I don't think Everybody Move has that much appeal. Like Yeah, The Waitress, and Let's Go are all better mainstream songs. So, I'm definitely saying Do It Like I Do It would be the better bet on radio/tv. Not that it matters....
I refuse to vote because I cannot stand either song, but given the circumstances being as you put them, completely equal... Do it Like I Do It would probably have higher odds of success
Do It Like I Do It sounds too much like some mainstream stuff that was coming out the South last year(or was it the year before that I don't remember) with that snap stuff. Hip Hop is just one big fad so Do It Like I Do It would be playing catch up and wouldn't work.
Tell me about it. When they did that song at the show I went outside for a cigarette. A lot of shit gets stuck in my head, but that doesn't mean I'll buy it. Shit I walk around singing the "Five dollar footlong" Subway song... But I still won't order anything from Subway.