@2-0-Sixx
quote:
Now, if god "knows all" then god knows all of our fates, including "his" fate. But if he is "all powerful" then god has the power to change our fates and his own fate if he desired.
good point, but you're missing a lot of numbers to this equation. First of all, God does not have a fate. God is the immovable, static reality who is all places at once. God does not need to travel, he is there! He does not change his nature. He is everything. His nature is everything. There is no change in God. He is all now, before, and from now on. This is as much as we can understand about God. Second, Yes God has the power to change our fates. What you fail to realize is that we are subjects under God's law. This concept of God's law is a very good one and it reconciles these problems you are having with "choice versus grand design". I suggest you pick up a book entitled, "The Science of Mind". It is very similar to Christian Science, but it goes deeper. The idea is that God's "law" is eternal with God, and yet, is a part of God also. This law does not have firm grasp at everything the universe does, obviously. It sets everything in motion. By God's law, God shares with us the power to make choices by loosening his grasp on how things play out. God knows that which will happen because God is beyond the limitations of time. God is already present at all times. He is eternal. Therefore you are attempting to affiliate a finite concept of time unto an infinite being of eternity.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
If god knows the future, then he could NOT be all-powerful. To be so is impossible. You cannot have both.
To add to what I wrote above........
God knows the future AND is all-powerful. This doesn't mean that he flexes his power to the fullest. He has no need to. He sets everything in motion. He puts the pieces on the game board. We roll the dice. And by His law we get our results. Not only is he "all-powerful". He has the power to share his power with us. He gives us freedom in our finite existence to choose "paths", as BaSICCally stated. If God flexed absolute power upon us there would be no reason for this discussion. We would have no choices and God would move us around like mechanical pieces. We would not have a soul. We would not share a part in the divine mind. We would have no conciousness of our own being as we do. If it is easier to reconcile this in your mind, my friend, think of it this way.......
remember what I always would state: By merely discussing God we are seperating him, in mind, from his "creation". God is as much external as he is internal. The only way we perceive anything is through our own minds. So, to look for this "external" God is a lost cause. Once, in our minds, we unite God with the rest of existence we see that it is no longer the idea of an external force putting his control upon the world. The world is another part of God. It is obvious that there are parts of God who are not fully conscious of their own being (all of us humans). We are a part of God which are made in the nature of self-discovery. We grow as a part of God eternally into the entirety of God.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
If god is all-powerful, can god create a square triangle?
Sure. But the question is, can you conceive of one?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
Or how about a married bachelor?
sure. These are all opinions. they are concepts we created. God is not limited by them. So, why attempt to ask God to create something which contradicts itself in our eyes. We will not understand it.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
Could god create something so heavy that even god couldn’t lift? But what if he wanted to?
This is a classic atheist phrase. God is not bound by your thoughts of physical properties. He cannot create things which he cannot lift. He is beyond the physical world. But, knowing that we are all a part of God's whole; We are all a part of God, you must specify which part you are asking could pick it up. I can create something I cannot pick up by myself. But, I alone am not God, merely a part. If you mean for the entirety of God (all existence) to create something in which the entirety of God cannot lift then you might as well ask infinity to pick itself up. (LOL) Its also like asking the infinite to create another infinity. YOU CAN NOT ADD TO INFINITY! there is no infinity plus one. This does not compromise God's power because God is already infinity. There are no boundaries. So to imply God to not be all-powerful because he cannot create another infinity is ridiculous thought. There is only one infinity! Don't let your finite mind delude you. By implying that God should have the power to create another infinity you are underestimating what infinity really is, INFINITE! We can not perceive of infinity in its entirety because we are not its entirety. So, the only thing you can be worried about is your own growth into this infinity. God will forever hold paradoxes in our finite minds. I will end this paragraph with one single phrase: God can not go against his own nature.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
There must be some limits even to god; therefore he could not be all-powerful.
no limits to God. Just limits in your perceiving God. Do not be confused when you attempt to ascribe finite concepts to the infinite. You set yourself up for that.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
If god truly is all knowing, then why should some humans be punished for what he created?
By law. I already explained the nature of God's law above. He has this law, you can call it the law of cause and effect, if you wish. The Law, where he does not hold firm grasp in our growth, but lets us make choices and reap what we sow under this law. GOD SHARES POWER.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
quote:
If god knows all, then he would have known I am Atheist before I was even created, it was god that made me an atheist. It was never my choice. Same goes for a serial killer, rapist, Jew, Muslim, etc.
God gave you the choice to become an atheist under his law. Once again, God shares power. If God could make everyone one religion then we would be mere mechanical forces of nature without "nous". ("nous" is Greek for "reasoning mind" especially "divine reasoning").