First, I would just like to state that MMLP and The Eminem Show are both classics imo but I would rank MMLP above Eminem Show.
So let me see if I fully understand your statements. You're saying that The Eminem Show totally ruined hip hop and that he started some form of "emo" rap music. So if he's rapping about his life and his struggles and this is "emo," what the hell does that make every other rapper that has made music about their life and struggles?
So let me see if I fully understand your statements. You're saying that The Eminem Show totally ruined hip hop and that he started some form of "emo" rap music. So if he's rapping about his life and his struggles and this is "emo," what the hell does that make every other rapper that has made music about their life and struggles?
1) he made a rap album firmly rooted in emo-music aesthetics; this is a very different statement from criticizing someone for rapping for his struggles in life. Pay attention to the exact words, I usually pick them carefully
2) he suck as a producer - his beats have nothing to do with hip-hop - but because he was so commercially successful, the style caught on, and we had to endure almost decade of arythmic, amelodic, painful for the ears beats.