The winner of last winter's Jody Reed Award (turning down a big contract, then settling for something much less), Molina fell right back to his normal self at the plate in 2006 after his career year in 2005. He's a 20 runner with a slowing bat and a body that is not aging well, and he's approaching replacement level as a hitter. After years of building up a reputation as one of the best defensive catchers in the game (or, at least, one of the best-throwing catchers), Molina threw out just 18 percent of runners in 2006, looking very slow getting up out of the crouch and into throwing position. It could be a one-year fluke, or a result of working with different pitchers, but given how his body has gone south on him, it has to be a red flag for potential suitors.