Pound for Pound Top-Ten; Marquez Forces Realignment
By Cliff Rold
Following Antonio Margarito’s devastating knockout win over Miguel Cotto in July, the pound-for-pound ratings were shaken up. Now a Mexican countryman of Margarito’s, new World Lightweight champion Juan Manuel Marquez, has forced yet another fresh look. Heading into the fourth and final quarter of 2008, Marquez’s knockout win over Cuba’s Joel Casamayor provided one of the defining highlights in a career which expands its definitions regularly in twilight.
Marquez had been rated variably in the eighth and ninth spots since September of 2007. It wasn’t a wildly popular choice with some readers who see gaps between spots on lists like this one where only eyelashes worth of distance exist. Those readers might well be pleased here…and with some big names and big fights yet to hear their opening bell, further shake-ups can be expected in the near future.
Let’s consult the Boxing Scene Pound for Pound ratings in the wake of Marquez-Casamayor
Let’s consult the Boxing Scene Pound for Pound ratings in the wake of Marquez-Casamayor.
1) Manny Pacquiao (46-3-2, 35 KO’S)
Age: 29
Current Titles: Alphabelt at Lightweight/135 lbs.
Career Titles: Lineal World Flyweight/112 lb. champion (1998-99); World Featherweight/126 lb. champion (2003-2005); World Jr. Lightweight/130 lb. champion (2008); additional alphabelts at 112, 122, &130 lbs.
Last Five Opponents: David Diaz, Juan Manuel Marquez, Marco Antonio Barrera, Jorge Solis, Erik Morales (thrice)
Next Opponent: December 6, 2008 vs. Oscar De La Hoya (39-5, 30 KO)
The Take: Pacquiao has been a minority favorite for the top spot for the better part of the last two years. With Diaz destroyed in June, this spot is further solidified and there really shouldn’t be much debate. While the man one step behind him has had one hell of a career, Pacquiao is what a pound-for-pound king ought to be. He has defied the scale in a way that only Hall of Famers like Henry Armstrong, Roberto Duran, Fidel LaBarba, Fighting Harada and Jimmy McLarnin compare to and Pacquiao’s success grows closer to Armstrong and Duran by the fight. He is the only man in history to win the lineal Flyweight, Featherweight, and Jr. Lightweight crowns, and very soon could challenge to be the first man the first four-division lineal World champion in history. Before he gets there in possible fights with Marquez or Jr. Welterweight king Ricky Hatton, he gets an Oscar and the question is already being asked: if he loses as just about everyone suspects he will, can he still hold this spot? It’s an interesting debate. The early impulse is to say wait and see. If Oscar wins this hand-picked vanity fight by blowout, it would be hard to justify the heights but if the fight is close, if it is genuinely competitive, then the ridiculous size difference present has to be a consideration even in a Pacquiao defeat. Of course Manny could always win and make the point moot, but most likely scenarios are more important considerations. Former Flyweight champions don’t often beat elite level guys, even over the hill ones like Oscar, who started near the Lightweight limit and peaked at Welterweight. If he can do it then, older names then those listed, names like Langford, will start coming up in the hyperbole of it all.
2) Joe Calzaghe (45-0, 32 KO)
Age: 36
Current Title: World Super Middlweight/168 lb. Champion (2006-Present); Ring Magazine Light Heavyweight titlist
Career Titles: Alphabelt titles at 168 lbs. since 1997
Last Five Opponents: Bernard Hopkins, Mikkel Kessler, Peter Manfredo, Sakio Bika, Jeff Lacy
Next Opponent: November 11, 2008 vs. Roy Jones Jr. (52-4, 38 KO)
The Take: He always said he wanted to come to the U.S. for a big name foe. In April, he got just that in defeating former World Middleweight champion Bernard Hopkins at Light Heavyweight. It wasn’t a thrilling fight, but it was an important one in furthering the bona fides of Calzaghe that have been too questioned outside of his native Wales. In the bout, he did something no one else has ever done. He adjusted to Hopkins late and won it down the stretch, something that Hopkins has staked as his territory over the years. Add to the Hopkins win two more against undefeated and younger foes (Lacy and Kessler) many favored to defeat him and Calzaghe’s plaque in Canastota is finally, fully guaranteed. He isn’t long for the game at 36, and he regularly talks retirement, but one has to wonder if he’ll be able to resist a big-money fight in 2009 with Kelly Pavlik should he blow by the faded Roy Jones as expected. Pavlik is the sort of challenge that could silence, forever, any lingering doubts about Calzaghe’s greatness even if there really shouldn’t be any.
3) Juan Manuel Marquez (49-4-1, 36 KO)
Age: 35
Current Title: World Lightweight Champion (2008-Present)
Career Titles: Alphabet titles at 126, 130 lbs.
Last Five Opponents: Joel Casamayor, Manny Pacquiao, Rocky Juarez, Marco Antonio Barrera, Jimrex Jaca
Next Opponent: TBA
The Take: Is it possible the Casamayor win could get a little overrated? Perhaps, but it certainly thinned the eyelash. Casamayor entered the ring aged 37 years after all and should have lost his title almost one year ago against Jose Armando Santa Cruz. That said, Casamayor looked good in March, stopping Michael Katsidis, and looked even better against the better Marquez. Marquez, no spring chicken himself, won anyways in a balanced battle of body and mind, becoming the first man to stop Casamayor after bigger, presumably harder hitting men like Jose Luis Castillo, Acelino Freitas, and the late Diego Corrales could not. Marquez, in his first fight at Lightweight and only his fifth above Featherweight since moving up permanently in 2007, dismantled Casamayor with precision punching and guts. Those were big left hands cutting into him all night, from a bigger man, and Marquez would not relent. It’s impressive when one remembers he weighed only 124 ½ for Jimrex Jaca less than two years ago. In victory, he picks up his first lineal World title after just missing out on the distinction at 126 and 130 lbs., cursed on both occasions by the excellent Pacquiao. A third fight with Manny would be next in a world of best-cases but Marquez lives in a world where his promoter and a promotional stable mate, Ricky Hatton, are getting and then are more likely to get the opportunity he desires. In the meantime, he probably can look forward to a showdown with young former titlist Juan Diaz and questions of when he might consider settling the issue of Lightweight supremacy with multi-belted titlist Nate Campbell. “blah blah blah Don King…” isn’t a good enough response in regards to Campbell. Two questions remain: why lower than Calzaghe? Answer: Hopkins was, is and always has been better than Casamayor and Calzaghe’s decade of dominance prior to Hopkins is hard to ignore. The other question: considering the mutually shared training from Nacho Beristain, is Marquez what Ricardo Lopez would have looked like had he been blessed with a tad more size? Fans can debate that one amongst themselves, but it would be hard to imagine Lopez could have looked much better.
4) Israel Vasquez (43-4, 31 KO)
Age: 30
Current Title: World Jr. Featherweight/122 lb. Champion (2007-Present)
Career Titles: World Jr. Featherweight (2005-2007); additional alphabelts at 122 lbs.
Last Five Opponents: Rafael Marquez (thrice), Jhonny Gonzalez, Ivan Hernandez, Oscar Larios, Armando Guerrero
Next Opponent: TBA
The Take: Vasquez was for years one of those incredible crowd-pleasers that few thought of as one of the very best in the game until one day he just was. Now, having left fans in awe after an all-time great thrillogy with Marquez, Vasquez goes from working class toughie to shoe-in Hall of Famer. Suddenly, the trilogy against Larios, the up from the deck win over Gonzalez in 2006…it all just means more. There can never be a discussion of the great Jr. Featherweights without him. Vasquez is proof that hard work and balls are just as important as natural athleticism in the ring. What’s next for him is unknown but as long as it nets him a solid check he’s earned it. It might be selfish, but hoping for a showdown one day with the emergent Juan Manuel Lopez is forgivable. No matter what, Vasquez can know forever that a fighter once rarely thought of will never be forgotten.
5) Cristian Mijares (36-3-2, 15 KO)
Age: 26
Current Title: Alphabelts at Jr. Bantamweight/115 lbs. since 2006
Last Five Opponents: Chatchai Sasakul, Alexander Munoz, Jose Navarro, Franck Gorjux, Teppei Kikui
Next Opponent: November 1, 2008 vs. Vic Darchinyan (30-1-1, 24 KO)
The Take: The WBC titlist Mijares was his typical bit of technical excellence in wresting the WBA belt at 115 lbs. from Alexander Munoz in May, the first unification bout in the division in over a decade. Mijares hasn’t lost since 2002 and has been on a tear of late with wins over former World champions Katsushige Kawashima (at 115) and Jorge Arce (at 108). Add to that a near shutout over former U.S. Olympian Jose Navarro and what’s left is a ring surgeon at the peak of his game willing to test it. His combination of deft footwork, subtle defense and sharp counterpunching is as good as any fighter alive. He stands out as the best choice for best in class at a weight that stands out as one of the best in Boxing right now. The only man with a serious argument against that claim is WBO titlist Fernando Montiel, and a showdown between the two is one of the best in the sport. It waits. Now that Mijares has finished the expected easy business of former World Flyweight champion Sasakul, whom he defeated in three one-sided rounds in August, he heads towards further unification with the IBF titlist Darchinyan. The awkwardness and power of Darchinyan will provide different tests then the power of Kawashima, Arce and Munoz did, but given his penchant for defusing bombers he’ll enter as a favorite. Win and he’ll have a very strong case for Fighter of the Year in 2008 and be in one of the strongest positions of anyone on this list to make a play for the very top in 2009.
6) Antonio Margarito (37-5, 27 KO)
Age: 30
Current Title: Alphabelt at Welterweight/147 lbs.
Career Titles: Two additional alphabelts at Welterweight
Last Five Opponents: Miguel Cotto, Kermit Cintron, Golden Johnson, Paul Williams, Joshua Clottey
Next Opponent: TBA
The Take: The best Welterweight in the world right now is the man who rules the undisputed best weight class in Boxing. That appears to be Margarito right now. The remaining non-believers in this rugged warrior have caught the fever after Maragarito went Monsterito on previous BoxingScene #4 Miguel Cotto. After years of being the steady force just beneath the top of the ladder, Margarito now stands (almost) entirely alone atop the Welterweight ladder. It wasn’t just that he beat Cotto; from the sixth round forward, he laid waste to the game but outmatched Puerto Rican star. The only thing preventing Margarito from wearing the crown alone is one Paul Williams. Margarito’s only loss in the division this decade came in narrow fashion to Williams last August. The rematch can’t come soon enough. Margarito gets the nod for this list over Williams because, even with the loss, his total body of work is deeper and more impressive. After the Cotto win, Margarito is 8-1 with six knockouts against Ring Magazine top ten contenders at 147 lbs. since 2002. Williams is 2-1, having split two fights with Carlos Quintana.
7) Ivan Calderon (32-0, 6 KO)
Age: 33
Current Title: World Jr. Flyweight/108 lb. Champion (2007-Present)
Career Titles: Additional alphabelts at 105 & 108 lbs.
Last Five Opponents: Hugo Cazares (twice), Nelson Dieppa, Juan Esquer, Ronald Barrera, Jose Luis Varela
Next Opponent: TBA
The Take: You’ll read from many a knowledgeable scribe that this diminutive Puerto Rican champion ‘might be the best pure boxer in the sport.’ Calderon can do it all in the ring short of knock opponents dead, making his inability to lose thus far all the more remarkable. His game is all skill with just enough thrill (usually) to make his fights worth watching; this is no Sven Ottke. After years as the uncrowned king at 105 lbs., Calderon outboxed and outgutted a much larger (at the opening bell) Cazares in August 2007 to cement his foothold among the game’s elite by capturing the World title at 108 lbs. The similarly small Ricardo Lopez was marvelously underrated for years of his prime; no need to make that mistake twice with Calderon facing the near end of his. His easy win over fellow Puerto Rican Dieppa was okay but Calderon’s biggest tests could come from excellent WBC titlist Ulises Solis. The test some thought he might get in the August rematch with Cazares never unfolded. Calderon built a strong lead through the first half before a headbutt split his forehead open and sent the bout to the cards. It was bad enough to keep him out of the ring again until 2009 and it’s easy to ask how much longer his legs can keep him winning as the calendar stalks them.
8) Rafael Marquez (37-5, 33 KO)
Age: 33
Current Title: World Jr. Featherweight (2007)
Career Titles: Alphabelt at Bantamweight/118 lbs.
Last Five Opponents: Israel Vasquez (thrice), Silence Mabuza, Ricardo Vargas, Mauricio Pastrana, Heriberto Ruiz
Next Opponent: TBA
The Take: Marquez had the better resume prior to his rivalry with Vasquez and, even in losing 2 of 3, all he’s done is add to the shine. After three early career stoppage losses that might have doomed him to be just “Juan Manuel’s brother,” Marquez found his way into the ring in 2001 and 02 with American Flyweight great Mark Johnson. Johnson was his first great rival and Marquez ended Johnson’s prime while emerging victorious in both those bouts. In 2003, he ended the run of another solid American, then-undefeated bantamweight Tim Austin, annexing the IBF belt at 118 lbs. in the process. Seven title defenses later, he stood out as one of the best Bantamweights to come around since the 1980s heyday of Jeff Chandler. His world title victory in the first Vasquez fight and the two subsequent losses put the icing on the cake. His has been a great career and it’s not over yet, but age is catching his body rapidly and the end may be nearer than anyone would hope for. One might ask by the end of this list why his two straight losses seemingly count less than losses for other fighters like a Miguel Cotto. The evidence is in the fights. Marquez had a case for victory in the rubber match with Vasquez and was nip-tuck throughout the epic trilogy; if Vasquez is here, Marquez belongs nearby though if both find youthful titlists like the aforementioned Lopez or a Steve Molitor to much for their worn bodies to withstand next year, it would be no surprise.
9) Kelly Pavlik (34-0, 30 KO)
Age: 26
Current Title: World Middleweight/160 lbs. (2007-Present)
Last Five Opponents: Gary Lockett, Jermain Taylor (twice), Edison Miranda, Jose Luis Zertuche, Leonard Pierre
Next Opponent: October 18, 2008 vs. Bernard Hopkins (48-5-1, 32 KO)
The Take: Having taken his customary ‘breather’ first title defense in Lockett, Team Pavlik talked about a trip up the scale to challenge Calzaghe but that isn’t happening in 2008. Instead we get a showdown no one really asked for against the former Middleweight champ Hopkins at a catch weight of 170. Sadly, it was the best option available. Undefeated IBF Middleweight Arthur Abraham, coming off his devastating rematch win over Edison Miranda on June 21, is tied up in a mandatory. Let’s hope timing doesn’t ruin a classic. Pavlik-Abraham is one of the two or three best in-ring matches that can be made in the entire sport. In the bigger picture, take a look at Pavlik’s last five foes and that’s his whole story. From prospect to contender to champion, and strapped to the meteor of his rise are the hopes of the American market for its next true superstar. The knockout of Taylor is their first fight came in arguably the best Middleweight title fight since Jorge Castro-John David Jackson in the mid-1990s.
10) Paul Williams (34-1, 25 KO)
Age: 27
Current Title: Alphabelt at Welterweight
Career Titles: Additional alphabelt reign at Welterweight
Last Five Opponents: Carlos Quintana (twice), Antonio Margarito, Santos Pakau, Sharmba Mitchell, Walter Matthysse
Next Opponent: TBA
The Take: By far the least accomplished man on the list, there is no denying the summer months have been good to Williams, good enough to edge out Cotto for this ten spot. While the glow of Cotto-Margarito is still washing over the game, and while Margarito has certainly earned the right to call himself one of the World’s best, what does it all say about Williams? He followed his gutsy win over the Mexican steamroller with a shocking loss to Puerto Rico’s Carlos Quintana in February but then credited himself by correcting and immediately avenging that off night in a single round in on June 6. This is clearly no one-trick pony. Margarito’s dismantling of Cotto casts a light on Williams because the lanky “Punisher” did something no one else at Welterweight has done against Margarito in recent memory. He built the customary lead only to have Margarito come roaring back to begin the process of doling out pain…but unlike so many others, including Cotto, he survived the suffering. He even outfought Margarito in the final round to seal victory after being stunned in the 9th and 11th. Margarito’s resume is better but until he exacts revenge we won’t know if, head to head, he can be better than Williams until they meet again.
Exiting the Ratings: None
Five More Who Could Easily Be Here: Miguel Cotto, Shane Mosley, Mikkel Kessler, Fernando Montiel, Bernard Hopkins
Five More Who Could Be Here Shortly: Jorge Linares, Koki Kameda, Chris John, Chad Dawson, Arthur Abraham
As always, feel free to agree…and disagree. This list is for entertainment purposes only and based purely on imagination, hypotheticals and conjecture just like every other pound for pound list ever written. Neither it nor any other such list made up of such illusory ingredients should be used to forward corporate agendas of any kind.
That doesn’t make it any less fun to argue