ADDAI OVER FRED TAYLOR PB08? R U FUCKING SERIOUS?
- Thread starter Unknownn
- Start date
wtf you talking about?? he's lucky he's in a pass happy offense?????
if he was in a run first offense he would have even better than that he already has??? this post makes no fucking sense!
I am still waiting on ANYONE to tell me how he is more deserving based off of THIS years #'s!
fuck 10,000 yards...he wasn't top 5 rb the year he got those so he didn't make it....he isn't top 4 or 5 right now when you take into account td's and recieving yards and td's as well.....
Sure he is a good consistent back..I AGREE!!!! But he has never thrown up #'s to place him in the top 5 or so in AFC much less NFL......
Again, rb's ahead of him during his best years, Priest, Faulk, Ricky, Portis, Cmart, eddie george, Jamal...Thats why he didn't make it..he wasn't better than them at the time........so now we want to take account his #'s from then for this year????
I am still waiting on an intelligent response on how a RB who didn't have any 100 yard rushing games and had only 1 td when the pro bowl voting started belongs in the pro bowl.
if he was in a run first offense he would have even better than that he already has??? this post makes no fucking sense!
I am still waiting on ANYONE to tell me how he is more deserving based off of THIS years #'s!
fuck 10,000 yards...he wasn't top 5 rb the year he got those so he didn't make it....he isn't top 4 or 5 right now when you take into account td's and recieving yards and td's as well.....
Sure he is a good consistent back..I AGREE!!!! But he has never thrown up #'s to place him in the top 5 or so in AFC much less NFL......
Again, rb's ahead of him during his best years, Priest, Faulk, Ricky, Portis, Cmart, eddie george, Jamal...Thats why he didn't make it..he wasn't better than them at the time........so now we want to take account his #'s from then for this year????
I am still waiting on an intelligent response on how a RB who didn't have any 100 yard rushing games and had only 1 td when the pro bowl voting started belongs in the pro bowl.
If any of that was directed at me…I’m not saying he got robbed…just responding to him not being good and the 10,000 yards.
I do think he deserved to go…but I have no complaints about Addai going ahead of him.
Addai does have the benefit of having Manning and a much more potent offense…but that’s just him being more fortunate than anything else I guess.
I think the biggest problem with the pro bowl is that the voting is so early. I see no reason why they couldn’t wait until later or after the regular season to vote.
I do think he deserved to go…but I have no complaints about Addai going ahead of him.
Addai does have the benefit of having Manning and a much more potent offense…but that’s just him being more fortunate than anything else I guess.
I think the biggest problem with the pro bowl is that the voting is so early. I see no reason why they couldn’t wait until later or after the regular season to vote.
Pass happy offense opens up the running game. Lots of teams stuff the box when playing vs Jacksonville. Man Taylor's avg year per carry is slighty above 5 and Addai's is 4. Yeah its a close call. It can go either way since their stats are comparable.
Well atleast Taylor is a top candidate for Comeback Player of the Year....its going to be tough though cuz Jamal Lewis is playing very well.
i knew he wouldnt be an allstar pick but i figured the players and coaches would put since he puts up almost as good stats and he shares time and its his 10th year and always probowl bound but never gets it/ i know it dont mean shit to us but to be a player and get voted in specially by co-players and coaches must feel hella good and appreciated
here are there stats right next to each other
now they pretty identical but fred taylor has less att rushing cause he shares time with jones-drew and he's still puttin up equal numbers to addai. i'm not takin shit from addai but its his 2nd year, he will make probowl again and who knows how much gas fred jones has in his tank and to put in this sophmore over the vet who always deserved but never went into the probowl when they having a pretty equal year is wack to me and the players shoulda made it happen. oh well wat can ya do but wait for next year but i highly doubt it will happen
oh yeah and fred taylor got the better runs with 40+ and that 80 yd one which makes him more enetertaining and thats what the probowls all about. just one more reason why this old bastard should be in lol
now they pretty identical but fred taylor has less att rushing cause he shares time with jones-drew and he's still puttin up equal numbers to addai. i'm not takin shit from addai but its his 2nd year, he will make probowl again and who knows how much gas fred jones has in his tank and to put in this sophmore over the vet who always deserved but never went into the probowl when they having a pretty equal year is wack to me and the players shoulda made it happen. oh well wat can ya do but wait for next year but i highly doubt it will happen
oh yeah and fred taylor got the better runs with 40+ and that 80 yd one which makes him more enetertaining and thats what the probowls all about. just one more reason why this old bastard should be in lol
here are there stats right next to each other
You completely ignored another stat though:
Fred Taylor:
9 REC, 58 YDS, 2 FUM, 1 LOSS, 0 TD
Joseph Addai:
39 REC, 351 YDS, 0 FUM, 3 TD
That give Fred Taylor 3 FUM on the season total...and Addai NONE. 4 TD for Taylor...and Addai 14.
Why do people always only look at the obvious stuff?
^^^i actually posted his fumble shit and i only posted his rushing stats cause thats wat nfl.com had. it isnt like i went outta my way to not post that shit. so u think flat out that fred shouldnt be in the probowl? oh and its easy for u to point out the things addai does better when u dont point out taylor has more yds. more 20+ and 40+ yd runs and less att. c'mon i can say the same shit on ur side as well
Taylor has 70 more yards than Addai..nothing to write home about.
Yes, he does have more "break away" runs, I will not deny that.
However, is shows that Addai is used more as a mulit-purpose back AND can score the TD.
Notice you only showed the fumbles from RUNNING the ball. He has 2X the amount once you show his recieving numbers.
Yes, he does have more "break away" runs, I will not deny that.
However, is shows that Addai is used more as a mulit-purpose back AND can score the TD.
Notice you only showed the fumbles from RUNNING the ball. He has 2X the amount once you show his recieving numbers.
