Malone and Barkley carried teams to the NBA Finals, Rodman was always a roleplayer with good defense and rebounding.
Rodman was great at what he did, but Barkley and Malone are top 20 all time greats. Barkley and Malone did what Rodman did and could be top 10 in the league scoring every season on top of it.
i'd rather have rodman on the squad, depending on the combination of players on the team, dude was an amazing rebounder, defender and played THE best mind games. one of my all time faves