I thought he was a helluva ball player. I believe in the end his relationship with the media and shortened career will keep him out of the hall. If he is gonna get in it will be down the road when some of his peers get a chance to vote. No way in hell the media puts him in. If he plays a full career they would have had to voted him in. The guy was intense and if you ever heard interviews from his teammates, they might have not liked him, but they all admired his will to win. I saw an interview with Kenny Lofton once, he went on and on about Belle and how hard he worked.
He falls into that Don Mattingly, Dale Murphy area of guys who at one time in their careers you would have thought they would be 1st ballot HOFers but injury or slumps took them out.