OFFICIAL OAKLAND RAIDERS 2015-16 SEASON THREAD
- Thread starter MobbinINda916
- Start date
and they both have the same amount of playoff appearances... niether side has much of an arguement...
Props:
Chree and Chree
Really? You reaching a little on that one to make these guys seem like they are on level playing fields, Carr is a second year qb while gabbert is in his fifth season.
Derek Carr has as many touchdowns this season as gabbert has his whole career. By the time Carr is in his fifth year he will have playoffs appearances and wins, I garnette it!!
Why the fuck is this even an argument lol
The funny thing about this argument is if Carr was a Niner
@Chree
would be acting like Carr was Joe Montana reincarnated lol
@Chree
would be acting like Carr was Joe Montana reincarnated lol
Props:
troythemac and troythemac
You're bringing outside arguments in to the discussion.
The question is Carr vs. Gabbert as in pure player skill.
Carr sitting in the couch in January doesn't at all have any impact on whether or not he's a better player than Blaine Gabbert, so why even bring that in to the mix?
all of the seasons John Elway, Dan Marino etc. missed the playoffs, does that all of a sudden make them terrible players? You can go down the list of QB's in the HOF with plenty of January's sitting on the couch.
lol I have no idea the point you're trying to make.
The question is Carr vs. Gabbert as in pure player skill.
Carr sitting in the couch in January doesn't at all have any impact on whether or not he's a better player than Blaine Gabbert, so why even bring that in to the mix?
all of the seasons John Elway, Dan Marino etc. missed the playoffs, does that all of a sudden make them terrible players? You can go down the list of QB's in the HOF with plenty of January's sitting on the couch.
lol I have no idea the point you're trying to make.
Props:
MaC A$$ ViC and MaC A$$ ViC