Raiders live chat here today at 3 p.m.
By Sports
Tuesday, December 30th, 2008 at 12:25 pm in Oakland Raiders.
Here’s where you can participate in our weekly live chat with “Inside the Oakland Raiders” blogger Jerry McDonald today from 3 p.m.-4 p.m.
2:58
jerrymac: May as well get started before any more coaches get fired . . .
2:58
[Comment From GEE NICE]
What do you think AL Davis is going to do about the head coaching position.
3:00
jerrymac: As usual, he's got people guessing. My guess is ultimately he'll bring back Tom Cable once he surveys the landscape and gets a good feeling for other candidates.
3:00
[Comment From RaiderMike]
Your thoughts on Jim Harbaugh?
3:01
jerrymac: He got a terrible Stanford program back on its feet, but his job is not done there yet. He was only 5-7 this year. I'd prefer to see him get them into a bowl game before meriting such a jump. And I'd think a little less of him for bailing out on Stanford before he had the ship righted.
3:01
[Comment From David]
Any chance of Raiders hiring Eric Mangini as defensive coordinator if they choose to let Rob Ryan go?
3:02
jerrymac: Mangini was interviewed by Davis over the phone as a d-coordinator candidate five years ago when the job eventually went to Ryan. I'd guess Mangini is looking to be a head coach and Cleveland is reportedly interested in talking to him.
3:02
[Comment From David]
What are your thoughts of the firing of Mike Shanahan? Is Al Davis choking on his own laughter right now?
3:03
jerrymac: He has no reason to choke his lown laughter considering his own product the last six years. He'd have to beat Shanahan for the next 10 or so to even things up. Hopefully he's putting his thought into continuing the progress made the last two games of the season.
3:03
[Comment From christian dean]
who will be the raiders coach next season?will we bring back tom cable?do you think cable is the best man for the job?
3:04
jerrymac: Most rumors right now have to do with Harbaugh, Kevin Gilbride (Giants O.C.) and Hue Jackson (Ravens QB coach). Of that trio, I'd just as soon see Cable. He already knows the territory, has embraced dealing with Davis and despite having a horrible hand dealt his way in terms of unproductive free agents and the whole Kiffin-Davis fiasco, had the Raiders playing the last two weeks better than at any point in the last six years.
3:05
[Comment From david]
any shot that mike shanahan will coach the raiders now that hes fired
3:05
jerrymac: Only if Jon Gruden turns it down first.
3:05
[Comment From Josh in LG]
What are the odds of the Raiders drafting a WR in the first round?
3:05
jerrymac: At No. 7,. I'd say pretty good if Crabtree is available. I'm sure JaMarcus Russell would lobby for it.
3:06
[Comment From pFunk]
How did the CYO championship turn out? What do you think of Grove's comments in the Chron about Kiffin quitting on the team in week 1? And good riddance, Mike Shanahan! Although it might mean Raider Hater #1 Marty S is on his way to Denver...
3:08
jerrymac:
made it to the title game, lost a close game to a good team . . . as for grove's comments, I think he's right, and a lot of players felt that way after they gave it all time to sink in. Kiffin essentially quit on them the moment he didn't get his way with Davis following last season _ even earlier if he was really considering the Arkansas job partway through year 1.
3:08
[Comment From raidermark]
Jerry – This, of course, is only a guess, but it connects the dots. The name of Al Davis’ mystery front office hire with Bay Area connections is a former coach who at age 74 does want to travel anymore on his NFL TV gig, has made a boat load of money various well known business ventures– so is not looking for a pay day, still loves the Silver and Black, frets privately over the stones thrown daily at Mr. Davis, and sincerely believes he is eternally indebted to Mr. Davis. His name is John Madden. What say you?
3:08
jerrymac: A bad idea. He's been a TV announcer for a quarter century or so.
3:08
[Comment From WashingtonRAider]
What’s more important at the moment... do they shore up the HC position? Or do they put in place the GM figure that Davis has alluded to? Seems to me this other football mind/GM type should be a big role player in implementing the new HC (cable or not) as they help put the team together and move forward on the same page...
3:10
jerrymac: Ideally, you put a GM or exec in place, then get a coach who is on the same page, as Parcells and Sparano have done in Miami. I don't see the Raiders operating that way. I think Davis will hire the coach, then bring in someone to help with personnel and other issues after the fact. The Raiders simply don't operate in a conventional fashion and there' s no reason to think they will now.
3:10
[Comment From WashingtonRAider]
With Drew Carter saying he wants to come back, Javon (most likely) staying because there’s no other option, the emergence of JLH and Chaz Schilens, plus Shields coming back hopefully healthy and having Mcfadden as an option, do we really need to go after another receiver? Why not let Russell get more in sync with what he’s already got? cuz it suddenly looks pretty good!
3:11
jerrymac: Drew Carter has had four knee surgeries. Even if he comes back at a minmum wage, how do you count on him. Even with JLH and Schilens emergence, this was the least productive group of WRS in franchise history. Of course you need help.
3:11
[Comment From WashingtonRAider]
Were Fargas and McFadden both that hurt so as not to be able to play hardly at all? Is it possible that this game was used as a means to be able to start shopping Bush? If not, what does his monster performance Sunday mean to next year’s depth charts?
3:12
jerrymac: McFadden was hurt during the week, listed as questionable, and bush said afterward he could tell at practice mcfadden wasn't close to 100 percent (reporters don't watch practice). If the year proved anything, it's that you need all three backs. Because they needed all of them over the course of the season.
3:12
[Comment From WashingtonRAider]
With Henderson suddenly looking above average, do we go after a tackle in the first round or try to sign an FA and maybe go after Mauluga to shore up the middle against the run?
3:13
jerrymac: Depends on the scheme and the tackle. But you don't let Henderson's improvement stop you from getting another one. You need two. Cornell Green is a reserve who has started for two years. Raiders seldom draft linebackers in first round, although in this case it would be worth a shot if it's a real beast.
3:14
jerrymac: His ball-security is an issue and needs to get better. Too early to tell if it's sort of a long-term thing like Daunte Culpepper or something he can fix with better fundamentals.
3:14
[Comment From WashingtonRAider]
Didn’t see whether or not he had any in this last game, but throughout the season all of the Jamarcus fumbles have been standing out big time to me. Is this a personal thing or did it have a lot to do with his being rushed too often and not having a decent O-line?
3:14
[Comment From Felipe]
Does the Shannahan firing make it harder for us to find a coach/GM?
3:15
jerrymac: Raiders are in their own universe. Not sure there are going to be a lot of candidates Al Davis and Pat Bowlen will be competing for.
3:15
[Comment From BlkHoleOccupaent]
Who do you think will be the next D coord?
3:16
jerrymac:
I think there's a chance it's Martindale, unless he goes with Ryan.
3:16
[Comment From Felipe]
Any chance of us getting Boldin, or trading Fargas?
3:18
jerrymac: Boldin should be on the radar, although he's more of a short pass, catch-and-run type than a downfield receiver. Think of a bigger, powerful Wes Welker. Not sure what Fargas would bring on the open market, and what the Raiders will take. He takes a lot of heat from fans, but he's hugely respected in the locker room and by the coaching staff.
3:18
[Comment From Raider310]
realistically what are the chances we keep Asoumgha and Lechler?
3:19
jerrymac:
They can absolutely keep one of them by using an exclusive franchise tag, or the regular tag and matching an offer. They could keep both by throwing a boatload of money at Lechler _ considerably more than he would make anywhere else _ and then franchising Asomugha.
3:19
[Comment From Steve]
Final thoughts on the season?
3:22
jerrymac:
After six years of uninspired football, I was extremely impressed by the last two games. Best back-to-back games since the 2002 season, and nothing even comes close in my mind. They actually looked like a good team and it's been a long time since I felt comfortable even uttering those words.
(lost track) question was final thoughts on the season . . .
3:22
[Comment From E.Turner#29]
Jerry, Admittedly I don’t see every raider play, but can you please tell me why Fargas continues to be the feature back. I understand the team loves his attitude and running style, but in my opinion he is the third best back on the team. When Bush finally got his chance, he ran for 129 yards in the 4th qtr against a first class defence. Fargas struggles to run for a 1st down in the 4th qtr.
3:24
jerrymac: Did you see the holes Bush was running through in the fourth quarter? I know this is an unpopular opinion because the best thing to do would be to send bush directly to the Hall of Fame, but if Fargas were heatlhy, he'd have had big yards in the fourth quarter as well. That's the beauty of the ZBS when it works _ it takes over in the fourth quarter.
3:24
[Comment From DH]
What type of coach do the Raiders most need now, and which type will Al likely pursue? Undiscovered offensive genius, proven winner, maintainer-of-continuity, or guy that's willing to do Al's bidding because he's desperate for another head coaching gig? And is there any chance that Al's choice will match the need?
3:24
jerrymac: How about someone who actually wants the job, who has actually produced something with the players already on hand, and who already has experience dealing with Al Davis . . . he's already in the building.
3:24
[Comment From christian dean]
do you think the raiders will bring in a new d coordintor?
3:25
jerrymac: I think after five years, and the contract expiring, that Rob Ryan may be allowed to walk. If his brother gets a head coaching gig, I wouldn't be surprised to see Rob join him.
3:25
[Comment From Guest]
Jerry - any thoughts on likelihood of keeping Nnamdi if Cable is HC vs some other HC?
3:26
jerrymac: Saw Nnamdi on the sidelines following the game standing right next to Cable and thrusting his arms in to the air. I'd venture to guess it was the first itme he actually felt some pride in being a Raider. Maybe he's seen too much to be swayed, but if Cable were to stay and the Raiders came through with that huge offer, who knows? Maybe they'd have a chance to lock up up longterm.
3:26
[Comment From David]
Do you think AL will listen at all to the players. They seem to be supporting Cable.
3:27
jerrymac: He might talk and listen to a few, but not the masses. There was a line of players heading up to his office imploring him to hire Joe Bugel. He listened.
3:27
[Comment From Chappy]
Were the past two weeks a true indicator of where this team is going or should be scale back our expectations? I know we can't go 16-0 but 8-8 would be a huge improvement
3:29
jerrymac:
Fact is, the AFC West is pretty much a wasteland. So 8 wins is a contending team. There seems to be a lot of people who want to reject the last two games as meaningless, end-of-the-line performances, but I'm not one of them. You can't destroy them each and every year for the way they fall apart at the end of the year, and then, when they finally do something worthwhile, destroy them again.
3:29
[Comment From RaiderMike]
how do Russell and Cable get along
3:29
jerrymac: By all indications, very well.
3:29
[Comment From Philip]
What are your thoughts on our offensive lineman?
3:31
jerrymac:
Surprising year for Grove, given his injury status. Very good year for Gallery. Carlisle wasn't as good as last year. Harris and Green were weak spots and a problem. Mario did enough to go into next season as the starting LT. Three good games.
3:31
[Comment From j]
how would you rate Macfadden's season?
3:31
jerrymac: Essentially ruined by injury. Not anything close to what they hoped for or frankly, what I thought we'd see following training camp.
3:31
[Comment From KoolKell]
Al Davis Hires All the Players Al Davis Hires All the Coaches Player turnover, Coaching turnover, same result. Why, if not Al Davis? Al Davis Hires All the Players Al Davis Hires All the Coaches Player turnover, Coaching turnover, same result. Why, if not Al Davis? Jerry, last week you downplayed the notion that there was a Revolution going on in the Nation, that most fans support Al Davis. I think you are wrong Most people have come to realize, Al hires all the players, hires all the coaches, player turnover, coaching turnover, same results. That's common knowledge in my Oakland barbershop.
3:32
jerrymac: If there's a revolution, it will show up in ticket sales. If I start seeing the amount of fans every week that I saw against Houston, then I believe it. If there are sellouts or near sellouts, I'm not buying it.
3:33
[Comment From Lifetime Fan]
Hello--is the rational behind hiring Gilbride something like he could insert an Earth Wind Fire of sorts running game in Oakland? Because it was ridiculous how we could not utilize all three of our RBs in the same game. That is the only reason I would want Gilbride (in NY--Jacobs, Ward, Bradshaw--all used quite well). Is that Davis' rational for his interest in him (because other than that Gilbride looks like a below average Norv Turner).
3:34
jerrymac:
the reason Gilbride was able to utilize three running backs is that he had a terrific defense that kept giving him the ball. The Raiders were 31st in rushing defense. They didn't get it back nearly as often, and found themselves behind far more than the Giants. Lot easier to be persistent with a good defense. Check out Sunday with a fourth-quarter lead _ eight straight runs to burn 5:46 off the clock.
3:34
[Comment From lamarr]
whats your opinion on tommy kelly?
3:35
jerrymac: A pretty average player and nowhere near a premiere player at his position, at least not this year. Questionable investment.
3:35
[Comment From Justin]
Although I hate to say it, I think the Raiders best course of action would be to trade Asomugha for a first round pick and a good receiver such as Boldin, T.J Houshmanzada, or the guy from the Texans. Your thoughts?
3:36
jerrymac: Interesting thought . . . the Raiders played without Nnamdi against Tampa Bay, and the world didn't fall off its axis. They actually played well and won, and still kept Antonio Bryant in check.
3:36
[Comment From Raiders4]
Assuming Cable is officially promoted (Never assume anything with the raiders) will Lofton be promoted to OC? I am also assuming Knapp will be gone.
3:37
jerrymac: Cable wasn't ready to talk about whehter he would remain the play-caller. Crazy for him to address it when he doesn't have the job. I'd assume he would try to hire someone he trusts, rather than have someone hired outside his influence be the OC.
3:37
[Comment From Emmanuel]
What about Plaxico Burress, do you think they'll go after him if the Giants release him?
3:37
jerrymac:
Sure. He can have his locker next to Javon Walker.
3:38
[Comment From DT42]
i'm a firm believer that when the assistant oline coach bolted for Tennessee, it brought the offense and the oline in particular together. your right about Fargus and the holes were huge in the last game. did you see a change in attitude after the kiffin poaching of the raider staff?
3:39
jerrymac: To be honest, no. Cable made a big deal of the Gregg defection, but in truth, the linemen I talked to liked the guy and felt bad he was put in a bad position. He's married, has a young daughter, and it's a fair guess that Kiffin told him ``Now or never.'' He had a family to look out for, and took the sure thing. Can't say I would have done any differently.
3:39
[Comment From R8ER JUAN]
jerrymac: how about bringing Ryans' dad as D-Coordinator?
3:40
jerrymac: Have seen him at a couple of games and it's fair to say he's not up to the rigors of traveling with an NFL team and working 20 hour days.
3:40
[Comment From Skloomsh]
Lowell Cohn wrote that he, Kawakami and Monte Poole aren't notified when the Raiders address the press because they 'tell the truth' about the team. That would imply that those who are notified, don't tell the truth. Do you have any thoughts on that?
3:41
jerrymac: There are guys occasionally kicked off e-mail lists for writing things the Raiders don't like. It's petty on the Raiders part, but it's also true anyone with half a brain contacts the beat writer and then finds out when the press conference is. You don't sit back and wait for the Raiders to tell you, or you deserve what you get.
3:41
[Comment From SPC Parker]
How difficult will it be for a new coach (other then Cable) to carry over the momentum that Cable has gained from these last 2 games into next season?
3:42
jerrymac: Impossible to say without knowing if there will be a wholesale system change offensively, or if the coach comes in with Cable intact and is working with one already in place.
3:42
[Comment From Toney]
Do you think Cable will play Bush more next year if he is coach?
3:43
jerrymac: Depends on the situation, health of the backs, etc. Bush was fabulous in the last game. He did himself no favors with his head-hanging and pouting regarding playing fullback. It was something they needed him to do in a pinch this year because O'Neal and Griffith were gone.
3:43
[Comment From Nnamdi21]
Whats our DT situation heading into 09'? Will Warren re work, get paid or bail? Not sure if other teams will pay him the kind of money he might exepect. More of a one gap rusher huh?
3:44
jerrymac: Kelly stays because of his contract. Warren and Sands will be evaluated closely. As a trio, they weren't nearly good enough.
3:45
[Comment From E.Turner#29]
Jerry - Why would you want Cable as head coach? Granted the last two games were better then most in the last 6 years, but please remember it was only two wins. Remember the terrible product he produced for the 10 or so previous games. Remember the "Communication issues" with the players. Everyone was calling for cables head 2 weeks ago. I don't believe he is the answer - but then again im not sure who is!
3:48
jerrymac: Only two games? Name two other games back-to-back the Raiders have played in the last six years that are comparable. There aren't any. I'm pretty much a skeptic, conditionied from seeing such shoddy football played for so long. Those last two games, it was as if they finally figured something out. Most important, Russell blossomed in the last two games. Cable did something Bill Callahan (in 2003), Norv Turner, Art Shell or Lane Kiffin never came close to doing in terms of what was on the field the last two weeks of the season
3:48
[Comment From Chris]
I haven't heard a single thing about Javon Walker recently? What is going on with him? How is he coming along? Has he been involved at all?
3:48
jerrymac: Have heard he's been in the building. Never saw him one time after the surgery.
3:49
[Comment From r8er22]
i think knapp is gone who do you think will be our o-coordinator? Martz?
3:50
jerrymac:
As I've said before, Martz is positively brutal on quarterbacks. He's critical and insulting, belittles them for their errors . . . is that the guy you want coaching Russell?
3:50
[Comment From yayarea_raider]
Jerry, what are the chances Rob Ryan WANTS to come back, assuming AL does?
3:50
jerrymac: Ryan has had unwavering loyalty to Davis. My guess _ and it's only a guess _ is he'd like to be a DC elsewhere. But if nothing materializes . . .
3:50
[Comment From Bryan]
Would it make sense that Parcells is the mystery GM candidate considering the fact Al mentioned it in week 3 but no one has been hired? Do you think it's possible they were waiting for the season to wrap up?
3:51
jerrymac: The mystery guy was supposedly local. Parcells has no local ties. And Parcells commands HUGE money. Way more than Davis has ever paid for a front office person.
3:52
[Comment From yayarea_raider]
What would be a cap hit of releasing Javon Walker & is it true he agreed on a reduced contract during pre-season? Do the Raiders still believe in him???
3:53
jerrymac: Don't have the figure at hand, but it was substantial. Believe it was 14 million or so . . . his salary was onmly 1 mil last year so reducing his salary wouldn't have done much. Doubt he's amenable to agreeing to forfeit scheduled bonuses. But he wanted to retire once, so who knows?
3:53
[Comment From JJ99]
Jerry - I'm on the east coast and havent followed Harbaugh's Stanford teams. There has been some noise about him as a candidate for the HC job. I recall as a player he seemed to make good decisions. How have his Stanford teams looked?
3:54
jerrymac: Much tougher, and more hardnosed than under the predecessor, Buddy Teevens. Ran the ball extremely well. Although a quarterback guy, Stanford has a shaky passing game both years. It's what kept them from being a bowl team.
3:54
[Comment From Nnamdi21]
Davis and Ryan's defense worked well with the offense keeping them off the field in the last two games. Do you think the scheme of a pass rushing coverage defense is viable and can we ride it to the play offs?
3:55
jerrymac: Bottom line is they've got to be better against the run overall. Improvement in the last two games was nice. Still, on balance, woefully inadequate. In five year's Ryans defenses have given up 101 rushing touchdowns. That's the most in the NFL and an indication they get pushed around a lot.
3:56
jerrymac: ASsumey ou mean Jim Harbaugh, not his brother John, coach of the Ravens. Pretty clear that under the current setup, with no strong G.M. involved, with just Al picking a coach, that I'd go with Cable.
3:56
[Comment From yayarea_raider]
If you had your pick out of Cable, Hackett, Gilbride & John Harbaugh, who would YOU pick Jerry?
3:56
[Comment From R8ER JUAN]
jerrymac: can you please answer Skloomsh with this: Lowell Cohn, Kawakami and Monte Poole are Raiders' haters?
4:00
jerrymac: Sure. Everyone's a hater. Write that the Raiders are terrible (which they have been for six years) and you're a hater. Write that Kiffin wants out, and you're a hater. (Hey _ he did want out). The whole hater thing is ridiculous. If the Raiders were winning conference championships, they'd be writing positive columns and then the ``anti-haters'' would rip them for jumping on the bandwagon. They're merely chronicling a poor team in an unprecedented stretch of bad football.
4:00
[Comment From yayarea_raider]
Will Drew Carter get another shot and what is your view on Arman Shields because some fans tell me he's the real deal?
4:01
jerrymac: Carter, if he were to get another shot, is a risk. Two major surgeries on each knee at a young age. No way to tell on Shields. Barely got to see him at training camp.
4:01
[Comment From kotrabela]
why do you think cable didn't use mcfadden much during his tenure, and does that make you uneasy about him as a decision-maker?
4:02
jerrymac: McFadden's season was ruined by injuries _ and that's a concern. Sometimes either backs are durable or they're not. McFadden's history at Arkansas was that he was reliable, so that's what the Raiders have to hope for.
4:02
[Comment From KeepDaCableGuy]
Do you think Mike Vick would be a good signing for the Raiders?
4:03
jerrymac: If he were to come aboard as sort of a hybrid player to shake things up, sure. But not as a quarterback. Russell is the quarterback. And someone will probably sign Vick to be a quarterback.
4:03
[Comment From 408RAIDER]
why weren't you at the tampa game? Will you keep us informed on all the off season rumors? your loyal fans need their fix.....
4:04
jerrymac:
Travel budget was one reason, but since it was a cross country flight on the return, someone had to be at the facility Monday morning. And that was me.
4:04
[Comment From KeepDaCableGuy]
Do you think Darrell Strong is good enough to have regular tplaying time?
4:05
jerrymac: Hard to say, not seeing him practice. But I know they're looking for a semi-regular player to play with Zach Miller to free him up even more in the passing game.
4:05
[Comment From JJ99]
Assuming you are right that Al will stay with Cable... What would a Paul Hackett OC team look like?
4:06
jerrymac: If CAble stays, it will look a lot like what you saw the last two games regardless of who the OC is. Even if he doesn't call the plays, he wants a strong running game, and for Russell to lend balnace with medium and medium-to-deep strikes
4:07
[Comment From Tenebrous]
What is the chance that Hue Jackson is hired as an OC?
4:08
jerrymac:
Not sure what his contract status is. He can't go from assistant to assistant without permission from the Ravens. It would have to be a head coaching opportunity.
4:08
[Comment From 'da rich' r8r!]
Was Big Al bsing when he said he would hire help [GM] earlier in the yr. Or do you believe it would happen?
4:09
jerrymac: I think he's been talking to someone, yes. He has no reason to lie. But what I don't know is what the role of that person will be, if it will be heavily involved in day-to-day football operations, or be more of a ``problem solver'' who deals with a lot of stuff like Bruce Allen did.
4:09
[Comment From Sean]
Jerry, what's your take on the late-season development of the younger players on the roster (Higgins, Schillens, Henderson, etc.) Was it coaching or just finally giving younger players an opportunity. The player development seems to have been lacking in previous coaching regimes.
4:11
jerrymac: Could be a little of both actually. With Schilens, it had to do with healthy. He struggled with his health for awhile and needs to get bigger. With JLH and Henderson, a lot of it was confidence. Higgins was put in positions where he could do things, the right plays were called with regard to his being a receiver. You can tell Cable thinks he really needs to stay on top of Mario. HIs practice performances have been so inconsistent he had a hard time cracking the lineup. They simply didn't trust him.
4:13
jerrymac: Time to wrap it up . . . not sure what the chat schedule will be in the offseason but I'll let you know one way or the other . . .
FYI: Raiders are denying there has been any contact with any of the rumored candidates, Harbaugh, Gilbride, Jackson, etc. . . .
rumor season in full swing . . .
4:14