2012 fantasy football roster discussion

[Count_Slapula]

QB: Eli Manning, RG3
RB: Foster, Peterson, Sproles, Blount
WR: Welker, Smith, Reggie Wayne, Desean Jackson, Darrius Howard Bey, Kendall Wright
TE: Jared Cook
K: Bironas
DEF: Texans

Only worried about my choice of QB's at this moment, Peterson is a god so hopefully he's back in full form like always, if not I have Sproles for cover.

 

[POLTERGEIST]

I have my one player keeper draft tomorrow. Who should I keep and why? Larry fitzgerald, andre johnson, or Rob gronkowski?

I'm leaning towards Fitzgerald or Gronk. Not sure on AJ health or AZ quarterback situation. What should I do?

 

[45park1904]

Fitzgerald!

 

[D.I.R.B]

What u guys think about my squad?

QB: Tom Brady
RB: Michael Turner
RB: Fred Jackson
WR: Andre Johnson
WR: Dwayne Bowe
WR: Malcom Floyd
TE: Jermichael Finley
W/R/T: Donald Brown
K: Bironas
DEF: Texans

Bench: Helu, Dalton, Amendola, Broyles, Keller, F. Jones

EDIT: I had 4th pick..

12 team league on Yahoo. I need an upgrade at WR and the flex position...

 

[Meta4iCAL]

What u guys think about my squad?

QB: Tom Brady
RB: Michael Turner
RB: Fred Jackson
WR: Andre Johnson
WR: Dwayne Bowe
WR: Malcom Floyd
TE: Jermichael Finley
W/R/T: Donald Brown
K: Bironas
DEF: Texans

Bench: Helu, Dalton, Amendola, Broyles, Keller, F. Jones

EDIT: I had 4th pick..

12 team league on Yahoo. I need an upgrade at WR and the flex position...

I agree, if you can get one more solid WR and a better flex option you'll be solid as fuck, but overall nice squad for 12 team league

 

[Rossibreath]

C Newton
R Matthews
A Bradshaw
Doug Martin
Demarious Thomas
R Wayne
A Hernandez
R Gould
Phi



A Luck
Daniel Thomas
Alfred Morris
Nate Washington
Greg Olsen

14 team league had pick 9

 

[DubbC415]

about to draft in a half hour...never played before, should be interesting.

 

[Stealth]

I have my one player keeper draft tomorrow. Who should I keep and why? Larry fitzgerald, andre johnson, or Rob gronkowski?

I'm leaning towards Fitzgerald or Gronk. Not sure on AJ health or AZ quarterback situation. What should I do?

Do you have to take a keeper? Most of those guys should go in round 2. Might make more sense to not take a keeper and have the first overall pick. You could probably grab someone better. If I had to take a guy with no QB (Fitz), a guy with leg problems (Andre), or a TE, I'd probably just jump back in the pool and try to grab the best available player. Then if there's no one you like, you can always just take one of those 3 anyways.

 

[ALL BOUT CHICKEN]

here's my team for the all defense league i'm in. there's 10 teams, and the draft lasted 22 rounds.

team defenses - new york giants, dallas cowboys

defensive ends - julius peppers, j.j. watt, jabaal sheard

defensive tackles - geno atkins, israel idonije

linebackers - demarcus ware, london fletcher, sean lee, von miller, wesley woodyard, d.j. williams, daryl smith, brian cushing

cornerbacks - darelle revis, brandon carr, ronde barber

safeties - ed reed, antrel rolle, earl thomas, kenny phillips

 

[Rossibreath]

I would keep Gronkowski

 

[killahoe666]

Do you have to take a keeper? Most of those guys should go in round 2. Might make more sense to not take a keeper and have the first overall pick. You could probably grab someone better. If I had to take a guy with no QB (Fitz), a guy with leg problems (Andre), or a TE, I'd probably just jump back in the pool and try to grab the best available player. Then if there's no one you like, you can always just take one of those 3 anyways.

I agree heavily with this, it makes no sense to keep any of those guys when the top ten players outweigh them by far. I assume if you don't keep you get to pick in the first round, I guarantee one of those guys will be availble for your next pick

 

[Rossibreath]

Keeper leagues are gay.

 

[D.I.R.B]

C Newton
R Matthews
A Bradshaw
Doug Martin
Demarious Thomas
R Wayne
A Hernandez
R Gould
Phi



A Luck
Daniel Thomas
Alfred Morris
Nate Washington
Greg Olsen


14 team league had pick 9

That's a great squad for a 14 team league, nicely done

 

[MRTHECOSE]

I got 2 squads:
Matt Ryan
Darren McFadden
Jonathan Stewart
DeSean Jackson
AJ Green
Greg Olsen
Dez Bryant

Sebastian Janikowski

Eagles Defense


Bench
Andy Dalton
Michael Bush
Pierre Garcon
Laurent Robinson
Raiders Defense
-------------------------------


Matt Ryan
Larry Fitzgerald
Marques Colston
Darren McFadden
Michael Bush
Vernon Davis
Jonathan Stewart

Sebastian Janikowski

San Francisco Defense

bench
Andrew Luck
Cedric Benson
Rashard Mendenhall
Denarius Moore
Heath Miller
Detroit Defense


What you guys think?

 

[POLTERGEIST]

I agree heavily with this, it makes no sense to keep any of those guys when the top ten players outweigh them by far. I assume if you don't keep you get to pick in the first round, I guarantee one of those guys will be availble for your next pick

The draft order is determined by order of finish last year. Yes, u have to keep one. I'm for no keepers but the league wants 1-2 keepers

 

[Cut-Throat]

I agree heavily with this, it makes no sense to keep any of those guys when the top ten players outweigh them by far. I assume if you don't keep you get to pick in the first round, I guarantee one of those guys will be availble for your next pick

do you get the concept of a keeper league? the top 10+ players will be kept...

anyway... keep Gronk...

 

[Meta4iCAL]

had my draft tonight. 8 team PPR league, which I won last year. here's my starting lineup and bench as it's set right now I'm sure I'll move some guys around before week 1

QB - Cam Newton
WR - Larry Fitzgerald
WR - Greg Jennings
WR - Steve Smith
RB - Ray Rice
RB - Matt Forte
TE - Aaron Hernandez
Flex - Reggie Bush
Flex - Jonathan Stewart
D - Mario Williams
D - Charles Woodson
D - Eric Weddle
K - Jason Hanson

Bench:
QB - Tony Romo
WR - Demaryius Thomas
WR - Torrey Smith
WR - Anquan Boldin
RB - Kevin Smth
RB - Stevan Ridley
TE - Jermichael Finley

some of the people in my league are hella dumb though. like one dude drafted 2 defensive players in the 5th and 6th round (out of 20 rounds). another guy (a Niners fan) drafted David Akers in something like the 6th round, and was gonna draft a back up kicker in the 19th round until my boy told him it was a dumb ass move. only an 8 team league, so everyone has a good team, but I'm sure I have one of the best, top 3 for sure

Edit: forgot to add my kicker before... although who fucking cares about a kicker anyways, right?

 

[Rossibreath]

^^I hate when people talk people out of a dumb pick. Its good if someone drafts bad haha.

 

[Count_Slapula]

had my draft tonight. 8 team PPR league, which I won last year. here's my starting lineup and bench as it's set right now I'm sure I'll move some guys around before week 1

QB - Cam Newton
WR - Larry Fitzgerald
WR - Greg Jennings
WR - Steve Smith
RB - Ray Rice
RB - Matt Forte
TE - Aaron Hernandez
Flex - Reggie Bush
Flex - Jonathan Stewart
D - Mario Williams
D - Charles Woodson
D - Eric Weddle

Bench:
QB - Tony Romo
WR - Demaryius Thomas
WR - Torrey Smith
WR - Anquan Boldin
RB - Kevin Smth
RB - Stevan Ridley
TE - Jermichael Finley

some of the people in my league are hella dumb though. like one dude drafted 2 defensive players in the 5th and 6th round (out of 20 rounds). another guy (a Niners fan) drafted David Akers in something like the 6th round, and was gonna draft a back up kicker in the 19th round until my boy told him it was a dumb ass move. only an 8 team league, so everyone has a good team, but I'm sure I have one of the best, top 3 for sure

Jesus, you have probably the best roster possible and that's a ton of slots.

 

[Rossibreath]

8 teams isn't enough