Eli vs Peyton - Which would you rather have on your team?

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.

Which QB would you rather have?

  • Total voters
    10
  • Poll closed .
T

Tony

Sicc OG
#4
May 15, 2002
13,165
970
113
47
#4
Eli because he's tougher, Peyton Manning wouldn't have won that game against the 49ers. The 49ers were beating Manning up and he hung in there. Peyton would've threw a few INT's and lost. There's no way Peyton would've won that game against the 49ers.
 
M

MooreBlock530

Sicc OG
#7
Aug 9, 2006
6,298
56
48
36
#7
eli now, peyton is better tho, even if eli wins more superbowls then big bro....peyton is the better overall qb. if they were the same age healthy. side by side....thats not the case now tho, peyton is a big hit away from a career ender


and @tony, peyton hardly ever gets hit hes always one of the least sacked qbs in the leauge year in year out, not because of some amazing o-line work either
 
T-Rip

T-Rip

T Camp
#8
Jan 18, 2006
14,367
6,557
113
43
#8
I guess people didnt notice that when Peyton is out for the year Colts go 2-14. When Brady is out for the year Patriots go 10-6 proving who is much more needed and relied upon between them 2. No way Eli is better, theres no comparasin
 
T

Tony

Sicc OG
#9
May 15, 2002
13,165
970
113
47
#9
MooreBlock530 said:
eli now, peyton is better tho, even if eli wins more superbowls then big bro....peyton is the better overall qb. if they were the same age healthy. side by side....thats not the case now tho, peyton is a big hit away from a career ender


and @tony, peyton hardly ever gets hit hes always one of the least sacked qbs in the leauge year in year out, not because of some amazing o-line work either
Click to expand...
Peyton gets rattled when he's hit or sacked.... you pressure Petyon it's over.

I'd take Eli because he's tougher, if that was Peyton gettin' hit like that in San Fran, the Giants don't win that game because Peyton would've thrown a few picks.
 
corinthian

corinthian

Just Win Baby!!!
#13
Feb 23, 2006
5,704
1,257
113
42
3rd ID
#13
Tony said:
Peyton gets rattled when he's hit or sacked.... you pressure Petyon it's over.

I'd take Eli because he's tougher, if that was Peyton gettin' hit like that in San Fran, the Giants don't win that game because Peyton would've thrown a few picks.
Click to expand...
I got a lot of respect for eli for the way he plays the game, but he did throw some picks. the niners secondary just kept taking each other out while trying to catch the ball. shit was lightweight comedy.
 
Ike Turner

Ike Turner

CDCR_#k775281
#14
Jul 17, 2011
1,056
174
0
43
South San Jose
#14
I would have to pass on both of them. Peyton is a damaged and refurbished goods, which makes him not dependable. He's passed his prime, and already has one foot in the wheelchair. And the problem with Eli is his mental handicap. he stutters and makes retarded funny faces. Team mates constantly complain about not being able to understand wtf he is saying in the huddle. if i had my choice of quarterbacks, i would pick Jamarcus Russel or Elvis Grbac
 
KrazeeRDM

KrazeeRDM

Sicc OG
#17
Nov 7, 2006
7,383
36
0
39
#17
Eli easily since peyton isnt even sure about how healthy he is and no1 knows how long he got. if they were both starting off at the same time it would be peyton without question. it's without question peyton was the better QB always, if peyton had half the team eli has around he would go 18-0 twice lol.eli isnt even the reason why the giants are winning so all credit cant go to him and i dont think he'll ever be considered the better manning.
 
Meta4iCAL

Meta4iCAL

Raider Nation
#20
Feb 21, 2005
19,635
4,278
113
37
#20
at this point in their career, Eli, obviously... just based on age and health

however, if they were the same age and both healthy... Peyton

people tend to live in the moment. Eli is playing good football and Peyton hasn't played for over a year, so people are gonna go with what they've seen lately. however, Peyton >>>> Eli, period. Nobody would even think about Eli over Peyton last season
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom