NES games will always be held in higher regard by long time gamers more than Genesis...no question. Its nostalgia at its highest peak.
As far as pure numbers of course NES will be held in a "higher regard", but that's based solely on pure nostalgia because the majority of people over age 25's first experience with a video game was probably an NES, but what does that have to do with quality of games and "stacking up" like you said earlier?
As somebody who is still a hardcore gamer, that interacts with gamers on a daily basis, and has spent his entire life around gamers the "higher regard" statement can't be further from the truth for hardcore gamers. Take away all of the casual people who maybe tried Mario Bros. as a kid and doesn't know anything outside of the NES and Genesis will definitely be a gamers pick then they'll more than likely say "fuck both, SNES is the best".
I dont know about you, but im almost 40, so when the NES came out, i was near 10 years old and it was the shit. It was on a whole different level than Atari or whatever other system that had come out prior. They basically started the home console rage...the NES is the OG.
I'm 33, got a NES at age 5 in 1988. What you're saying about NES is how my generation felt about Genesis/SNES. You had your Atari, then NES dropped and your Atari collected dust. That's how we were a console generation later.
NES starting the rage and being "OG" doesn't make it better, is NES better than PS4 because it's "OG"? lol
I would rather see a SNES over a Genesis. Quite frankly, i never liked the Genesis even though I owned one. Not even CLOSE to the hype i had for the NES. Altered Beast was about the only game i really fucked with on there.
I would like to see both SNES and Genesis get made. Both had great exclusives.
Dont know....never played it. Video games are subjective for the most part but if you took a poll of what is more iconic and nostalgic...i can guarantee most people wouldn't even list Phantasy Star as a contender.
I think you don't realize the amount of super nerd gamers are in the world, you ever heard of RPG's? Phantasy Star started the RPG craze. Phantasy Star 1-4 especially 4 is on numerous gaming publication "best games of all time" lists. Before World of Warcraft Phantasy Star Online was the game retards were hurting themselves over because they refused to stop playing and take care of themselves lol
I ask again though, what does your post have to do with "stacking up". Of course Mario Bros. wins by nostalgia points. Mario Bros. beats any video game ever made based on nostalgia points. Have somebody play through Mario Bros. and then play through any of the 4 Phantasy Star games on Genesis and then ask them "what game is better".
Your entire post is basically screaming "nostalgia is better than game quality".