David Carr might be available...should the 49ers sign him?

  • Wanna Join? New users you can now register lightning fast using your Facebook or Twitter accounts.

Tony

Sicc OG
May 15, 2002
13,165
970
113
47
#1
CHARLOTTE – It’s time to begin trimming the fat from NFL rosters.

The Carolina Panthers, like other teams around the league, are free to begin releasing unwanted players Monday morning as the NFL waiver wire picks up. The cuts will come for various reasons – age, overall ineffectiveness, injury concerns and high salary cap figures.

After finishing 7-9 in 2007 and failing to make the playoffs for a second straight season, the Panthers are likely to see plenty of turnover. As owner Jerry Richardson said last month, the Panthers can’t afford to have a “ho-hum” off-season.

That means the team will be looking to make changes. And to make room for the new, the Panthers in many cases will have to part with the old.

And while the cuts won’t all come Monday – and, in fact, some may takes weeks or months to make as the team makes certain it has a replacement in place – you can bet the Panthers roster will look very different when they report to training camp in July.

That said, here are a number of players who should be a little concerned with their job security over the off-season:

QB David Carr

Reasons to cut him: Carr looked frightened in the pocket and his teammates quickly lost all confidence in him. By the end of the season coach John Fox was even afraid to play Carr, demoting him to third string. With a cap figure of more than $4 million, keeping Carr would be, well... ludicrous.

Reasons to keep him: Can’t think of any.

My take: To me, this is easiest cut in franchise history. I would anticipate the team will waste little time parting with Carr.
 

Tony

Sicc OG
May 15, 2002
13,165
970
113
47
#4
Shaun Hill, Alex Smith, Trent Dilfer... y'all don't think adding David Carr would open or add to the competition they have at qb?
 
May 17, 2004
2,574
2
0
41
#5
with that logic lets sign Weinke too. Adding more shitty qbs isnt gonna make one qb do better. i guess the qb who looks the least like shit can be the starter.
 

V

Sicc OG
Apr 25, 2002
5,308
137
0
40
#9
  • V

    V

HELL NO!!

for some reason I always wated Carr to succeed in NFL...he was super week with the texans...Thought it might just have been the o-line and him gettin sacked somethin like 65 times a few years ago...but he sucked just as bad in carolina...

lmao @ that wienki comment...niners did sign him and the end of the season with smith/dilfer/hill were all hurt...yea it was pretty bad.
 
Apr 26, 2003
10,869
16,112
0
60
East Oakland, USA
#10
I trust mike martz to find us a QB, either free agency or draft.

Carr, weinke are both worse then smith or hill.
like hell he is the niners are stuck with smith theyve invested waaaay too much time and cash into him to replace him with anoth$er qb, expect smith to stay until he gets hurt bad enough not to come back, or to run whatever contract he has out
 
Apr 26, 2003
10,869
16,112
0
60
East Oakland, USA
#16
Trent Green is goin to be released, if anything the 9ers should get him, hes good and has plenty of exp.
the niners dont specifically need exp right now, they need a beefed up O-Line, and young quarterback development be it hill or smith, its dumb to stick some old ass qb in there now, its time for smith to step his shit up or look for greener pastures
 
Aug 7, 2003
6,046
1
0
#19
like hell he is the niners are stuck with smith theyve invested waaaay too much time and cash into him to replace him with anoth$er qb, expect smith to stay until he gets hurt bad enough not to come back, or to run whatever contract he has out
umm, they could cut him right now and take a $5 million salary cap hit. but why cut him? he's already under contract and is a 2nd string qb that might be able to turn into a solid starter with martz. and time invested into him? tahts like every player on the team has time invested into them doesnt mean they wont get cut or traded. just there isnt much out there to replace smith with. as there are several other teams looking for qb's too. the 9ers difiently arent stuck with smith but would be unwise to cut/trade him.
 
Apr 5, 2005
4,271
1
0
42
#20
Fuck David Carr....dude is a loser.....a loser on Texas and a loser as a backup on Carolina......I'd rather the Niners stick with Shaun Hill. Lets give this man a shot. He played well enough to be a starter in the NFL.