pretty much though both those tvs you said are great though, i would get a led tv for my next tv easily. this plasma is pretty much a movie viewing tv, i wouldn't bother unless you watch blu-rays like 90% of the time. looking back id get an LED cause i game like crazy now and i have to be careful about image retention from the bright ass HUDs in all these games. burn-in is dead but image retention is very much alive and extremely annoying