I agree with CO-Rookie of the Year for both.
There's positives and negative surrounding both players.
Carmelo-tougher conference, tougher schedule, by far toughest division in NBA, made playoffs, but he has a much better surrounding cast.
LeBron-not much talent around him for support, but still was able to kick ass every game.
But if i had to pick one it would be Carmelo.
GO NUGZ!