Golden Compass/Northern Lights/Dark Materials Trilogy

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.
Apr 25, 2002
15,044
157
0
#1
Has anyone read these or have kids/relatives that have read these?

Religious groups are raising quite a ruckus over the Golden Compass movie that is coming out saying it is athiesm for kids and anti religious.

I'm wondering people's opinion who are actually familure with the material.

If it is I'll have to buy it for when I have kids. :cool:
 
Apr 25, 2002
15,044
157
0
#4
Really? I saw a short preview for Golden Compass and thought to myself it was probably a Christian movie. Like the The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the wardrobe. Christian movie. Trying to trick people and shit
“They” say that it is supposed to be the anti-religious/atheist version of Chronicles of Narnia.

Catholic league is saying it is an Atheist movie trying to trick people and shit. You go into the movie thinking it is a wholesome family movie with good Christian undertones, but your kid comes out thinking church is evil.

They had the books removed from all the public schools in Ontario Canada. The book has been out since ’95, but now that the movie comes out (still not out yet) they want the book pulled.

Crazy catlicks
 
May 13, 2002
49,944
47,801
113
44
Seattle
www.socialistworld.net
#7
Thanks for the info CB, maybe I'll check it out. Apparenlty, the author of the books is a self proclaimed atheist.

^ Haha after reading that im kind of interested.. we'll see about it


I was mad when I first found out that Narnia is backed by a bunch of Christians. I thought the original movie from the 80's was pretty sick when i was a little kid. I didnt really see any propaganda back then I guess.
The story takes inspiration from the Gospel themes of betrayal, death, resurrection, and redemption. The "Deep Magic from the Dawn of Time," and "Deeper Magic from Before the Dawn of Time" can be seen as similar to the Old and New Covenants of Christianity, respectively. In the subsequent books, there is a nod in the direction of the Trinity concept, with Aslan in the Christ-role and a passing reference to the "Emperor over the Sea" as God the Father. The children form a disciple-group around Aslan, with Edmund as Judas and Peter the High King as St Peter. The two girls also follow Biblical precedent, as Mary Magdalene and the other Mary, through being first to see the resurrected Aslan. In addition, there are various allusions to Christ's execution, including the humiliation prior to his death and the splitting of the curtain in the Temple, represented by the cracking of the stone table. The book is not intended to be a retelling of Biblical stories in another form; it simply borrows ideas from them so as to illustrate basic conceptions of Christianity (and some other ideas as well — Platonic philosophy among them). Additionally, the White Witch is said to be descended from Lilith, who some religious texts say was Adam's first wife.

J. R. R. Tolkien was a close friend of Lewis', a fellow member of the Inklings, and an early reader of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. However, despite his sharing Lewis' Christian faith, Tolkien was rather dismissive of the book. He considered its theology to be both blatant and naive, and the mixture of different mythic elements very inconsistent.

[Wiki