Dhadnot said:
No I'm not because I said they should get punished accordingly...but if you care so much about justice and law, why aren't you arguring for tyhe right to be judged by your peers (which the boys didn't recieve)? What that boy and the others who helped in putting up nooses aimed at the blacks, on school property is illegal and considered hate crimes, why aren't you talking about that? All you are talking about is the boys whipping that dude's ass...what about all the blacks and Mexicans who are assaulted everyday and stomped out and shit and the assailants get away with out doing shit, but this whiteboy is special? He didn't have any life threatening wounds, he got beat up cuz he feels he can disrespect a whole race and now 6 non-adults are facing 22 for attempted murder, give me a fuckin break.
I said it before that the hanging of the nooses was WRONG. But does hanging a noose = physical harm. No it doesn't. It's wrong, but it ain't the same as physically harming someone. They should ALL get punished.
Even if he didn't have any life threatning wounds, the fact is that "there could" have been life threating wounds.
I'm not sure if it applies in every state, but there's a law where you take your victim as-is, even the weak, it's called the "Thin-Skull rule." For example, lets say you happened to pick a fight with someone who has a metal plate in his skull or other brain damage that you can't see or don't know about. So you fight him 1 on 1, he dies as a result of you punching his "weak" skull. Your liable for his death, even if you didn't know he had that metal plate or brain damage. It sounds fucked up, but that's the law, you take your victim as-is. It's basically a law to protect the weak.
I see this case as similiar, the whiteboy is the weak because he's by himself vs. 6 other dudes. It's reasonaly foreseeable that death can occur when 6 is on 1. However, considering the racial circumstances that the whiteboy displayed vs. the blacks with the nooses and name calling, I think the punishment for the blacks needs to be lessened. 22 years is definitely rediculous. But my point is, for them to walk away with no punishment, that's wrong. Both parties should be liable. It just seems like everyone wants these kids to go FREE like they didn't do nothing. But the fact is, they did, they commited a violent act. They need to get probabtion, community service or at worse, their sentences shortened.