following Hopkins, he defended against a Winky Wright who had won eleven straight and unified the Jr. Middleweight division. The result was a draw with arguments on both sides about the result.
Taylor followed with what passed for soft touches. A defense against former Jr. Middleweight titlist Kasim Ouma and former undisputed World Welterweight champion Cory Spinks produced wins but nothing aesthetically pleasing. In none of these fights, from Hopkins to Spinks, did Taylor look the part of gilded star he’d been built, largely on HBO, to play. The critics were howling and the fans were losing patience. It was time for Taylor to be THE champ or be pushed aside.
In stepped Kelly Pavlik. Hot off a pair of electrifying knockouts over contenders Jose Luis Zertuche and Edison Miranda, Pavlik emerged as the quality contender to make or break Taylor’s reign. Surviving a trip to the floor in round two, Pavlik broke it in round seven.
Inside the Atlantic City Boardwalk Hall on September 29, 2007, it was bedlam. Fans had been treated to a minor classic and what appeared to be the birth of a star. A rematch with Taylor or potential war with the best Middleweight only the hardcore fans were really clued in on, Arthur Abraham, loomed.
Following the Taylor knockout, Team Pavlik sounded all the right notes. They said they’d face the Abraham’s, the Felix Sturm’s. They talked about getting Pavlik’s blue collar, big punching, Youngstown, Ohio story to the masses.
A push for network TV.
High activity.
The Middleweight king the world asked for.
On October 21, 2009, 27-year old Kelly Pavlik’s team announced the latest of what have been multiple postponements and cancellations this year. A nasty staph infection in his left hand has taken a highly anticipated defense against Paul Williams off the table for the second time this year.
The pictures from their kick-off press conference back up the medical dilemma. Something is clearly wrong with Pavlik’s hand. However, something went wrong before this latest setback.
So wrong that it makes the title reign of Taylor qualify as the good ol’ days.
In over two years, Pavlik has defended the title only twice and against opposition which makes Spinks look like Godzilla. Part of the issue has been fights outside the division.
Fans got the Taylor rematch of course in February 2008; not a bad start. It was a catchweight fight above 160 lbs., but that was a contract issue and Pavlik won an entertaining decision. However, the fight was on pay-per-view and did a pedestrian buy rate, doing no good for the building of a star. His other catchweight bout, similarly pedestrian in terms of buys, came in October of last year. Thinking former champion then-43 year old Bernard Hopkins an aging name, coming off a loss to Joe Calzaghe, Pavlik was put in position to finish a legend.
He lost every round.
The shine was off the rising star and, making matters worse, more people heard about it then saw it. He could take condolences in still being the Middlewight champ.
Not much worth noting has happened in that role, before or after Hopkins. Gary Lockett and Marco Antonio Rubio aren’t names which roll off the tongue but they were mandatory contenders, for what that’s worth a lot of the time. They are Pavlik’s lone defenses, the latter on a pay show which made Taylor II and Hopkins look massive. The planned follow-up to Rubio, former Jr. Middleweight titlist and Contender Season One winner Sergio Mora, was no more tantalizing. Mora would have challenged coming off a lopsided loss to the late Vernon Forrest which exposed massive limitations.
The fight never came off, the first cancellation/postponement due to Pavlik’s hand problems. With no one besides Mora really interested in a Pavlik-Mora fight anyways, the talk turned to Pavlik-Paul Williams (37-1, 27 KO). It was supposed to happen over the summer 0f 2009. Then it was scheduled for December 5.
Now it isn’t scheduled at all.
It is probably the case that no one, save Williams, is more frustrated right now than Pavlik. While aspersions will be cast, while claims of ‘fright’ and ‘duck’ will roar, a slow healing infection is what it is. If the Pavlik camp has sinned, it is in continuing to schedule fights before they know, rather than just hope, they’re good to go.
There is a question to consider while the healing continues.
Pavlik is the champion at 160 lbs. He beat the man who beat the man to claim the lineage of the crown. Ring Magazine issued a new belt for further recognition. And, hey, there really isn’t anyone to dispute the claim in a class which isn’t at an uptick right now.
That doesn’t mean there are not others who would not like to make a case. Williams plays between 154 and 160 lbs. while Sturm (33-2-1, 14 KO) currently holds the WBA belt and a win over IBF titlist Sebastian Sylvester (32-3, 15 KO). Of course Sturm, who is going through major promotional issues right now, probably should have lost in his last defense against Khoren Gevor (30-4, 16 KO), another fighter who’d like a say.
Should Pavlik (35-1, 31 KO), who cannot be sure when he will be healthy enough to fight again, step aside and let these men sort it out?
Should Pavlik vacate the Middleweight crown?
It’s a tricky question of course. Fighters have vacated Ring belts to symbolically release the lineage in the past but Pavlik also reigns as the WBC and WBO titlist. Inactivity could eventually force those belts vacant without his say or at least force interim title situations.
Pavlik hasn’t been out of the ring a whole year yet, so the question is hasty. If he is healthy and ready to go at the New Year (his people floated a rejected January 23, 2010 rescheduling with Williams), Pavlik can right the ship. If he can’t, if he can’t be sure he can, then the right thing to do is step down until certainty rules.
This isn’t just any weight class. Middleweight is a key piece of the legacy of the sport, the land of Monzon, Greb, Hagler. It has lived with parity before in the absence of a king. While he has stated in the past that he’d like all the belts to feel secure in the spot, history labels Pavlik with the top spot. It’s his to lose in the ring or give up voluntarily.
It would be insane to wish Pavlik anything less than a full recovery, return to action, and a chance to fulfill the potential he showed in 2007.
There’s nothing wrong with needing to get healthy when one is not, particularly in a savage field like boxing.
But there is something wrong with holding up the show.
No decision need be made now, but the time could be approaching.
The Weekly Ledger
But wait, there’s more…
Top 25 Lightweights Pt. 2:
http://www.boxingscene.com/index.php?m=show&id=22968
Super Six Wrap:
http://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=22925
Picks of the Week:
http://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=22942
Cliff’s Notes…
All Super Six here…Count me among those who saw the Froch-Dirrell fight for Froch, if only by a single point. Dirrell’s split decision loss to one of the top three in class wasn’t enough to get him rated by Ring with the rationale that Dirrell lacks a top ten win and they don’t rate on “potential.” It’s an interesting argument until one looks at the #6 slot at 168 and finds Allan Green. Green, if he eventually replaces Jermain Taylor in the Super Six, will enter like Dirrell and Ward: in search of a top ten win…Nothing against Green who would be a welcome addition to the field if Jermain Taylor does not continue. While he looked blah his last time out, Green would bring a power dimension sorely lacking among the Americans right now…Promoter Dan Goosen’s idea of Green having a ‘box-in’ against Edison Miranda should be pushed aside. Let’s say Miranda won and, presumably, stepped in for Taylor. We’d all be treated to Miranda-Andre Ward II. Super Six? No, that would super suck…This all presumes a Taylor exit and the former Middleweight champ has earned the right to determine his own fate here